Any Sludge Left?

Started by popeye, January 01, 2005, 04:58:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

groundmeat

Relax people.  Melvins have not lost their melvinosity the shitty collaborations notwithstanding. Even great musicians are allowed to like crappy music ;)  

It's just the Melvins being Melvins.  

Personally, though , I don't care if they never write another bullhead or lysol or maggot. I mean there are a zillion other bands who write nothing but sludge.  I love albums that have  a lot of variety and Melvins writes exactly those kind of albums.

beee

melvins rulez !!!
meshuggah rulez !!!
POTRE RULEZ
NEVER... RULEZ
HAT is boring !! SORYMEN

Well i was most impressed with eggnog :D


this post sucks sorry :(

:P

Kurva

Quote from: Binkard and FriendsI personally think the Melvins reached their creative zenith
yea
i think OZMA/GPT were their 'melviniest' albums
especially DALE!
his HAT drumming cannot be compared to OZMA/GPT!!!!
on HAT, i only like the noiz stoff...

Reverend Ebeneezer

Personally I see nowt wrong with 'Pigs...'. Frankly, it's the only collaborative effort of theirs that I think works. To me, Crybaby's just godawful with no direction and a load of tossed-off attempts at avant-garde and the less said about Never Breathe If Your Name Is Jello the better. Least Pigs had some depth to it...

And another thing, what's wrong with HAT? It sounds like Stag Part 2 to these ears, which surely should be welcomed but in the main it looks like the Melvins might be losing something. I mean, Collosus was frankly shite compared to their old stuff and makes Prick seem awesome and Electroretard was essentially a retread of their old stuff. Now we've had 3 collaborative albums and only really the Maggot, Bootlicker and HAT to reassure us of the Melvins greatness as a band themselves...Even the 7"s they've had out recently have been fucking terrible i.e. Thank You/Message Saved. Something's got to give soon.

But again, they produced some of the best music ever in the Lorax/Preston/Deutrom years so I'll try and counterbalance my whinging.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

popeye

Absolutely Dood!  i'm just glad i'm along for the ride!  listened to millenium monsterworks today and Thoroughly enjoyed it.  it's a live perf with mike patton doing his Lame-ass Scat singing to a slew of melvins tunes- SDSS is prob'ly on it i'd have to check the cd booklet to figutre out whoelse is playing on there, But - today - after going to those two shows at neumo's I just wanted to hear MM one more time, cuz i usually write it off as soon as patton starts shrieking - hell!  - i can sing better than that Tard!  Especially to melvin's songs!  And like i was saying - I turned it up loud and listened good - and it was Fukn Glorious.

Binkard and Friends

Dale's drumming has not been the same since Gluey Porch Treatments. I'm glad someone brought that up.


It seems like he gave every ounce of talent and strength for that record, and the only recent Melvins effort which has amazed me with its drumming was H.A.T.

Listen to "Exact Paperbacks" and "Heater Moves and Eyes" off of GPT; some of Dale's best work.

Vow

Quote from: anacondahey popeye, here's a live clip of them doing the title
song to Pigs as a trio; Dale, Buzz and Dave Scott Stone:

http://lazerman.netomia.dk/POTRE.mp3
This clip is awesome :D Do you have the other songs of this gig too Anaconda :?:

anaconda

I got the whole set from DubEMC. I agree that it's awesome.
It's not the classic sludge, but it sure as hell rocks! It gives
me hope for the future, if this is how they can pull of Pigs
as a trio.

beee

hey, can you upload hung bunny ? I love that song :)

Vow

Last five minutes are amazing! Some new / improvised sludge ala Lysol! This is some heavy shit! Hope they release it on their next record :twisted:

Grungeisdead

It would be nice to see another real melvins only album. I don't think it have to be "sludge" seeing another lysol would be weird though. I just don't want anyone else singing but Buzz and definatly not Jello.

turnacus

Yeah, Jello's lyrics and vocals suck fo-sho. On that album, The Melvins changed their style towards Jello, instead of having jello change his style, or have some sort of inbetween.

But the last song on that cd kicks.

And if you want sludge, try Men of Porn. Or High on Fire. Its still out there.
Van Hagar

popeye

Buzz must have some kind of "Respect" for Jello, and at least Jello can come up with lyrics for the tunes Buzzo & Adam are Grinding out.
  This brings me to my Point.  The whole jello "thing'  it's all worth it.  Absolutely!  just to give Buzz - Dale - Adam - SDSS a motivation to get together and come up with something New.
 The real payoff is seeing the Live shows.  Right now - i'm referring to the 2 shows last Week in Seattle @ Neumo's.  Believe me - it was Incredible.
That was good stuff - Brilliant.  of course i am partial to the melvins sound as opposed to Slipknot or Brittany Speers.
 They didn't fuk up.  I didn't notice any musical "Gaffes".  Even jello delivers in a sense.  At least he keeps the beat and he's energetic as hell.  That second night he didn't have much left as far as Range goes.  But he was still doing it. So i say god bless him  (even if he is Gay) he Rox and i like his Band!

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: popeyeThe real payoff is seeing the Live shows.  Right now - i'm referring to the 2 shows last Week in Seattle @ Neumo's.  Believe me - it was Incredible.
That was good stuff - Brilliant.  of course i am partial to the melvins sound as opposed to Slipknot or Brittany Speers.
!

There's no need to be patronising about things, it's just the the Melvins tend to make good noise and Jello makes horrible nosie. Add to that the fact that, from what I've heard (2 songs-I refuse to buy the record) it's all standard shite punk which seems below the Melvins' usual creative and heavy stuff.

As for "it's all in the live show...", I'll bet it is, but sadly I've yet to see the Melvins headline a tour as they were too ill to come play Europe last year. But they were fine with playing in America after making such a claim. Lost me a fair amount of respect, did that move...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

popeye

Rev Dood-  now that you explain it like that - i understand better where you're coming from, sorry man - i don't mean to offend.  I was just lucky, so were the other melvins fans in the Area.  Lately Buzz has been doing these kinda shows in SF.  But Seattle got a Fantastic Treat with 2 shows.
They played for 90 minutes the second night (maybe 83-85)  
 I had to look up Patronizing.  Yeah - i guess i am.  Definiktely patronizing towards king Buzzo and the melvins and just about anybody who gives them a reason to play music - including ursula the bass player from the supersecretshow.  You rock Girl!