Dale and Shrinebuilder

Started by benfromhell, January 12, 2009, 05:04:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

black stallion

Nagas sounded great. honestly my expectations with this project were too high and when the album finally came out, listening to it for the first time, i thought they could have done a lot better in matter of riffs.. i changed a bit my opinion after seeing them live, show was great.
Charmicarmicat:Bastards

vince furnier

Welcome to my Nightmare!

Israeli billionaire dies during penis enlargement surgery

Pelican

I think Shrinebuilder is a pretty good example of the problem with super groups. Each of these guys was involved in other very active bands and this project wasn't their main gig. I'm sure they were friendly with one another, but I don't know that they had any kind of working relationship with each other before this project.  I'm sure whatever time time they had to put it all together was super rushed. Then you take the fact that you're combining all these veterans who haven't worked with each other much and they're working out an album's worth of material in a short period of time, combine that with the expectations of fans who worship the bands they normally play in, and it's going to be hard to meet expectations. Not many super groups are all that super. I think the Traveling Wilburys might have done it best. I've always liked what I've heard from The Highwaymen and the videos I've seen of them performing, but I finally bought their album and it's not that great. The creative process is a funny thing.

I was fortunate enough to see Shrinebuilder twice. They killed live.

Bigval


surfling

Quote from: Pelican on February 15, 2020, 10:37:13 PM
I think Shrinebuilder is a pretty good example of the problem with super groups. Each of these guys was involved in other very active bands and this project wasn't their main gig. I'm sure they were friendly with one another, but I don't know that they had any kind of working relationship with each other before this project.  I'm sure whatever time time they had to put it all together was super rushed. Then you take the fact that you're combining all these veterans who haven't worked with each other much and they're working out an album's worth of material in a short period of time, combine that with the expectations of fans who worship the bands they normally play in, and it's going to be hard to meet expectations. Not many super groups are all that super. I think the Traveling Wilburys might have done it best. I've always liked what I've heard from The Highwaymen and the videos I've seen of them performing, but I finally bought their album and it's not that great. The creative process is a funny thing.
Couldn't have put it any better. They usually sound like a promising idea, but it's not enough to just have some fun together, it doesn't automatically make you come up with great songs too...
"Pop music is for sheep. And we are shepherds disguised as wolves."
(Laibach)

))))((((

Quote from: vince furnier on February 15, 2020, 01:53:43 PM
wow. didn't know about that one.
They played it live quite a bit. Originally it was much simpler and shorter but gradually it morphed into what it was in that video. It never had any vocals though. I like to think that would have definitely appeared on a future record.


There is this one too. Basically a Scott Kelly song that it seemed was earmarked for Shrinebuilder. Once the band went in-active Scott recorded it for one of his solo records.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqT45ZXvqGk



Quote from: vince furnier on February 15, 2020, 02:37:32 PM
'Sagan' backwards?
Ha! I never thought about that before!


Quote from: Pelican on February 15, 2020, 10:37:13 PM
all these veterans who haven't worked with each other much and they're working out an album's worth of material in a short period of time
One of the interesting things i remember from the album was hearing how each of them were NEVER all together at any point before they were in the studio recording it. Prior to the recording they had met in groups. So once it was just Al and Dale. Then some other time Scott and Wino. Or then Wino, Al and Scott. From what was said, it didn't sound like the material was made up excessively quickly. For instance the band was mentioned a good few years before the album came out. But then originally Shrinebuilder was only going to be Al, Wino and ex-Sleep/Om drummer Chris Hakius. So i suppose whatever those three had conceived was either reworked or ditched.

black stallion

wow, lots of info i wasn't aware of. thanks Ian

especially this

QuoteBut then originally Shrinebuilder was only going to be Al, Wino and ex-Sleep/Om drummer Chris Hakius. So i suppose whatever those three had conceived was either reworked or ditched.   
Charmicarmicat:Bastards

))))((((

Quote from: black stallion on February 16, 2020, 06:06:39 AM
especially this

QuoteBut then originally Shrinebuilder was only going to be Al, Wino and ex-Sleep/Om drummer Chris Hakius. So i suppose whatever those three had conceived was either reworked or ditched.   
Yes, Chris left Shrinebuilder at the same time as he decided to leave Om. It would have been interesting to hear what that original line-up would have sounded like.


This thread got me listening to Shrinebuilder again now!! You guys should check this one out if you haven't already. A longer more developed version of the album track.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oegACcki3VQ

Bigval

The Shrinebuilder album is Neurot's free/name your price album for the next week:

https://shrinebuilder.bandcamp.com/album/shrinebuilder

amazonAMAZON

Thanks for the tip. Bought!

Dumpster D


black stallion

Quote from: Pelican on February 15, 2020, 10:37:13 PM
I think Shrinebuilder is a pretty good example of the problem with super groups. Each of these guys was involved in other very active bands and this project wasn't their main gig. I'm sure they were friendly with one another, but I don't know that they had any kind of working relationship with each other before this project.  I'm sure whatever time time they had to put it all together was super rushed. Then you take the fact that you're combining all these veterans who haven't worked with each other much and they're working out an album's worth of material in a short period of time, combine that with the expectations of fans who worship the bands they normally play in, and it's going to be hard to meet expectations. Not many super groups are all that super. I think the Traveling Wilburys might have done it best. I've always liked what I've heard from The Highwaymen and the videos I've seen of them performing, but I finally bought their album and it's not that great. The creative process is a funny thing.

I was fortunate enough to see Shrinebuilder twice. They killed live.

totally agree



Quote from: Bigval on February 15, 2020, 11:22:00 PM
Quote from: Pelican on February 15, 2020, 10:37:13 PM
Not many super groups are all that super.

Fantomas

agree with this too
Charmicarmicat:Bastards