two questions for serious melvins fans

Started by Binkard and Friends, September 05, 2004, 10:25:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Binkard and Friends

im thinking about getting a live Melvins cd.


which one should i get, keeping in mind i LOVE older Melvins ('88-92). Your Choice Live Series, or Alive at the Fucker Club?


also, where would i find Altamont cds?

benton netty

the best live melvins i've ever found is the stuff that was posted on sharingthegroove earlier in the year. there was a soundboard/aud mix from the last tour, and one from 2003, and they were both excellent.

the your choice live disc was recorded in the early 90's, so that sounds like the one you'd like best.

klump

the your choice disc is the best if you like old melvins. and theres also a bunch of good concerts on soulseek etc.

Eponymous

Quote from: Binkard and Friendswhich one should i get, keeping in mind i LOVE older Melvins ('88-92). Your Choice Live Series, or Alive at the Fucker Club?
As they are both hard to find, I would suggest getting anything you can.  :D

Reverend Ebeneezer

Hard to find?!? They're both long deleted...Collossus is all you have left, man.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

zium

i thought this topic was going to be about one of the melvins mysteries, like what happened to lorie and whether they did drugs or not :D

there should be a thread with all these mystery questions and then get someone to interview them. it would be the greatest interview ever

klump


Dog Tired

Yeah, if you have the choice between both, either get both of em, but if you can only get one, get Your Choice, cause Alive at The Fucker Club is wayyyy short.


buckowens

trust me. alive at the fucker club sounds like shit...cool show, just shitty quality. but you would DEFINITELY like your choice live series if you like older stuff. also the sound quality is awesome. it's hard to find where i am, i had to get all my rare melvins stuff off ebay.

Andy

Quote from: buckowenstrust me. alive at the fucker club sounds like shit...cool show, just shitty quality. but you would DEFINITELY like your choice live series if you like older stuff. also the sound quality is awesome. it's hard to find where i am, i had to get all my rare melvins stuff off ebay.

Yeah both those cds show up on ebay once in a while. I quite like the sound of Alive at the Fucker club. Well the drums sound awesome anyway.
For your health!

Beto Brasil

Goods tours : 1990,1997 and 2000 .
goods setlists,and good recordings,some soundboards!
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

(PAUL)

There was some rumor that they might rerelease Your Choice Live on Ipecac, but who knows.
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

anaconda

the answer is simple, start at the beginning!
Your Choice Live comes first! Then Fucker Club
next, altho Fucker has a killer Mombius on it and Dales Kit
sounds like a monster beat on every song.. Mark D owns this one

Vow

To answer your second question. Civil War Fantasy and Our Darling were both released on Man's Ruin so they are hard to find. At eBay you have the best chance to get a (new) copy I guess.