pigs of the roman empire reviews thread

Started by benton netty, August 30, 2004, 08:55:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

idiotboy


Joe Deutrom

Quote from: Dr. GonzoIt's true you idiot!
It's a store, every review is positive.
They're not gonna put bad reviews next to an album they're trying to sell.

Just go ahead and check every album on the site. Not one negative review.

Did they try to help the sales for Colossus of Destiny when it came out? If they did, this guy sure wasn't impressed with it and did not cook up his review of it to help boost its sales.

Dr. Gonzo


Joe Deutrom

Quote from: Dr. Gonzoyour name describes your posts...

Thats what I thought. Just answer the question. Was this reviewer in question, impressed with Colossus Of Destiny? It sure doesn't sound like it. And I don't know what is more absurd, to name yourself after a muppet or trying to be cool by referencing and name checking the burnout Hunter S. Thompson by calling yourself Gonzo. You need a hero.  

Andy

Quote from: Mr. Stu Pedd
Quote from: Dr. Gonzoyour name describes your posts...

Thats what I thought. Just answer the question was this reviewer in question impressed with Colossus Of Destiny? It sure doesn't sound like it. And I don't know what is more absurd, to name yourself after a muppet or trying to be cool by referencing and name checking the burnout Hunter S. Thompson by calling yourself Gonzo. You need a hero.  

:roll:  :roll:  :roll:
For your health!

klump

oh crap, someone needs to get laid here!
the testosterone is gushing here!

settle down! all of you!
shake each other hands and hug...


and then we can hold hans and sing cum bay aghhhiiewoprjpfipewrjiweiofuck
:)

Chomas

maybe they do embelish a tad on their reviews, but the new melvins CD is fucking nasty no matter who reviews that bitch

anaconda

nasty as in good? or nasty as in bad? (in your opinion)

Dr. Gonzo

ahahaha..... you're killing me man
Simpsons sucks btw. I'd rather reference Fear and Loathing than the Simpsons.

And I checked the reviews for COlossus and they're all quite positive dumbass.

http://www.stonerrock.com/store/info.asp?item_num=ATH-2099

Next time check before you make some gay "challenge".... or whatever it is you were talking about. I wasn't paying much attention.

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: blacksantaThis one comes from C. Troutman over at Stonerrock.com:





The Melvins. That name alone can be the deciding factor lately on whether it's a 'must have' or a 'must skip' album. I personally am a huge Melvins fan, but some of the so called 'noise' albums can be disappointing to say the least. They do their own thing. Plain and simple. No one can change the fact that 'Colosses Of Destiny' was one of the most disappointing albums for me to purchase, but I was immediately back for more with the records which followed. I have seen the writing styles morph from flat out punk rock to some heavy ass metal, as have most that have stayed put with this band through the years.

This album will consume you with it's opening track, 'III' as it's what the band has been more than capable of doing for years, and that's pummeling ones' ass. A standout track, will consume you and remind you of the first time you heard The Melvins, in which you may have decided : "This is some fucking heavy shit..."

The further descent into the darker ambient sounds which Lustmord brings to the table, shows the direction that the Melvins are not afraid to venture into. Mesmorizing. Dark.Trippy.Heavy.

Atmospheres quickly evaporate into some of the heavy familar Melvinesque sound we have all come to know and love alongside some unique approaches to experimental jams. Songs structures are prevalent as this isn't a 'noise' album, in one sense, as it is in another. 'Toadi Accerrato' delves into Pattonistic experimental beats reminiscent of a Melvins/Tomahawk jam. An epic masterpiece, the title track ' Pigs Of The Roman Empire' may be one of their strongest songs written to date. Osbourne has found quite the riff in which to take the opening trancelike intro and transform into a truly epic mindblowing experience. This 22 minute 'ride' through some of the trippiest trance may be the deciding factor in how you rate this album. For me, well, it was the dark undertones that I havent seen much from them in their past material that left them leaving an almost doomlike mark on me. Electronic fan I am not, but this works. It lays the groundwork for the crushing that follows. I am not afraid to say there may be some of the strongest songs they've done to this point on this release, and that is spanning alot of material.

I have to hand it to the Melvins for not being afraid to take it one step further and unload one of the most intriguing and heavy albums I've heard in quite some time. File with your experimental/ambient/drone albums...and put it right up front. This may be the masterpiece we thought we already got from them.



Maximum volume yields maximum goats..

Why don't you read this review again Hunter S. Muppet.  Especially where this guy is talking about Collossus. If you can take your eyes of the Simpsons. This is the review I am talking about okay. And after the two hours it's going to take you struggle reading the review over again, you can listen to your Houdini album once more alright there Johnny Depp.

klump


Dr. Gonzo

Quote from: Mr. Stu PeddDid they try to help the sales for Colossus of Destiny when it came out?

I responded with an answer to your "challenge", which was yes.
Let it go sonny... You Lose in your little "challenge"!

TosT

I finally got the fucking cd yesterday.

i love it. it's a work of art.


oh, and the production is top-notch too, i see what some people were complaining about, but in my opinion it falls only just short of brilliant. Great unconventional arrangement of the sounds and instruments in the mix, the different elements frame each other at different points in the songs/album, awesome stuff.
headphones or a good stereo are a must though, some songs didn't sound quite as good in my girlfriend's hyundai accent, ha.

TosT

haha

From omahapulp.com

MUSIC
PIGS OF THE ROMAN EMPIRE
By Jeremy Kruse
Aug 25, 2004, 14:39



Melvins + Lustmord
Pigs of the Roman Empire
[Ipecac Recordings]
Released: August 24, 2004

There is a good side and a bad side to everything. Sometime the bad is neccesary in order for us to keep a perspective on what good is, and allows us to better appreciate goodness when we experience it. Bad can be good.
Lately a lot of CDs have been coming my way that were good, or all right, but nothing very bad

Metalhead Cow