The Melvins arent really THAT unpredictable....

Started by thegrumpylil'hermit, April 06, 2005, 02:40:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

the bloat

You gotta give these guys a break. They are the hardest working band around. It's not 1992 anymore!!!
STOP waiting for the next Lysol to drop and START waiting for the next bandmember to drop. POTRE is one of the best Melvins records!!

benton netty

Quote from: the bloatPOTRE is one of the best Melvins records!!



Voltzy

in my eyes i see pigs of the roman empire and the jello cds all as melvins cds, their both excellent but they just portray different sides of the melvins. I even go to the point were i consider the venomous concept album as melvins, even though its only got buzz in it  :)

blacksanta

I consider the C.C. Deville solo album.......fuck it. Never mind.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Vcavallo

Quote from: blacksanta
Quote
Quote from: michael
QuoteThis band has never been (and are definitely smart  enough never to be) stagnant.

2002 HAT
Millenium Monsterwork
2003
26 Songs
Melvinmania
2004
collab. with Lustmord
collab. with Jello
greatest hits art book
electroretard revolve single
message saved (anyone?)
2005
1983 demos

If they can't go gracefully, I hope they will at least stop raping their fans with this recent spat of lazy, low-quality, sub-par work.

in case the reader doesn't remember, michael explained how the recent re-issues are valuable to newer listeners who would like hi-fi copies of otherwise very expensive original vinyls and whatnot...

blacksanta, you are obviously an idiot.  sorry, i usually try to keep my posts strictly opinion-based and not start calling people names (though it is an opinion) but here i am going to make an exception, and call you an idiot.  
it seems as though you are insinuating the melvins are approaching retirement and crapping as they go.. there is really no evidence to support this.  they have only began re-releasing things recently because NOW albums are old.  what were they gonna re-release in the 90's?  a fucking album that came out four years ago?  just think for a second about what you are saying.   it looks like you are calling HAT a 2002 stagnation, and i find that really confusing as you said that you put on HAT when pigs bores you...what?  Millennium Monsterwork is a live album, and a very unique one at that, i see no reason to complain about it.  don't knock the melvins for "Melvinmania" because they had nothing to do with it.  get your shit right before you start bitching. the collaborations were experiments that seem justified to me (jello less so than lustmord).  the collaboration with lustmord is interesting and new for the melvins and if you don't want them to learn new recording techniques and mood elements and whatnot from a fellow experienced musician, then they might as well be dead.  it seems to me like you are promoting stagnation by whining when they do something new, no?  i'd like to see you contest that, ass.
the art book was a huge fucking milestone in the melvins' career.  i can't believe anyone doesn't like it.  not only are the melvins releasing music for you, but then are releasing an expertly designed fucking BOOK! jesus christ you are a greedy bastard.  if you can't appreciate art in the same sort of way that you can experience music, then i just feel sorry for you.  publishing a book...wow, what a good example of Productiveness, as opposed to stagnation.. it is beginning to look like you were almost completely wrong..as far as message saved and the revolve single, i see these two items as live show merchandise sort of things, and they just add to the vast menagerie of rare melvins memorabilia on ebay that adds such a deep dimension to the whole atmosphere of the melvins.  if they didn't have that aura about them they would be just one step closer to boring.  and stagnant.  
im not going to bother disputing the "stagnation" of re-releasing the demos because as you can see, they aren't out yet.  so it would be idiotic to argue about them, and i'd rather not stoop to your level.  
i realize that i didn't mention 26 songs, and that is because it is a great remaster of a really fucking old album, that deserves the honor of being made-over.  also, it had the bonus tracks and essay...these are the types of things i am saying add to the interest of the melvins as not just another hard rock band.  how many other 20+ year old bands can you think of that provide their listeners with evidence of their early years in the form of 15 extra tracks?  not to mention the fact that 10 songs is completely great, and all but impossible to find.  can you really argue with a band creating access for their fans to their first and very rare album?  come on, don't be an asshole.

lastly, you called yourself a jackass or something like that for buying all these items that you purported to be evidence of stagnation.  if you are that against them, then why didn't you boycott them and stick it to the melvins, just as you firmly believed they were sticking it to you?

and just to be a little child:  i had the tattoo avatar before you, and yours is pretty godawful ugly.  nany nany poo poo.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Next_on_the_Shitlist

Last time I checked they were The Melvins and they have always did what they want. If you don't like what they're putting out don't buy the shit. I hope they do more collaborative projects just to piss everybody off. Running low on ideas? Please.

GrimReaper

Quote from: anacondaSingles 1-12 reissue w/ alternate takes of Fast Forward?

