the themelvins.net Melvins canon

[Erikkerik]

Lets make a melvins canon.

Buzz has his list (from the Stockholm interview), 5 albums + 1 song:
- Eggnog
- Stag
- COD
- Pigs of the roman empire
- a senile animal
+ nightgoat

Post your list and in two weeks we ad them all (ignoring Buzz) up and find the final list.

Mine:
- Bullhead
- Honky
- The maggot
- Lysol
- Houdini
+ Charmicarmicat

Pardons if this is a stupid idea, but lets do it anyway. Feel free to change your list during the voting-period.

[glen]

help a poor dumb-ass out and kindly explain to me exactly how this works.

[norecess]

Those Norwegians again... I think he means we should all post our five favorite albums plus favorite song, make a stock-taking, and then make a final list, also known as our canon. Am I right, Erik?

[Erikkerik]

Those Norwegians again... I think he means we should all post our five favorite albums plus favorite song, make a stock-taking, and then make a final list, also known as our canon. Am I right, Erik?

you`re right.

But, to clarify, the single song in your personal list is supposed to be one not from the previous five albums. The final list will be composed by the 5 albums with most votes and the single song with most votes that is not on one of the 5 albums. I can see why this is confusing and perhaps it would be better to just stick with five albums but I followed Buzz`s model.

get it?

[Lunica]

I don't get it either, maybe I'm not Norwegian enough. But I would think making a poll would be easier? It would save you from a lot of work, Erikkerik. What if the song is from one of the albums? That means its already there, doesn't it?

[Lunica]

Ok, thats pretty strange, cause the song you'll pick, is most likely not your favorite melvins song (I'm guessing your favorite song is on one of the albums you pick? If you even have one). So I don't really get the idea about this, other than doing something like Buzz did it. Oh well

[norecess]

Pardons if this is a stupid idea, but lets do it anyway.

OK

- Gluey Porch Treatments
- Eggnog
- Lysol
- Honky
- Pigs of the Roman Empire

+ At The Stake

[glen]

-ozma
-HAT
-the maggot
-lysol
-honky

+hag me

[norecess]

+hag me

Of course.

[glen]

+hag me

Of course.

even got you to rethink yours!   

[norecess]

+hag me

Of course.

even got you to rethink yours!   

It's At The Stake now. Your Blessened is another serious candidate.

[Erikkerik]

So I don't really get the idea about this, other than doing something like Buzz did it.

Well you get the idea then

[Schnabster]

Schnabster understand the semi-Bergen Erik perfectly, and throw out the following list:

Ozma
Lysol
Maggot
Houdini
Bootlicker
+Pink  Bat

Come on, Lun, shall grandpa Schnabster explain? 

[TommyHC]

Stag
The Bootlicker
Honky
Hostile Ambient takeover
The Maggot
+ A Vast Filthy Prison

[rimb]

- Lysol
- Pigs Of The Roman Empire
- Bullhead
- Stoner Witch
- The Maggot
+ Hag Me