what would be the chances

Started by Brooklyns Finest PoonTang, April 16, 2004, 10:46:36 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic.

beee

beto is right! Do NOT ENCODE TO MP3 :(

Andy

Quote from: beee54beto is right! Do NOT ENCODE TO MP3 :(

It's ok, I won't be now that I actually read the text file that came with it.

I still don't quite understand why I can't though if I was only going to send it to one person and then delete it.

Could send the shn files I guess
For your health!

beee

check sharing the groove to know why you shouldn't do that, but you can do it and not tell anyone :)

Eponymous

Feel free to convert it to whatever you like for your own personal use but do not trade them.

The problem is that these are available in LOSSLESS formats but people start trading them as MP3s etc. What happens is the trading pool gets diluted. Years down the track you might trade for audio CDs but they could have been made from MP3s, and you won't know until you get them. This sucks. If people don't convert them to MP3s (or any lossy format) this will not happen.

Kind of like pissing in the gene pool.

anaconda

mp3s DO NOT sound that bad, especially with the mixing option in
iTunes. cmon guys the loss is so minimal it's not worth mentioning.

turnacuss

It may not be as good, but its better than no music at all.

anaconda


Eponymous

If it is a good clean rip at a decent bitrate, then MP3s can sound OK.

The problems start when people burn those MP3s as audio CDs, then other people rip them as MP3s... etc

It is a lossy format.

Like JPGs.

And if it is a choice between MP3 and nothing, I will take MP3.
However, in this case, the choice is between a lossy format and a lossless format. Which would you prefer?

Beto Brasil

Quote from: beee54beto is right! Do NOT ENCODE TO MP3 :(

im with you man, and the Laws from Sharing the groove too!
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

Andy

Yeah, I read all the stuff and the fact that it's compressed audio means by the time that someone gets a third generation copy, say, the sound is clearly much worse.
For your health!

Beto Brasil

Quote from: AndyYeah, I read all the stuff and the fact that it's compressed audio means by the time that someone gets a third generation copy, say, the sound is clearly much worse.

yeah man of course!
if I and you download this SHN files, why the guys dont download too?
because yours connection is slow?i dont know, but , trade by airmail!
:shock:  :shock:  :shock:
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm