An in-depth review of NEVER BREATH......from Pitchforkmedia

Started by the bloat, October 22, 2004, 11:00:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

the bloat

Here is a review for all of you to read who have not heard the CD yet, or  those of you who have, might still enjoy it.

http://www.pitchforkmedia.com/record-reviews/b/biafra_jello/never-breathe-what-you-cant-see.shtml

fearless1000


brian


cellphone


the bloat

Pitchfork is everything that's wrong with music???? Explain.

moorst

They actually do a lot to expose obscure bands, but they definitely have their own agenda, as far as the underground goes. I was exposed to Single Frame by them.

EGO the Living Planet

I don't know if I could say "everything that's wrong with music" 'cause ther's a fuck of a lot that's wrong with music that has nothin' to do with them but they are some boring, pretentious, long-winded fucks anyway.

cellphone

actually, music critics are everything that is wrong with music, period.

EGO the Living Planet

Music critics; not MTV; not Clear Channel; not major label buisness practices; not a proliferation of bands without the courage or vision to make anything beyond cookie cutter imitations of whatever is popular; not fans who don't know or care enough to explore beyond what's right in front of them  (just to hit the very tip of the iceberg) JUST MUSIC CRITICs. That's all that's wrong wioth music? Sorry man, I can't even joke about agreeing with that.

alnis

I enjoy music critics. They help me judge CDs that I have not heard of. I think the key is to not be an idtiot - just read critically.

BTW, I'm gonna have to disagree any umbrella negative phrase against critics, simply on the basis of the existence of Mark Prindle.

Alnis

TosT

Quote from: alnisI enjoy music critics. They help me judge CDs that I have not heard of. I think the key is to not be an idtiot - just read critically.

BTW, I'm gonna have to disagree any umbrella negative phrase against critics, simply on the basis of the existence of Mark Prindle.

Alnis

Prindle is SO wrong sometimes, but always fucked up and hilarious, great interviews too...

alnis

The thing about critics being wrong is that you can usually recognize this even before listening to the album. For example, if someone critizes an album for being too unstructured, or too repetative, etc. you can just mentally replace the word 'too' with the word 'pleasently'.

Alnis

groundmeat

In general I have found PFM doesn't know what it's talking about when it comes to Melvins. And it seems to prefer bands that are likely to get picked up  by 120 minutes or whatever the equivalent is - i.e. just a little better than what's on radio.

And as for the review, - I don't know about the 7.9 - I heard one song from the  album (Caped Crusader) and it was god awful. Easily the most boring crap the Melvins have done.

And biafra's naive pseudopolitical rants lose their charm after the first minute.

I bet the only reason the album got a 7.9 was *because* it was biafra.  

Anyone who has heard the whole album care to contradict me ?

groundmeat

And as far as music critics go, I have found the best way to get the most out of them is to look at how they reviewed albums you've already heard and use that to figure out if their review for something you haven't heard is going to be useful to you.

They are not entirely useless!

EGO the Living Planet

I don't know, I really dig the album (I am a pretty big Biafra fan though). I kinda thought 7.9 was low. I was thinkin' it would have been higher if either Jello or the MELVINS were some flash in the pan critical darling band. Bands that have been around more than 3 years seem to get slagged on shitfork every time.