I miss this part of the Melvins

Started by (the) Razor, September 12, 2014, 07:38:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

(the) Razor

I think it's amazing a band can reinvent themselves over 30 years and still manage to not only retain their originality but still find new paths and still surprise even the most hardcore of fans. It's a credit to just how brilliant Buzz is at song writing and that Dale is easily one of the top drummers in the business. No questions on both accounts.

BUT there is one core aspect of the Melvins that seems to have disappeared over the last few years and it's a tragedy that needs to be highlighted!


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fyBa3U6KaJ8

The awkward time signatures and phantom drumming!

So many songs in the past were built around strange rhythms - all of your mum's favourites like Oven, Roadbull, Cow, The Fool. You can here the angst in those beats over the top of Buzz's filthy vocals.

Sure it works perfectly the other way too when it flows so well like Billy Fish and most of the modern Melvins catalogue. There was something, however, so unique about those strange rhythmic offbeats in the past that had all sorts of signature tricks like phantom beats that would suddenly turn into repetitive caveman drumming. Even after twenty years of listening to these songs I still can't manage to tap along accurately to Dale's drumming on Lysol or Bullhead on the steering wheel in the car, it's deadset impossible.

I can live without Mark D or Kevin in the band anymore, that's cool, as Jared and Coady destroy - but the odd rhythms is something I wish Melvins would still employ in their deep, deep bag of tricks.

If you don't agree with me, you're wrong. Go and put on Ozma or Bullhead you campaigner!
Don't click this

homeless_dad

It's tough to argue this point and I'm glad someone brought it up. Two songs may help to illustrate this argument.

Green Honey: it's a song that goes all over the place in only the most brilliant ways.  The time signatures are wacky, the drumming sounds like it skips a beat at time and utilities the snare in a peculiar way.  Very sharp, precise and heavy!

Your Blessend: It's all about the drumming. For me, it's like how razor described that after years of listening you still can't freely tap your fingers along to the beat.  I've pretty much gotten it down now but still mess up at times by adding an extra beat or what have you. 

And I love that about these songs and others of equal difficulty.  It's part of what keeps me coming back to them.  They are interesting and cerebral as well as ear pleasing. 

I don't necessarily wish for them to go back in time and regurgitate these songs and call em new.
Is Ian back yet??

meezer

I thought you were gonna say the Les Paul guitar tone. Again.

Sure, bring on some weirdo time signature type stuff. Why not?

You know what I wonder about? Every time I watch a video of Buzz
playing in foreign country, there's the old Marshall stacks.
And the video sounds good. I wonder if Jules or someone who has
seen them in the States and abroad has noticed a difference in that department.
I'm all for Buzz picking his own gear that he's happy with, but just wondering......

Sorry for rambling off topic, (the) raZor.
"Get off of our stage. If you want on this stage, get in show business." -King Buzzo
"Yeah, we don't come in the 7-11 where you work and get up on the counter." -Mark D
https://soundcloud.com/meezerpocalypse/nathalie-b20-driving-force-paploviante-cyclone-open-collab-meezerpocalypse-haboob-remix

black stallion

i think the albums with the Big Business guys have some weird time signature stuff...Dale seems to have changed his style a bit over the years though... Coady had a bit of an influence on his current drumming style in my opinion
Charmicarmicat:Bastards

Oscar

Quote from: meezer on September 12, 2014, 09:40:10 PM
I thought you were gonna say the Les Paul guitar tone. Again.

Sure, bring on some weirdo time signature type stuff. Why not?

You know what I wonder about? Every time I watch a video of Buzz
playing in foreign country, there's the old Marshall stacks.
And the video sounds good. I wonder if Jules or someone who has
seen them in the States and abroad has noticed a difference in that department.
I'm all for Buzz picking his own gear that he's happy with, but just wondering......

Sorry for rambling off topic, (the) raZor.

