Best Melvins album as of 2009

Started by Idlehanz, February 08, 2010, 10:18:42 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Vote for your favorite album  (studio albums & official releases)

Gluey Porch Treatments
2 (3.1%)
Ozma
3 (4.7%)
10 Songs
1 (1.6%)
Bullhead
7 (10.9%)
Eggnog
0 (0%)
Lysol (aka Melvins)
8 (12.5%)
Houdini
3 (4.7%)
Prick
2 (3.1%)
Stoner Witch
4 (6.3%)
Stag
3 (4.7%)
Honky
1 (1.6%)
The Maggot
6 (9.4%)
The Bootlicker
1 (1.6%)
The Crybaby
1 (1.6%)
Hostile Ambient Takeover
16 (25%)
Pigs of the Roman Empire with Lustmord
1 (1.6%)
(A) Senile Animal
2 (3.1%)
Nude With Boots
2 (3.1%)
Electroretard
1 (1.6%)

Total Members Voted: 60

Voting closed: March 11, 2010, 09:08:27 AM

Idlehanz

I've probably left something out.  I don't mean 6 songs, 8 songs or the Jelvins albums.  Or the re-releases.

I know I've included the Lustmord album.  I consider that a Melvins album.  

Vote for your favorite.  

This is open for 30 days from tonight.  Take your time and relisten to them.  

Yep, stuff has been left out.  I went for full band Melvins releases.





MrLuck87

Recently I did listen to all quite a bit and here is what I sent to Mark Prindle for his Top 3-7 survey.

ALL-TIME (favorite albums by any band)
Melvins - Hostile Ambient Takeover
Melvins - Lysol
Melvins - Nude With Boots
Mr Bungle - Disco Volante
Faith No More - Angel Dust
Flipper - Generic
Jesus Lizard - Liar

I could have put more Melvins albums but I figured I'd put some other bands on there.  Choosing between these three albums to me is like asking me what type of girl I'd rather bang; a blond, a brunette, or a redhead.  Can't I just have all three?

Answer: No.  I choose H.A.T.

I am the Sun

I voted for Hostile Ambient Takeover too. To call it the best Melvins release is a bit of a stretch, since all of the studio albums are great, but I feel that it's the one album that blends experimentation and songcraft the most seamlessly. The fact that it was the first Melvins album I ever heard probably has a lot to do with the way I voted as well.

Juan

Tough one......I went with Maggot due to AMAZON, Manky and Green Manalishi.

If it was top 5 it'd be.......

Maggot
Bootlicker
Stag
Honky
Bullhead

black stallion

i voted for Honky,although don't know if that's my very favourite album,it's in my top three though

Lysol
GPT
Honky
Charmicarmicat:Bastards

Idlehanz

Gee.....I got drunk and made a poll.  I don't remember what inspired this. 

Somewhere people were arguing about albums.  My head hurts.


Juan

Quote from: Idlehanz on February 09, 2010, 08:41:04 AM
Gee.....I got drunk and made a poll.  I don't remember what inspired this. 


You were inspired by Pitchfork.

It doesn't come much gayer than getting inspired by Pitchfork.........RESPECT!

norecess

one is too difficult, which is the whole point of  a poll of course. my top 3 is ever changing probably but will always include GPT, eggnog, lysol and POTRE at least.

EVILSTACK

1. The Maggot
2. Pigs Of The Roman Empire
3. (A) Senile Animal

ManWithNoName

Quote from: norecess on February 09, 2010, 09:12:02 AM
one is too difficult, which is the whole point of  a poll of course. my top 3 is ever changing probably but will always include GPT, eggnog, lysol and POTRE at least.
That's four!

I vote Hostile Ambient Takeover. Like everyone here I love all the Melvins releases and picking one is very difficult but HAT always seems to win. The artwork, the music. Everything about it is amazing.

norecess

Quote from: ManWithNoName on February 09, 2010, 09:50:26 AM
Quote from: norecess on February 09, 2010, 09:12:02 AM
one is too difficult, which is the whole point of  a poll of course. my top 3 is ever changing probably but will always include GPT, eggnog, lysol and POTRE at least.

That's four!

i know! and i didnt even include stag and the maggot.

molotov


>>>JZS<<<