melvins + sonic youth album?????????

Started by <--hoax-->, April 19, 2004, 01:57:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Vcavallo

Quote from: Dr. GonzoHe inspired all that mainstream nu-metal crap.

well in all fairness, buzz inspired all that mainstream grunge crap.  which was crap. sheesh, he is even indirectly responsible for shit like puddle of mud, audioslave and creed.  i mean, scott stapp cites nirvana as a major influence, and we all know damn well kurt would have been nothing if he had never taddled around snorting buzz's farts straight out of his ass.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

The Piss-Machine

Quote from: Vcavallo
Quote from: Dr. Gonzowe all know damn well kurt would have been nothing if he had never taddled around snorting buzz's farts straight out of his ass.

Damn straight to that. Everyone cries about Cobain all the time, and granted, there were some relatively good songs 'in yuir u-tero', but as far as I'm concered it's just another dead junkie, without whom the modern rock radio might have been something completely different, and perhaps tolerable.

By the way, regarding patton; why doesn't any ever mention FNMs last album before the implosion? "Album of The Year" is a monumental tour de force of pop wonder. If my facticity is in line, I think Patton wrote most of that, insofar as they were disintegrating at the time (i.e. keyboard player = gay junkie). As far as I'm concerned, there are moments on that album that bitch-slap some of the stuff from Angel Dust and KFADFFAL.

Anonymous

FNM is good....but nirvana sucks??

Dr. evil says:  rright

again, warped musical perspective.

quick reference for some of those who apparantly need it-- here's a rough outline:


- classical:  mozart/beethoven/bach/hayden

- opera: mozart, rossini

- jazz:  m. davis, ellington, brubeck, armstrong

 (crooners:  sinatra, sammy davis, nat king cole)

-  blues:  bessie smith, muddy waters, bb king

-  rock:  beetles, stones, dylan, hendrix

-  country:  hank williams......

- folk: .....

- taking a shit

-techno.....

-rap.....


you fill in the rest

ya see, there's a whole heirerarchy...that most everybody agrees upon... and thats why ya can't say nirvana sucks...just cuz you don't like it.
i don't even care about nirvana, but still, it scares me when people don't really get it

Anonymous


anaconda


Anonymous

more smearing!



Quote from: anacondafag :lol:


says the guy with a picture of a dog with a tongue ring next to his name















that's me acting like patton.

anaconda

actually i love directors cut

and lovage, peeping tom, and some FNM
namely Angel Dust and King for a day

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: The Piss-Machine
By the way, regarding patton; why doesn't any ever mention FNMs last album before the implosion? "Album of The Year" is a monumental tour de force of pop wonder. If my facticity is in line, I think Patton wrote most of that, insofar as they were disintegrating at the time (i.e. keyboard player = gay junkie). As far as I'm concerned, there are moments on that album that bitch-slap some of the stuff from Angel Dust and KFADFFAL.

Then you'll perhaps be dissapointed to know that that "gay junkie" was responsible for a large proportion of Album of the Year. The majority of that record was written by Bill Gould and Roddy, largely because Patton wanted out of the band and only begrudgingly produced any lyrics for it, Mike Bordin didn't really come up with songs anyhow and Jon Hudson was hired too late. I'm not saying it's not a great record-I love some moments off it, but it's very VERY bland in places and what kind of career ender is fucking 'Pristina'?!? Christ...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Jess

Quote from: The Piss-Machinebut as far as I'm concered it's just another dead junkie.

come on man, another dead junkie?  if you think cobain is the only junkie making music then you are wrong.  i don't like nirvana, but i don't like them cuz of there music not what kurt did in his spare time.  was hendrix just another junkie, or bonham?  being addicted to anything is sad but fuck man if you don't like druggies throw away all your albums, unless it's a fucking fugazi record.

Vcavallo

just for the record, I never said i don't like nirvana.  i just think it wouldn't've been what it was without the melvins.  i actually like nirvana alot, namely bleach and inscestide.  (is it possible to use two contractions? i.e. 'wouldn't've)
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

(PAUL)

What the hell did this have to do with Sonic Youth?
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

The Piss-Machine

The point I was trying to make, if memory serves was that I'm not going to cry about someone else's tragedy. I understand why it's supposed to be sad when someone is 'hopelessly' under something, I'm just not going to waste my time crying about someone elses misery. Combine this with the fact that (with the rare exception) Nirvanas output wasn't altogether brilliant IMO, and you've got a situation not worthy of hoopla.
The number of people who die of substance problems every day is probably something I'll never be able to fathom, why is Cobain any different from those that die on the street? Because he sold alot of records.
I suppose I'm bitter, I never could understand the idea of feeling that kind of 'concern' at the loss of someone who put themselves in a position to be lost.

Anonymous

um...i think he's different...because he's KURT COBAIN!
i don't think you're reading carefully

it doesn't matter what you think.  what matters is repeated critical acclaim

just as it wouldn't matter if i thought the beatles suck.

i personally think bob marley is very boring...but it doesn't matter!
i don't know how you can't understand that.  self centered, much?

i'm being mean because way too many people think this way

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: Anonymousum...i think he's different...because he's KURT COBAIN!

By that token do we have to respect, say, Nsync simply because they're celebrities and millions of people bought their records?
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Anonymous