Melvins bassist with best "stage presence"

Started by thegrumpylil'hermit, August 27, 2004, 02:09:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

thegrumpylil'hermit

ok, i know something like this has probably been done before, but im not talkin' technical abilities or contributions to the music.....just on-stage chemistry with the band.  I have yet to see live clips with Matt Lukin in the band(aside from the Salad DVD), but im thinking he might be on the top of my list.  Joe Preston seems to fit in nicely on the Salad DVD....and what i liked about Mark D was that he just made the Melvins look even more like this band of oddballs....you've got this crazy Sideshow Bob looking character bopping about on stage caught up in his own world, some madman hidden in the back beating the shit out of the drums....and then to just completely throw everyone off.....the cowboy.

Metalhead Cow

Everyone compares Buzz to Sideshow Bob. I have no idea who he is, or what he looks like. Who is he?

I've only seen live footage of Melvins with Kevin and Joe (and Mike on Salad DVD).

TosT

Mike on Salad? that's Dale isn't it? drumming all weakly, in the bang my head clip... and Matt on bass.

I think Kevin looks the craziest, so he goes pretty well with them. i've only seen a couple short clips of them with Mark, so I can't speak too much for that, but from the interviews i've heard Mark seems to force the crazy a bit more, whereas Kevin seems to have a bit more crazy in the soul, you know?

oh, and sideshow bob is from the simpson's cartoon

___-----_____------_____

hmmmm   I think I'll go w/ rutmanis.  he's got this zen connection with the band.  very on. very tight.  he hits that teacher's bell that's on one of his bass guitars and you'll hear it throughout a 3000 capacity venue.  I love the guy for the melvins I hope he never leaves.
Beauty is a Rare Thing - Ornette Coleman


the bloat

I vaguely remember a show with Mark D and I was right below the band throughout the set so I was able to get a good look. I have seen the Kevin-era Melvins many times and eventhough Kevin is much more animated as he bobs his head around reminding me of a bird during a convulsion fit, Mark D stood still like a stature. I watched in wonder as he played the notes of Livitity staring out over the crowd, his eyes barely visible beneath the shadow of his 10 gallon cowboy hat. It was all very creepy and his expression never changed. It was if he was saying "Here we are, f*** you if you don't like it!".
My vote is for Kevin though.

klump

kevin is doing his mad dance with that dirty smirk...hes scary

exide

I would say Kevin Rutmanis has the best stage presence.Last time I saw the Melvins/Fantomas Big Band, Kevin ended the show slamming on a ride cymbal that he'd taken off Dale's drum set while doing this crazy chicken dance a la Chuck Berry across the stage.The crowd went nuts!

Metalhead Cow

Quote from: TosTMike on Salad? that's Dale isn't it? drumming all weakly, in the bang my head clip... and Matt on bass.

I think Kevin looks the craziest, so he goes pretty well with them. i've only seen a couple short clips of them with Mark, so I can't speak too much for that, but from the interviews i've heard Mark seems to force the crazy a bit more, whereas Kevin seems to have a bit more crazy in the soul, you know?

oh, and sideshow bob is from the simpson's cartoon

I meant Matt when I said "Mike"

Which character is he on the Simpsons? :shock:  :?

Metalhead Cow

Quote from: the bloatI vaguely remember a show with Mark D and I was right below the band throughout the set so I was able to get a good look. I have seen the Kevin-era Melvins many times and eventhough Kevin is much more animated as he bobs his head around reminding me of a bird during a convulsion fit, Mark D stood still like a stature. I watched in wonder as he played the notes of Livitity staring out over the crowd, his eyes barely visible beneath the shadow of his 10 gallon cowboy hat. It was all very creepy and his expression never changed. It was if he was saying "Here we are, f*** you if you don't like it!".
My vote is for Kevin though.

Whoa, they've played Lividity live?

Methadone Bus

Ironically, I was just having this conversation a few days ago....


I'd have to say it's Rutmanis. The first time I saw him live with the band (After seeing Mark D and Joe Preston) I was completely in awe of the way the guy performed.... As excited as I was to watch Buzzo, I couldn't stop looking at this crazy dude with a Butt-Head haircut, blowing kisses and spitting at the crowd... He's rock and roll to the max.....

Reverend Ebeneezer

I always liked the image that Mark brought to the band...a real air of randomness, although when Preston grew in that huge beard, he really did look quite odd. There's a pic on this site somewhere of the Melvins in about 92 and Preston looks like he's wearing a Klan outfit or something, with dark glasses as well as the beard. Looks like some kind of evil wizard...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

zium


klump

i think kevin sums everything up...
hes a really flexible bass player, and that dirty smirk just makes everything...well...dirty!

and im not talkin aguilera dirrtey...im talking about "this man has killed 26 people and is getting away with it, hes actually killing all of us now with his grin and dance" dirty look :)

Reverend Ebeneezer

Check out the piccie...doesn't Preston just look so damn menacing?

Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

zium