HAHAHAHAHA or maybe Theresa Screams (2005 remix)?  :oops:


:lol:  :lol:  :lol:  :D

GrimReaper

You know, this is a great thread. I've read through this a couple of times and get a good laugh everytime.

There are loads of bands out here I would love to see repackage their old material. But they can't, they don't own it.

Tora, Tora, Tora could be the next release, or a HAT singles EP.

What about a Fugazi type live series?

Grungeisdead

As long as the melvins keep touring, so i can see them live at least once, I'll be happy.

blacksanta

Quotei had the tattoo avatar before you
It's Dead Moon, look them up. And to be a little child, I registered to this forum a WHOLE MONTH before you did.

Anyway, please calm down. I'd hate to see you have a stroke over a band.
You didn't notice that the line you quoted from me was followed up with "I'm just fucking with you" or something to that effect. Mainly that was because I knew that someone was going to right a book on here about what an asshole I am, and I realized I could point that out.

Quotewhat were they gonna re-release in the 90's? a fucking album that came out four years ago?



I didn't realize that re-releases were an integral part of the Melvins experience. I humbly apologize.

Quotecrapping as they go..
Everybody poops! Even King Buzzo

Quoteit looks like you are calling HAT a 2002 stagnation, and i find that really confusing as you said that you put on HAT when pigs bores you...what?

If my post was confusing to you, why not just ask me for clarification, instead of calling me a bunch of names?

QuoteMillennium Monsterwork is a live album
And I think it sucks, so maybe I shouldn't be allowed to like the Melvins anymore.

Quotedon't knock the melvins for "Melvinmania" because they had nothing to do with it. get your shit right before you start bitching
Is it a bootleg? No. is it a legitimate release? Yes. Therefore, I will count as part of the Melvins discography. Sorry.

 
Quoteit seems to me like you are promoting stagnation by whining when they do something new, no?

No, I whine when I think the albums suck. But that is my opinion, no?


"i can't believe anyone doesn't like it"



I thought the book was cool to look at a few times. I even shelled out for the hardcover. But if I didn't like it would that make me a lesser human being in your eyes? What are you, a psycho?


"not only are the melvins releasing music for you"

If that were the case, the quality of the recent offerings would be much improved!



"mood elements"


Did the Melvins get signed to Windham Hill when I wasn't looking?



"jesus christ you are a greedy bastard. if you can't appreciate art in the same sort of way that you can..."



I can see where your going.........no wait I can't.



"then i just feel sorry for you"



Do you feel sorry for the handicapped? If you do, do you call them assholes and greedy bastards too?



" it is beginning to look like you were almost completely wrong"



It is beginning to look like you don't agree with me!



"...as far as message saved and the revolve single, i see these two items as live show merchandise sort of things, and they just add to the vast menagerie of rare melvins memorabilia on ebay that adds such a deep dimension to the whole atmosphere of the melvins"



Jesus Christ, Fine OK, Awesome You Win Vast aura of manageries and shit



"so it would be idiotic to argue about them, and i'd rather not stoop to your level."



Why that would make you call me an asshole because you disagree with me.


" can you really argue with a band creating access for their fans to their first and very rare album? come on, don't be an asshole."



I've changed my mind and I think your right. Although I thought the rarity of 10 Songs added to the menagerie of auras.



"lastly, you called yourself a jackass or something like that for buying all these items that you purported to be evidence of stagnation. if you are that against them, then why didn't you boycott them and stick it to the melvins, just as you firmly believed they were sticking it to you?"



I had to buy them to find out that I DIDN'T LIKE THEM. I CAN'T RIGHTLY LISTEN TO THE FUCKERS THROUGH OSMOSIS CAN I? :roll:
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

mumu

It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

blacksanta

:lol:  :lol:  :lol:

Muu-muu, that rules! The idiocy of internet arguing :lol:  :lol:  :lol:
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Huey P. Newton


dontyoutellme

Quote from: GrimReaper

What about a Fugazi type live series?

i think that would be a great idea for people who've never had the fortune to see the melvins live.....
i love the live fugazi stuff and since theyve split into different bands and havent made an album since the argument or furniture ep its awesome to hear the variations in live form. although--- i will have to say that fugazi is not about a profit and logo packaging etc while the melvins seem to have a little bit more of a commercial edge to them-
but hey what do you expect from a band whose tickets range in the twenty dollar price range and once signed to atlantic?

at any rate i enjoy the live melvins stuff ive amassed in the past to present.

and so on and so forth.
gamble gamble gamble DIE.