The Melvins arent really THAT unpredictable....

Started by thegrumpylil'hermit, April 06, 2005, 02:40:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

anaconda

i think the guy who started all this BS
is an Ipecac/Bunglefever board refugee.

I want the proper follow-up to HAT too though!!

blacksanta

Quotethe Melvs
:cry:

QuoteThe Melvins don't owe us a damn thing
They owe me a new album of all new material without a guest artist.



QuoteI want the proper follow-up to HAT too though!!

Right! I'll still buy the fucking Mangled Demos, and I'm sure it will be a nice novelty, but I'm still gonna be a snide sarcastic cocksuker until they personally hand-deliver a new album into my *deserving* hands w/o Jellmord McWhatthefuck on it.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

TosT


Kurva

hey dr. ghira & VCavallo
dont be like that
dont tell me you liked THEMELVINS from the very first time ...
people need some time to GET into good bands, especially THEMELVINS

I was playing their old stuff to my satanic-death-metalhead friend for quite a time .... and finally he said: "Wow man. NOW I realised why did you liked em. They are so KICKASS."

ofcourse when I said "And this is  the OLD SHIT, this is just the beggining."
So I played him Air Breather Deep in Arms of Morphius..... and he didnt know what to say... again  :lol:

so be nice. ALL OF YOU!
THE MELVINS are one of the most AMAZING THINGS ON THIS CRUEL PLANET

Chomas

"I saw Buzz rolling down the street in a fat black beemer while cleaning his teeth with a diamond studded tooth-pick. He was laughing like a madman"

haha!!!!!!!

chill out you haters, the melvins can do no wrong...

mobmob

after listening to those HAT 7" b-sides i knew something is smelly.
buzz is too pretentious to ever admit he screwed up but i'd sure like to
hear what dale has to say about POTRE.

heneverblinks

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitBut whats the point in arguing with a bunch of stoner rock drones and Tool fans.

Touch

mumu

I once saw a t.v. show on HBO where Buzz was walking around in Beverly Hills with a real estate agent looking for a house to buy.  He must be LOADED!

When you become a superfan, you're allowed to call them 'The Melvs'.  For example, The Melvs used to live in Frisco, but now they live in La La Land.
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

Michael

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitI was gonna do 3 albums from 3 different bands, but thats just too hard and id probably end up hanging myself from a tree if i was ever in that situation......so, 3 Melvins albums:

Ozma/GPT cd(is that cheating?)
Stoner Witch
Honky

.....id still probably opt to kill myself though and id really be missing Eggnog, Lysol, Houdini, pretty much everything.  But i think the above three would be a decent mix.

I don't see why you feel the need to put yourself above everyone else by dismissing people for discussing which albums they prefer.  You yourself are guilty of such an offense as a simple look at your past posts provides.  

I think that many of the arguments countering your original post in this forum are valid.  For example, the reissue of GPT sounds infinitely better (i.e. LOUDER) than the Boner version tacked onto Ozma.  Same goes for the reissue of 10 Songs.  

The Melvins release these reissues because people buy them.  If there was no interest, they wouldn't do it.  They are doing a service to those of us that do not have easy access to the originals and/or do not want to pay an outrageous price to some random collector for this music.  Plus, the new artwork and essays help put the work into the context with in which it was created.  

I don't think there is anyone here that disagrees about wanting a new full-fledged Melvins album sans Lustmord, Jello, Adam Jones, etc. but that does not inherently mean that the collaborative work that has been produced with these individuals is inferior or not worth checking out.  Pigs of the Roman Empire was as inspiring, heavy and original as anything the Melvins have ever released.  If Lustmord's name was hidden among the credits under production instead of being plastered on the cover, then everyone here would be drooling over it.  It is hands down my favorite record released in all of 2004, but that topic is for another forum.

To state that Buzz, Kevin and Dale are running out of ideas is the funniest thing I have yet heard.  For over twenty years they have consistently pushed themsleves to be forward thinking and challenging.  This band has never been (and are definitely smart enough never to be) stagnant.  If they felt that they had run out of ideas than the recent shows would have been a greatest hits package with no new material from either of the two albums that they had a hand in making last year.

Most major musical artists have two to three year gaps between releasing anything deemed "new".  They also do not tour incessantly and play in multiple bands.  The fact that the Melvins can juggle everything on their plate and still be valid enough to have us ranting and raving in this forum is testament to their integrity and vitality.

