The Melvins arent really THAT unpredictable....

Started by thegrumpylil'hermit, April 06, 2005, 02:40:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

thegrumpylil'hermit

.....at least not anymore.  Ipecac releasing a remastered CD version of old Melvins material....who didnt see that coming??  Ok, doctoring up the old Mangled Demos and putting them on CD i can maybe understand, but the fact that they pointlessly re-released Gluey Porch Treatments and 10 songs makes this one just as annoying.  As much as Buzz tries to play down his success and deny that anyone really likes his band, i think he knows he can keep doing stuff like this and get away with it, because theres a cult of fanboys out there frothing at the mouth for anything Melvins-related(me being one of them, up to a point).  HAT was the last Melvins album as far as im concerned.

turnacus

Yeah it sucks they gave us those 3 albums in 1 year, or HAT, or two albums this past year, and all those tours, and those other bands they play in, fantomas, tomahawk, men of porn, man, what a bunch of greedy assholes.


Oh man, all that quality music theyve made for 20 years too, god, I almost forgot that, its insulting to the nth degree.
Van Hagar

mumu

It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

klump

10 songs and gluey porch... were re-released so the melvins could actually make some money on these records, and make them more availble for the young fan boys...(so we dont pay 50 bucks for it on ebay)

the melvins have put out two albums (and I think at least Pigs of the roman is a real Melvins reocrd, its just a matter of what you like)
and the Neither here or there book, that they used quite some time on...

the last 8 years have been the melvins most productive period, so why complain?

I bet a new album is just around the corner, but if its not, I dont think we can blame them...I mean, putting out a new album every year isnt exactly easy if youre expecting quality...

the jello record isnt my favourite, but its a quality release...
the pigs record is a landmark in melvins history...
and neither here nor there is gathering together all the loose threads and celebrating the 20 years theyve been making music...

Hat is one of my top favourite albums, but it surely not the last melvins album as far as Im concerned.

Fantomastro

I cannot see your problem.
The melvins were never that successful as you suspected. I'm sure they don't make really big money with their music.

But however...they make great music and had made great music.

They spend a lot of time in their music and by the way, I really don't care how much money they make off it. It can't be that much.
Albums like the rereleas of gluey porch treatments and 26 songs are, as klump said, a chance for melvins fans that don't want to spend a fortune for the original albums.

If you want to listen to bands that screw off their fans, then listen to the Rolling Stones, who put out every year another repetition of themselfes :wink:

gwiz

I saw Buzz rolling down the street in a fat black beemer while cleaning his teeth with a diamond studded tooth-pick. He was laughing like a madman.







*Aliens are real and theyre coming to get you.

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: turnacusYeah it sucks they gave us those 3 albums in 1 year, or HAT, or two albums this past year, and all those tours, and those other bands they play in, fantomas, tomahawk, men of porn, man, what a bunch of greedy assholes.


Oh man, all that quality music theyve made for 20 years too, god, I almost forgot that, its insulting to the nth degree.

i imagine you've always scored pretty low on reasoning and reading comprehension.  Hat was released in 2001, if im not mistaken, and as i stated was the last Melvins album in my eyes.  if by "those 3 albums", you mean the Trilogy, what does that have to do with the last 4 years?  And half of you carry on pointless discussions about which was the best of the 3, so you're obviously clueless to begin with("i like Maggot the best cuz its the heaviest..."  :?).  Those two albums this past year??  unless you're talking about that Lustmord/Adam Jones record or that Jello Biafra w/Melvins deal, i dont recall the MELVINS having ever released anything new of their own.  And what does Fantomas, Tomahawk or Men of Porn have to do with the MELVINS?.  The Melvins tour their asses off, ill give you that, but its obvious they're stalling and running out of ideas.  But whats the point in arguing with a bunch of stoner rock drones and Tool fans.

feelmytool

that melvins/lustmord record was basically melvins playing and lustmord producing it, he said on his site tha%t he produced about 75% of the record and toshi did 25%. jellos record was melvins playing and jello singing. adam jones and lustmord is a completly different thing that's definatly going to have buzz on it. he's also working with robert fripp on it. but still don't bash adam, ever sense he "joined" the band the melvins have seen a huge jumped in popularity and he's been a driving and rejuvinating force in the melvins so bashing him now is like bashing kevin or dale.
if life is a dream in the imagination of ourselves, and there is no such thing as death, then what does waking up mean?

klump

Pigs of the roman empire was a FORKING good record, its not another Gluey porch treatments, eggnog or stag, its a completely NEW thing...

open your eyes and take your head out of your ass.

please :)

oh wait, I dont REALLY care what anyone else thinks, cause I love all the melvins records to different degrees...

