So far I like all the stuff with Big Biz better than old Melvins
Just wondering if anyone else agrees. Anyone?
Every time I put on GPT I can't help but thinking 'goddamn! they were goddamn peaking here!'.
I like to think about it like this.
The Melvins were completely different people then. The music was completely different, and will always continue to be completely different. I don't think they're ever compelled to record another album that sounds like Gluey or Ozma or Houdini or Stoner Witch, so comparing old and new is kind of pointless, when all that really matters is what is yet to come.
The classic Melvins sound has been copied many times, and they continuously show an ability to grow and change beyond anything ever expected from them, without emulating some other style completely. Buzzo's guitar work is better than it's ever been, in my opinion. He's always come up with odd and catchy rhythms, but the riffing has become even better, more "standard" yeah, but still incredibly original and captivating. Civilized Worm and Billy Fish are probably my favorite examples of this...
But yeah, I am a relatively new fan, so I guess I've experienced the Melvins differently than most of you old farts and look at it with a relatively fresh viewpoint. I'm just eager for what the future brings and less worried about "the glory days."