Greatest Hits ?

Started by joshman, July 14, 2004, 10:59:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

joshman

This is my first post, so hello fellow Melvins fans.  I wanted to ask you what songs you feel should be on a Melvins greatest hits.  One of my fellow record store workers really liked Momibus Hibachi, so he asked me to make a greatest hits cd for in-store listening.  What songs would you deem worthy to be on a greatest hits compilation ?

Dr. Gonzo

The Melvins have a "greatest hits" CD called Neither Here Nor There.... It comes with the book

A track from almost every album including some from EPs.... it's actually a great track listing.... I was surprised how good the order was and what not. It's got a wide variety so one will able to get a picture of the wide area they cover.

But frankly, I hate fucking greatest hits / mix CDs.  I always just put in albums and lets em flow, or just play whatever tracks I want to hear at the time from different albums. Ha, hate referencing Metallica, but Lars said you had to listen to St. Anger as a whole to get an understanding... you shouldn't take away one song. I think that applies to almost every album.

Beto Brasil

Welcome to board dude!
:shock:  :shock:  :shock:
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

AlmightyRetard

1. Honey Bucket
2. At A Crawl
3. Mombius Hibachi
4. Teet
5. Candy-O
6. The Bit
7. Lacrimosa
8. Grinding Process
9. Magic Pig Detective
10. The Horn Bearer
11. Ever Since My Accident
12. Youth Of America
13. Operation Blessing
14. Dry Drunk
15. Little Judas Chongo
16. Echohead/Don
I like fucking corpses

Metalhead Cow

Quote from: Dr. GonzoThe Melvins have a "greatest hits" CD called Neither Here Nor There.... It comes with the book

A track from almost every album including some from EPs.... it's actually a great track listing.... I was surprised how good the order was and what not. It's got a wide variety so one will able to get a picture of the wide area they cover.

But frankly, I hate fucking greatest hits / mix CDs.  I always just put in albums and lets em flow, or just play whatever tracks I want to hear at the time from different albums. Ha, hate referencing Metallica, but Lars said you had to listen to St. Anger as a whole to get an understanding... you shouldn't take away one song. I think that applies to almost every album.

Do you like St. Anger? I'm not bashing you by the way-I love it.

Metalhead Cow

Oh, and I acctually made a imaginary live Melvins setlist, containing some of my favorites:

1.Eye Flys
2.Oven
3.Buck Owens
4.Let It All Be
5.Buck Owens
6.Hag Me
7.Dr. Geek
8.Hog Leg
9.Up The Dumper
10.Honeybucket
11.Ligature
12.The Brain Center At Whipples
13.Echohead/Don't Peice Me
14.The Anti-Vermin Seed
15.Revolve
16.Skin Horse
17.Youth Of America
18.Charmicarmicat

Let me know what you think.
Let

joshman

Those are many of the songs I thought of using.  In the end, maybe I'll just pick up Neither Here nor There.  I'm ashamed of myself for not picking it up yet.

Dr. Gonzo

Quote from: Metalhead Cow

Do you like St. Anger? I'm not bashing you by the way-I love it.

I don't hate it....  I'd gotten 100's of better CDs throughout the year though. My favourite songs were the Unnamed feeling and the last one that starts with a nice wah intro. Too bad Unnamed feeling starts with those gay vocals though It's probably their worst album to me, with black album in a close second.  But I don't even listen to Metallica anymore whatsoever.... caught em live couple months ago and meh, didn't really like the stage setup and it was arena rock (yuk).

I've only seen one good indie rock concert!!!!!!!!!! SUCKS

Eponymous

Don't forget, the Melvins do have a "best of" of sorts
Track Listing
1. Hooch
2. Lizzy
3. Honey Bucket
4. Set Me Straight
5. Pearl Bomb
6. Queen
7. Sweet Willy Rollbar
8. Revolve
9. Roadbull
10. June Bug
11. The Bit
12. Bar-X-The Rocking M
13. Tipping The Lion
14. Black Bock
15. Berthas
16. Honey Bucket (enhanced)
17. Revolve (enhanced)
18. Bar-X-The Rocking M (enhanced)



Yeah, yeah... I know.