picked it up over the weekend, listened three times just yesterday. it's good. very good. the choice to use the upright bass was a perfect one, if you ask me-- especially when dunn uses the bow. and i love love LOVE the fact that they didn't use any bass amps -- it sounds so much more natural when it's just a mic. i like when you can hear the room.....
i don't think it's better or worse than any of the BB lineup stuff. it's just... a little different. different is good.
a lot of the production of the bass and drums reminds me of primus... this is not a bad thing at all.
great album. can't wait to see it live.
oh, also-- does anyone know why buzz stopped using les paul guitars? that's my only complaint: those aluminum guitars make his tone seem kinda thin. it's not awful, but i much prefer the big heavy melvins guitar sound.