I just dont see the point in talking shit about the melvins here...

you are just spoiled...

"I havent heard a new album in a few months...BUHU"


im in a bad mood, and im listening to melt banana so im writing this in 30 different tempos oh my god theres cvomes the trcuk  shgititmn!!쮷0䝩

Joe Deutrom

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit.....at least not anymore.  Ipecac releasing a remastered CD version of old Melvins material....who didnt see that coming??  Ok, doctoring up the old Mangled Demos and putting them on CD i can maybe understand, but the fact that they pointlessly re-released Gluey Porch Treatments and 10 songs makes this one just as annoying.  As much as Buzz tries to play down his success and deny that anyone really likes his band, i think he knows he can keep doing stuff like this and get away with it, because theres a cult of fanboys out there frothing at the mouth for anything Melvins-related(me being one of them, up to a point).  HAT was the last Melvins album as far as im concerned.

I look forward to hearing this remaster. I have never heard it before and I would like them to remaster Ozma too. If you are talking about the last album just with the Melvins then Pigs would be it. They play songs from it live so I think that qualifies as a Melvins release. I mean whats the hang up with Lustmord producing it? Pigs of the Roman Empire was certainly not predictable in my opinion.

LouiLoomis

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitif by "those 3 albums", you mean the Trilogy, what does that have to do with the last 4 years?  And half of you carry on pointless discussions about which was the best of the 3, so you're obviously clueless to begin with("i like Maggot the best cuz its the heaviest..."  :?).
This is a Melvins discussion board where people post their opinions, just like you're doing now by whinging about re-releases. So whats the problem with people talking about what album they like best?

Pigs Of The Roman Empire was the last Melvins album and it was released last year and as Klump said it was unpredictable, so I doubt very much they are running out of steam.

Some people do actually wanna hear this re-release, but if you're someone who doesn't then don't buy it. Problem solved. And yes, we did all see this release coming because they've been talking about releasing it for a long time now. Each member has commitments with other bands and because Fantomas and Men Of Porn are on the road this year there probably won't be a studio album, so this album will be more of a 'tie you over til then'.

Seems you picked the right username... :wink:

Vcavallo

after listening to Pigs of the Roman Empire again recently, i realized even more so what a quality record it is.  in fact, i hope they do MORE with electronic tweaking and layering and stuff.  when one listens to POTRE, and then goes back and listens to some older material, one may start to feel as though the older stuff is missing a certain quality that can be found on pigs.  i used to want them to go back to 10 songs days, but alas, i have changed my mind in a big way.  i don't want the melvins to turn out caveman rock that only satisfies a visceral longing for pounding, i want them to compose (as they have been in recent years) and astound me with their song writing and creativity.  something i can be proud of and finally be able to support my love for them with fans of equally complex music like good jazz or recent sonic youth.  [anyone ever have this happen to them?  you tell someone you love the melvins and play it for them and you realize that this person is only hearing some generic metal band and you can't get them to hear what you hear?  its frustrating, eh?  ...fuck em!]
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

dr.ghira

Man, you're goddam right. There are a few guys who i gave some Melvins stuff, especially early, and they went like this: Metal, good musicians, but...

Open your EARS!!!

blacksanta

I'm not sure which new Melvins album I'm looking forward to the most. The 1983 demos, the rumored Jello/Melvins EP, the Electroretard re-issue of re-done tracks and covers, the Al Jourgenson remixed Jello/Melvins album, or the new Fantomas record. All quality Melvins releases in the hizzy fo' sho.'
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Bryan

"""but the fact that they pointlessly re-released Gluey Porch Treatments and 10 songs makes this one just as annoying. As much as Buzz tries to play down his success and deny that anyone really likes his band, i think he knows he can keep doing stuff like this and get away with it"""

Get away with it??? The Melvins don't owe us a damn thing. They are not obligated to give us a new record every year.  This sounds like people who get offended and complain when their favorite band breaks up ("how could they do this to me?!"), as if the band had signed a contract to entertain  the fans for the rest of their lives. And I doubt the Melvs are gonna make lots of money off of Mangled Demos. Some people want to hear this, and releasing it also helps keep the band afloat.  I too would rather have another brand new Melvins album. But I will buy Mangled Demos and, frankly, I'm more excited about this than the new Fantomas.