NEVER BREATH WHAT YOU CANT SEE: Thoughts/Reviews

Started by klump, September 15, 2004, 06:07:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

thor

I did the AT mail order...

I agree...this is one of the more "listener friendly" Melvins releases in a while. It's good stuff, I like it a lot. (then again, I've liked almost everything that the Melvins have put out.)

I think it's really cool that the Melvins jam out with a lot of other artists/bands that I like.

The lyrics are definitely primarily Jello driven...political and social commentary abound.

Got my tix to see 'em in October!

-T
Bass player, recording engineer, Melvins superfan

benton netty

got the album on monday, and i've listened a few times through.

i don't really have much to say about it -- it's pretty much just straightforward 4/4 time punky hard rock music. it's actually not very melvins-y, save for the last song, "dawn of the locusts," which is essentially the little brother of "brain center at whipples." overall, the album's not musically very interesting, although it does have a good energy about it.

jello's vocals and lyrics are as strident as ever, no surprise there. the first song, "plethysmograph," is pretty good, as jello kinda growls in a lower register for much of the song. sometimes, though, you just want to punch him, when he starts the cliched liberal ranting about SUV's and shit. yes, jello, we know -- rich people spend money stupidly. you're not telling anyone anything new, buddy.

overall, i'd have to say that, as much as i dislike "pigs of the roman empire," i still like it in some way better than this album, because this album is kind of generic-rock sounding, and that's something i never expected to hear from the melvins. although jello wrote a lot of the music, so they're not totally to blame. but i'd rather the melvins take a chance and experiment than just churn out some rote riff-rock like AC/DC or something. and that's what this album sounds like, at times.

the sound quality is okay, if a bit muddled (dale's drums are buried for a lot of the album), but it seems to work fine for the type of music they're playing, here.

so, this isn't really a melvins album with jello singing. it's more like an average hard-rock album with jello singing.

i didn't have high hopes for this one, so i'm not too let down, but it's still an album i'll probably only listen to a few more times before shelving it.

hopefully we don't have to wait too long before the melvins do another "real" album, with no fucking guest star bullshit to muck things up.

this will go near the bottom of my own personal melvins album rankings, down there with "pigs" and "the crybaby." collaborators suck.

klump

this was a good old school punk record...i think it really compliments Pigs... :D

the only thing i think is sad is that dale always hides his bass drum sound :( you have to hold your breath to hear it!

klump

actually i think Pigs was made as a reaction on Never breath ( never breath was made before that) one strange, one "regular" = pretty ok for me :)


more now!!!

turnacus

Actually I thought that Pigs of the Roman Empire had a sister LP called like, Making Room For Puppies that was more Melvins focused or something.
Van Hagar

klump

hehe, that would be fun, if that wasnt just a funny little prank from the good folks at hippiecrack

steve

Quotehopefully we don't have to wait too long before the melvins do another "real" album, with no fucking guest star bullshit to muck things up.
Amen. 2004 is not a good Melvins year.

To me one of the great things about Melvins is that they were, until this year, one of the few bands where you could listen to their CDs all the way through without skipping crap tracks (well, except "Prick" I guess...).

Now we have "Pigs" which has some amazing stuff... but realistically most of us are only going to listen to 3 tracks (and even then, if you want the good bits some fast forwarding is necessary)... and the Jello CD which at least for me is 100% unlistenable because I am not going to listen to Jello Biafra's preachy liberal crap (or give him my money).

Then there was the Fantomas release which was (admit it) disappointing....

Here's hoping we get a full 100% music release before long.
...Steve

klump


TosT

crappy for you maybe, i like the fantomas release alot, and love pigs... i have yet to skip a track on it.

Jello's voice though.... i don't know, i have that one on order from the AT site, we'll see.

Leroy

The thing is, even if you guys don't like these new albums from the Melvins, at least you're helping them out by buying them.

steve

I am very happy to help the Melvins... and for that reason I will buy ANYTHING they produce, no matter how crappy it may be... but I specifically do not want to support Jello Biafra - there is no way he is going to get even 1c of my money. So if you tell me how I buy the CD and make sure JB does not get anything... please do so.  
:?
...Steve

TosT

Quote from: steveI am very happy to help the Melvins... and for that reason I will buy ANYTHING they produce, no matter how crappy it may be... but I specifically do not want to support Jello Biafra - there is no way he is going to get even 1c of my money. So if you tell me how I buy the CD and make sure JB does not get anything... please do so.  
:?

steal the album when it's out in stores, and then mail 10 bucks directly to Buzz :)

steve

I will definitely download it and send $10.00 to the Melvins...
...Steve

Eponymous

Quote from: steveI specifically do not want to support Jello Biafra - there is no way he is going to get even 1c of my money.
Why?