Long term investment?

Started by Dr.Benway, August 07, 2008, 04:03:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Dr.Benway

First let me say I'm a Melvin's fan and collector, part of what I like about the band is they pay so much attention to the artwork/ collectable side of things.  But I wonder what the chances are that any of this stuff will keep its  value?  Neither Here Nor There hardcovers are apparently going for big bucks, Melvin's vs. Minn. is already going for double list price, not to mention the prices for the old vinyl singles and such.  But, in say 20 years, will anyone care?  Or by then will this stuff be through the roof?  I somehow can't see my son taking NHNT or Alive at the Fucker Club to Antique's Roadshow and being told "you've got a real gem there". 

FartLips

Judy is mad.🤣

spunkmonkey

I think some of the rared stuff will retain it's value (some 7"s, the 8-track, a few of the posters) but I don't see being able to pay for college for anything down the road.

anaconda

Melvins will still be playing in 20 years, someone will care.

nothintothenotice

i think it will be relevant forever....some people will always want this stuff.....i myself will probably never sell it....it means the world to me...and i will hand it down to my daughter or son....so...i wouldnt even think of it as a investment....that doesnt sound like a collector to me

Chomas

its like they say...

if you need to ask, well then...

the Melvins will be looked at by historians as we look upon all the greatest artists that ever lived

turnacus

I doubt it.

Unless we get off our asses, start successful bands, and praise the shit out of the Melvins. Mastodon plays the Bit, what are you doign?
Van Hagar

gesundheit

I know my Salad of a Thousand Delights will be worth something someday..I've had this DVD since '92 man!

anaconda

I know you're kidding, but I have held onto my complete
Melvins cassette collection for years now as an investment

BUT ID RATHER GIVE THEM TO MY GOOD BUDDY BHM.

Dr.Benway

I maybe phrased it the wrong way.  I don't mean the purpose of buying this stuff is the eventual reselling for profit.  I mean, the Melvins won't be getting into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, it was rightly said not too many bands with the majority's ear are talking about the Melvin's. What will come of the band's long term legacy?  Face it, the Melvin's aren't the Beatles in terms of popularity.  John Lennon writes a phone number on a matchbook in 1965, and in 2008 collector's will pay big bucks for "a piece of history". I guess I was trying to find a nice way to say are we ever  going to kick ourselves for having that "I've got to have it no matter what it takes mentality" when it comes to Melvin's collectables.....I know, more I try to explain, the worse I'm making it for myself

Pelican

Vincent Van Gogh sold one painting in his lifetime. Now his paintings are among the most expensive ever painted. What does that mean? Nothing.

Like anyone who knows anything about anything will tell you, never collect art (or anything else) as an investment. Collect what you like, when you can afford it. If you're lucky it will go up in value. If it doesn't, oh well, you've got something cool that you like so who cares?

The best thing the Melvins have ever offered is a live performance. So collecting memories is going for $25 a pop now, not too shabby.

FartLips

Quote from: Dr.Benway on August 07, 2008, 08:22:57 PM
I maybe phrased it the wrong way.  I don't mean the purpose of buying this stuff is the eventual reselling for profit.  I mean, the Melvins won't be getting into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, it was rightly said not too many bands with the majority's ear are talking about the Melvin's. What will come of the band's long term legacy?  Face it, the Melvin's aren't the Beatles in terms of popularity.  John Lennon writes a phone number on a matchbook in 1965, and in 2008 collector's will pay big bucks for "a piece of history". I guess I was trying to find a nice way to say are we ever  going to kick ourselves for having that "I've got to have it no matter what it takes mentality" when it comes to Melvin's collectables.....I know, more I try to explain, the worse I'm making it for myself
don't remind me of beatles sigs. the wifey had a first pressing meet the beatles signed by all four before their performance at giants stadium. daddyinlaw took out the trash. :( :( :( :( :( :(
Judy is mad.🤣

perusha

Who cares?

I tend to buy some of the collectors stuff from the Melvins.  At least the music and some of the art.  I don't buy the Nike shoes or the weird dolls or belt buckles or cigarette lighters or whatever else they sell. 

But the music and art I like.  I love it now, I loved it 20 years ago, I'm very sure I'll love it 20 years from now.  So there is the investment.  It's a great investment.  I don't want to resell any of it.

Brooklyns Finest PoonTang

Quote from: Dr.Benway on August 07, 2008, 08:22:57 PM
I mean, the Melvins won't be getting into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

Not like I give a flying fuck about the R&R HoF, but I wouldn't be surprised if the Melvins eventually get in there. Sure Rolling Stone Magazine (and Jann Wenner) bankroll that place (and we all know how Rolling Stone pays close attention to the Melvins every move), but lets face it: the Melvins spearheaded the grunge movement. That's serious history.
Quote from: cottoncrown on January 06, 2009, 07:17:08 PM
this is serious business here guys.  i don't want a tour of anyones chocolate factory please

glen

melvins will never be in the rock-n-roll hall of fame.
and thats just wonderful with me.

not that they aren't deserving. they just don't belong there.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN