PIGS..I just figured it out!!!

Started by anaconda, September 04, 2004, 02:31:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

anaconda

It's almost sounding like a tool album! thats what Pigs of the...
makes me think of!! this CD is like a tool-alike phase of the melvins

am i close?  :?:

EGO the Living Planet

Not really. At least That's not what I'm gettin'.

anaconda

my apologies. but except for the 3 straight up rocking tunes,
the rest sounds like a tool album to me. a bit of opiate
here, a little lateralus there, the noodly segues on the virus synth

Dr. Gonzo

I just lost much respect for Anne.....
Sadly

Joe Deutrom

I think you went off the deep end here Conda. POTRE doesn't sound anything like Tool. And another thing, the Melvins wouldn't try to create anything remotely similar to Tool. Tool is not an influence of theirs to begin with. These are my opinions anyway...

anaconda

just in the repetitive sounds, the synth bass, the minimal vocals
and the production tone -  it has a spacey quality like lateralus,
even the cd artwork is lifted from lateralus for all you fucks who didnt
actually buy it!  its the same schematic drawing that they
used for that artwork. i stand by my opinion, goddamn any
last dissenter. whatever 8)

also, directly from the credits:
"Thanks to Adam Jones for making the introductions"
"Adam Jones: Guitar"

klump

i undertstand what youre talking about conda , ive been thinking about that to:) but i havent had the pleasure seeing all the artwotk yet...

since i STILL havent got my record yet! dammit! i ordered that sucker 29. july and i STILL havent got it ! damn amazon! someones gonna finda a head of some sort in their bed soon!....

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: anacondajust in the repetitive sounds, the synth bass, the minimal vocals
and the production tone -  it has a spacey quality like lateralus,
even the cd artwork is lifted from lateralus for all you fucks who didnt
actually buy it!  its the same schematic drawing that they
used for that artwork. i stand by my opinion, goddamn any
last dissenter. whatever 8)

also, directly from the credits:
"Thanks to Adam Jones for making the introductions"
"Adam Jones: Guitar"

Fine, you can stand by your opinions. I stand by mine. There is no disagreement here.

TOOL

I'm sort of with Conda here.  It certainly has parts that sound like Tool although I wouldn't say they sound like Tool songs.  Some sections of Pigs  are definately Tool-influenced.  Does that make sense?  I was also wondering if anybody else noticed the artwork.  You'd have to be blind not to see the resemblance.
There's a lot of things blamed on me that never happened.  But then, there's a lot of things that I did that I never got caught at.

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: TOOLI'm sort of with Conda here.  It certainly has parts that sound like Tool although I wouldn't say they sound like Tool songs.  Some sections of Pigs  are definately Tool-influenced.  Does that make sense?  I was also wondering if anybody else noticed the artwork.  You'd have to be blind not to see the resemblance.

I can understand what you and Conda are seeing yes. The CD artwork in my view represents the electronic atmosphere in the work therein. It's a schematic of some sorts I do believe. I don't think Mackie said "Hey, let's do it like Tool" and used it. The similarity is coincidental at most. POTRE is definitely atmospheric, so is Tool but to say it's the Melvin's Tool album, I have to respectfully disagree. If I get the chance, and I happen to get to talk with Buzz at one of the shows, I will ask his thoughts about this.  

Dr. Gonzo

someone should delete this thread...

And Tool is a big influence on the Melvins... That's a fact

grachan

Mackie's done Tool artwork before - it's a moot point.

the melvins

Quote from: Dr. Gonzosomeone should delete this thread...

And Tool is a big influence on the Melvins... That's a fact

or are the melvins a big influence for tool........... ehh EHHHH????
makes ya wondor... hmmm?
woo hooooo,
havent even heard pigs yet.

(PAUL)

I consider POTRE to be more along the lines of a modern Stravinsky album. And I see much more early industrial influence and even a little bit of Queens of the Stone Age as far as production goes (the part when the guitars first come in on Pink Bat come to mind there). I'm not saying they sound like QOTSA, I'm saying the production is similar. I guess I could see similarities with Tool, but the two are also very different in my mind, such as both bands have distinctive styles that are all their own.
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

Dr. Gonzo

ha....
THe Melvins are  a HUGE influence on Tool, and that's a fact