What is it about them that creates fanaticism?

Started by Reverend Ebeneezer, April 07, 2004, 08:41:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Just what have the Melvins 'got' that most other bands don't? I can't think of too many other bands that have survived my listening habits with such longevity and renewed joy. I mean, maybe it's the fact that they're the total outsider band that gives people something to cling to...maybe Buzz is Satan's henchman and makes us all addicts, I don't know. But maybe you do! So, guess away...if you want.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Vcavallo

well i guess they are right when they say they are the best band in the history of music.  actually i can think of many reasons for their following..don't really feel like using my brain too much now.  the melvins just have a ton of depth (see: neither here not there).  they have all sorts of merchandising mysteries and rare collectibles, oodles of singles, a freakin gigantic music catalogue, art exhibits in their honor, A BOOK.  they've just done so much, they are like their own nation of people with their own culture and history and laws, they aren't only a band.  plus they are completely original, and as you said, they are "outside" mainstream music, so it gives people like us another dimension to them, like they are all ours and nobody knows who the hell they are.  i think it is quite possible that the melvins and their REAL fans are all semi-elitists, and love to think they 'understand' something that others don't (whether it is actually understanding, or just taste is hard to say..like would everyone like the melvins if they 'understood' them and 'knew' them like us?)  i think that is all i meant to say but i feel like i am leaving alot out..i am also being sidetracked by an argument with el ex, which is a huge drain on creative writing.  that's my $0.02
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

The Stranger

Fuck, these guys make such good music!!!!!!!!!

Kurva

Just what have the Melvins 'got' that most other bands don't?

god so many things come to my mind i cant pick one


but........ theyre normal
theyre just like us: they fart, they shit, they belch etc....

..... i think so

anaconda

i think it's because theyve managed to keep it underground
for 20 yrs and yet still make a nice living.

Kurva

Quote from: anacondai think it's because theyve managed to keep it underground
for 20 yrs and yet still make a nice living.

yeah that too :)

i think everyone could come up with something...... something that makes melvins a unique band

Pringles

They are so fucking dark and heavy even after 20 year. There album from the 80' are more heavy than death metal of today.
Luck is a residue of design

nightgoat1978

SO MANY BANDS OVER THE YEARS HAVE FOLLOWED TRENDS, SOLD OUT, AND HAVE JUST GIVEN UP. WHAT IS GREAT ABOUT THE MELVINS IS THAT THEY REINVENT THEMSELVES EVERY 3 YEARS OR SO. I HAVE BEEN MIND BLOWN BY ALMOST ALL OF THEIR RELEASES. TO THINK THAT A BAND CAN GO 20 YEARS AND STILL KICK YOUR ASS IS AN AMAZING THING. I HAVE SEEN THEM 4 TIMES AND THEY NEVER GET OLD.

AS WITH MOST GREAT BANDS, THEY SUCK MORE AND MORE AS THE BAND GETS OLDER. MAYBE IT IS THE 20 BASS PLAYERS THAT THEY HAVE HAD THAT KEEPS THEM FRESH. BUZZ, DALE AND KEVIN ARE AMAZING AND TALENTED PEOPLE AND THIS BAND HAS ONLY JUST BEGUN TO DOMINATE THE MUSIC INDUSTRY.

ALSO ONE OTHER THING ABOUT THE MELVINS IS TAHT YOU CANNOT PLACE THEM IN A CATEGORY. THEY HAVE 200 DIFFERENT STYLES THAT THEY RANGE FROM. WHAT MAKES ME REALLY SAD IS THAT THE ONLY BAND IN THE INDUSTRY THAT HAS GIVEN THEM ANY KIND OF PRAISE IS NIRVANA. i WAS NOT A HUGE FAN OF NIRVANA BUT I RESPECTED THEM. THEY MENTIONED THE MELVINS MANY TIMES IN INTERVIEWS.

LETS ALL HOPE FOR ANOTHER 20 YEARS FROM THIS BAND. THEY WILL STILL KICK MORE ASS THAN ANY OTHER BAND EVEN IF THEY ARE IN THEIR 60'S. bUZZ WILL BE A SICK MAN EVEN WHEN HE IS ON HIS DEATHBED!!![/quote]

anaconda


rimb

Quote from: nightgoat1978...WHAT MAKES ME REALLY SAD IS THAT THE ONLY BAND IN THE INDUSTRY THAT HAS GIVEN THEM ANY KIND OF PRAISE IS NIRVANA. i WAS NOT A HUGE FAN OF NIRVANA BUT I RESPECTED THEM. THEY MENTIONED THE MELVINS MANY TIMES IN INTERVIEWS.

T00L praise them.

bUcKsAtAn

Quote from: rimb_38
Quote from: nightgoat1978...WHAT MAKES ME REALLY SAD IS THAT THE ONLY BAND IN THE INDUSTRY THAT HAS GIVEN THEM ANY KIND OF PRAISE IS NIRVANA. i WAS NOT A HUGE FAN OF NIRVANA BUT I RESPECTED THEM. THEY MENTIONED THE MELVINS MANY TIMES IN INTERVIEWS.

T00L praise them.

yup.  without tool, this would be a conversation with me and a cool music fan

fan-"hey, have you heard of the melvins??"
me-"no"

Galvano

Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerSo, guess away...if you want.

Don't have to guess, it's obviously because of Dale's speedos.

Andy

Quote from: Galvano
Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerSo, guess away...if you want.

Don't have to guess, it's obviously because of Dale's speedos.

That and Buzzo's cool hair!!!!111!! :lol:
For your health!

beee

slipknot's drummer is a melvins fan !  :P
(not kidding)

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: beee54slipknot's drummer is a melvins fan !  :P
(not kidding)

He claims he's into any band with any shred of underground credibility. Frankly, sometimes his namedropping just seems pathetic...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...