As for, Tool fans/stoner rock dweebs, I have no excuse for them.

blacksanta

QuoteThe Melvins release these reissues because people buy them
Suckers like me.



Quotethe new artwork and essays help put the work into the context with in which it was created

Gardner's Melvins through the Ages Vol. 1 - The Boombox Microphone Demo Years.



QuoteI don't think there is anyone here that disagrees about wanting a new full-fledged Melvins album sans Lustmord, Jello, Adam Jones, etc. but that does not inherently mean that the collaborative work that has been produced with these individuals is inferior or not worth checking out.
Quote

It's worth checking out of your local library and burning a copy.





QuotePigs of the Roman Empire was as inspiring, heavy and original as anything the Melvins have ever released.

It was a piece of shit. It inspired me to put on HAT.

QuoteIf Lustmord's name was hidden among the credits under production instead of being plastered on the cover

I would still think its a piece of shit and I'd have to blame the Melvins 100% for its sucking so bad instead of only 50%.

QuoteThis band has never been (and are definitely smart  enough never to be) stagnant.

2002 HAT
Millenium Monsterwork
2003
26 Songs
Melvinmania
2004
collab. with Lustmord
collab. with Jello
greatest hits art book
electroretard revolve single
message saved (anyone?)
2005
1983 demos

If they can't go gracefully, I hope they will at least stop raping their fans with this recent spat of lazy, low-quality, sub-par work.

I'm fucking with you on that last one, but still...what's next? Singles 1-12 reissue w/ alternate takes of Fast Forward? If they were gonna do a reissue of anything, make it Tora Tora Tora. I couldn't afford 45.00 when it came out my freshman year. Or maybe they should re-issue the concept of the Melvins as a 3-piece band that makes records of new and original material mainly written by Buzzo and mainly played by Buzzo, Crover. and (bassist name here).
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

mumu

Quote from: blacksanta
QuotePigs of the Roman Empire was as inspiring...

It was a piece of shit. It inspired me to put on HAT.


This made me giggle.

  =P~

Carry on.
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

anaconda

Singles 1-12 reissue w/ alternate takes of Fast Forward?

HAHAHAHAHA or maybe Theresa Screams (2005 remix)?  :oops:

they are getting kind of embarrassing with these one-off cash grabs

klump

I cant imagine them making a lot of money on these albums.
the re-issues i mean.

turnacus

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit
Quote from: turnacusYeah it sucks they gave us those 3 albums in 1 year, or HAT, or two albums this past year, and all those tours, and those other bands they play in, fantomas, tomahawk, men of porn, man, what a bunch of greedy assholes.


Oh man, all that quality music theyve made for 20 years too, god, I almost forgot that, its insulting to the nth degree.

i imagine you've always scored pretty low on reasoning and reading comprehension.  Hat was released in 2001, if im not mistaken, and as i stated was the last Melvins album in my eyes.  if by "those 3 albums", you mean the Trilogy, what does that have to do with the last 4 years?  And half of you carry on pointless discussions about which was the best of the 3, so you're obviously clueless to begin with("i like Maggot the best cuz its the heaviest..."  :?).  Those two albums this past year??  unless you're talking about that Lustmord/Adam Jones record or that Jello Biafra w/Melvins deal, i dont recall the MELVINS having ever released anything new of their own.  And what does Fantomas, Tomahawk or Men of Porn have to do with the MELVINS?.  The Melvins tour their asses off, ill give you that, but its obvious they're stalling and running out of ideas.  But whats the point in arguing with a bunch of stoner rock drones and Tool fans.

Actually, as long as we're talking reading comprehension, if you look here here and here  you'll notice that Men Of Porn, Fantomas, and Tomahawk contain members of The Melvins. I guess that sort of qualifies as having something "to do with the melvins". You see, the members of The Melvins take their talent, and when fused with other musicians, make good music, that (much to your dismay) doesn't sound like The Melvins.

And yeah dude, I agree, fuck those Tool fans too...... trying to go about, liking music they enjoy that we don't right under our fucking noses. Shit like that pisses me off. Why can't they be more like us, if only just when we are around.

The arrogance man, the fucking arrogance.
Van Hagar

photman

I like pigs of the roman empire and they also came out with a riddle book which I have not figured out any of the riddles.