Never saw them in the States but on most Euro legs, they play their own backline which they store in the UK. Buzz's rig is essentially the same basic set up the US one. Sunns, Carver preamps, two Orange 412 cabs which in the US are replaced by his new custom Emperor 412+115 cabs.
The Marshall stacks you mentioned are rentals used for festivals and/or fly-in shows. They tend to sound a bit blander and less colourful compared to his usual sound. They still use their own condenser mics and all that, so the difference is marginal. I'd like to think that the Euro/US differences were a lot more noticeable back in the days when they didn't have their own backline in Europe. Going from the eloborate Sunn, Hiwatt, Carver, whathaveyou setup to straight Marshalls (sometime single cab) and Ampegs.


Here's an example:

http://youtu.be/XXarJpcqLvo

As opposed to this (just look at the friggin Hiwatt full stack on top of the Dietz 215):

http://youtu.be/s_Au0fRI6OE




Don't really know about Jared's setup though. He sort of always sounds the same to me.

Stonergrunge

I can't honestly tell a huge difference between those two videos since the audio quality of both are not very good, but I can say that this topic reminds me of Boris. I read somewhere that the band is extremely picky about their setup and they never rent backline, it's always the same no matter if they are playing in Japan, Europe or the US and they have tons of full stacks, Roland Space Echo units and so on.
cartoons, chocolate milk & rock 'n' roll!!
Fuzz is love.
Foot fetishism means love, because, it's the magic of feet odor... Long live depravation.

GrimReaper


Freak Puke has awkward time signatures and phantom bass playing. Revisit it with a good set of earphones.

With the double drumming it's got to be choreographed and practiced. But in exchange you get the crushing beats, intensity and high energy.

Dumpster D

Dont blame the band.

Theres just no thrash or sludge bands these days to Hybrid and still be relevant.

these records are there for you when you need them.

I really like this band because they DIDNT stick to one thing they were good at.

(the) Razor

Quote from: meezer on September 12, 2014, 09:40:10 PM
I thought you were gonna say the Les Paul guitar tone. Again.
Am I that predictable/  :lol:
No problem going offtopic, they're all good points.

Quote
I really like this band because they DIDNT stick to one thing they were good at.

It's not about heavy, or sludge or any of the past records because that's all been done and dusted I agree. You are cooked as a band if you start doing the same thing over and over again.
I just think that it is such a unique and signature element (one of many) of the band to have that strange almost comical drumming. Just sad to see that element of the band gone forever even in the one drummer setup in recent records.

Double drumming rules and it is an experience I'll never forget and all, but I doubt if anyone is not impressed by that Crover video )Melvins fan or not).

By the way, did anyone click the video and see who posted the first comment on YouTube?
Don't click this

GrimReaper

 
Mark D:

Those shows were really fun, and also a dream come true. Who wouldn't want to open for Rush ? They were absolute gentlemen, and actually liked the music. The audience was less than excited with us, but playing through Rush's PA was really something. Great memories.

And Billy Anderson:


Even in a stadium with 25,000 people, most of the booing-Dale retains control and brutality. ;) I was doing sound at front of house, and i swear i almost couldn't get the p.a. louder than the booing of Rush fans. Great moment in time. Billy



Oscar

Quote from: Stonergrunge on September 14, 2014, 10:47:09 PM
I can't honestly tell a huge difference between those two videos since the audio quality of both are not very good, but I can say that this topic reminds me of Boris. I read somewhere that the band is extremely picky about their setup and they never rent backline, it's always the same no matter if they are playing in Japan, Europe or the US and they have tons of full stacks, Roland Space Echo units and so on.

I only posted the videos for you to see the difference between backlines of the same era. Of course the only way to tell the difference sonically, would be to have been at two seperate shows in those days. It's impossible to tell by a Youtube video.

FartLips

Judy is mad.🤣

meezer

"Get off of our stage. If you want on this stage, get in show business." -King Buzzo
"Yeah, we don't come in the 7-11 where you work and get up on the counter." -Mark D
https://soundcloud.com/meezerpocalypse/nathalie-b20-driving-force-paploviante-cyclone-open-collab-meezerpocalypse-haboob-remix

(the) Razor

Yeah right? That was a great album. Although 99 Bottles is probably the only Melvins song I've never listened to. :lol:
Don't click this