What style are the Melvins better at writing?

Started by Leroy, November 22, 2004, 02:18:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Leroy

Are the Melvins better (skill-wise) at writing noise rock or straight-ahead rock?

Huey P. Newton

I'd have to say the rock. They are extremely good at both, but I think nothing can compare to the heavy ass rock they produce. Why don't you make this a poll?

Dog Tired

Why don't you ask Buzz? He seems like the man to know, and not us fans.

thrust_mcnaughton

Quote from: Dog TiredWhy don't you ask Buzz? He seems like the man to know, and not us fans.

Yeah! Call him up.
Where Rock Is Criminal, Criminals Rock!

Andy

Quote from: thrust_mcnaughton
Quote from: Dog TiredWhy don't you ask Buzz? He seems like the man to know, and not us fans.

Yeah! Call him up.

867-5309

Works in any area code.
For your health!

klump


FartLips

how about going to his house, since we know where he lives! (thanks klumpy! : P)
Judy is mad.🤣

Huey P. Newton

Poor Buzz.... you guys are just like Bob Dylan's stalkers.

gwiz

what are noise rock song you say?
hmmm...do you think Melvins make more 'noise rock' songs or 'straight rock' songs?
if noise rock are really dense songs, then i think they make more of those, and they are most known for that.
i prefer those songs to the "less packed" song but they are good at doing both.
songs like Let It All Be compared to Manky ... it think its perfection either way. i couldnt do without one or the other.

what do you think Leroy?


Beto Brasil

Quote from: klumpi just like good music :)
i love you !!  :D  :D  :D
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

nerker

i love both.
the best is the mix of the two, IMO.
like some the stag stuff.

Ron Maiden

i think the rock. the songs on Stoner Witch and Stag  are really great rock songs, but the noise stuff on Honky is my least favorite of their noise.

Goggles is my fave noise song though. its fucking pissed.

turnacus

they don't really make specific noise or rock songs, they seem to make a blend of both, and then some.

Could you call boris noise or rock? Sounds like sludge to me.
Van Hagar

Pringles

I think even GPT  sound noise when you compare with other rock band.
It was my first Melvins cd (Now I have all of them) and at the time, I tought GPT was seriously fucked up. Imagine the shock when I got HAT one month later.
Luck is a residue of design