what are some melvins covers that make you cream yer jeans?

Started by Chuck Hartford, May 07, 2005, 07:28:08 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: dontyoutellmeyouth of america. the length of their cover is even a strongpoint. the wipers sound like total wankers when their version is re-inspected.

that is the dumbest fucking thing ive ever heard......obviously you're not that familiar with the Wipers.  The Melvins version is alright, but it doesnt even touch on the original.  What exactly is it about the Wipers that you dont like?  They're not "heavy" enough for ya??  Cant live without those heavily distorted Drop D tones, huh??

Ive been meaning to start a thread on the Wipers....ive always wondered if their were any other fans on here.  Id recommend the 3 cd box set to anyone wanting to get into them.  go to zenorecords.com, they're practically going for nothing considering whats included.  Awesome band.....definitely deserve more recognition than just "that band that the Melvins and Nirvana covered".      
Anyone know what Greg Sage has been up to lately?

Anyway, back on topic....id have to say their version of the MC5's "Rocket Reducer...", "Symptom of the Universe", "Butcher Town".  Thats what comes to mind right now.

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: dontyoutellme
Quote from: DubEMC
Quote from: dontyoutellmeyouth of america. the length of their cover is even a strongpoint. the wipers sound like total wankers when their version is re-inspected.


Go back to school man. I'm sure even Buzz himself would admit how important and influential Greg Sage and the Wipers were to the Northwest scene and punk/alternative/whatever you want to call it in general.  The original YOA came out in 1980, recorded and produced by the band independently and is at least 10 minutes long. Pretty radical for " wankers " eh?

im not knocking the wipers as hard as you may fear with the obvious passion found in your reply. i'll go the less harsh route and say youth of america is my favorite cover, i think the wipers are splendid, but when the melvins cover something- odds are they're covering it in a way thats going to frost the cake. AND yes i do think buzz would "admit" in a hot minute how influential and important the wipers were. cornerstones shant be refused; eh?

what exactly did you mean by "the length of their version is a strongpoint" in your original post?  thats a bit suspect to me......i actually wasnt very fond of the Melvins cover the first time i heard it.  I dont think it does the original justice at all.  Not even close.  It rocks, for sure, but the original goes above and beyond that.  Its funny that you would call the Wipers "wankers" when all the Melvins really did was take the basic verse and chorus of the song, beef it up, and then replace most of that experimental noise in the middle(thats the best part!) with the same ole guitar solo wankery that Buzz has done a million times.   Listen to the middle of "Your Blessened" from Bullhead, perfect example....Buzz basically plays the same thing, note for note on Youth of America.   But Melvins fans dont take this the wrong way.  Its just a cover and im sure they didnt intend on trying to one-up the Wipers in the first place.   They're just fans paying tribute.

DubEMC

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitAnyone know what Greg Sage has been up to lately?



Far as I know he still leads the Wipers. Land Of The Lost is another great release.

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: DubEMC
Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitAnyone know what Greg Sage has been up to lately?



Far as I know he still leads the Wipers. Land Of The Lost is another great release.

Well, he never officially called it quits but they've been inactive quite some time now.  Ive just assumed its over.  I dont have Land of the Lost yet.....ive heard the title track and a couple of others off of it.  I managed to find The Herd in the used bin not too long ago.

norecess

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitId recommend the 3 cd box set to anyone
wanting to get into them.  

Got it. A few years ago I wanted to buy YOA but the box was the available only Wipers-release at most stores, if they even had something. At first I felt kind of bad 'cause I thought I had spent too much money it but now I can tell it was worth every penny.

I also bought Silver Sail a few weeks back, for a few euros. Haven't really heard it yet though.

tinycorkscrew

Beto, I'd be happy to do that, but I'd have to find the tape first. I used to have 15-20 early 90's Melvins shows on videotape, but when I moved eight years ago, I had to leave the tapes behind, and I don't know what happened to them.

Most of the shows were recorded between Eggnog and Houdini.

If I can find them, I'll be happy to send you the ones you don't already have.

Beto Brasil

Quote from: tinycorkscrew...If I can find them, I'll be happy to send you the ones you don't already have...

No Problens man, i wait you, if you find the tape, please let me know.
thank you,

BB
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

Green Honey


Chuck Hartford

i am surprised that nobody has mentioned Lexicon Devil
i was listening to 1-12 today (Theresa Screams is the best song ever)

thegrumpylil'hermit


thegrumpylil'hermit

or how about their cover of Brutal Truth's "Zodiac"?   :wink:

klump

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitor how about their cover of Brutal Truth's "Zodiac"?   :wink:

uh? i hope that was a joke?  :wink:

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: klump
Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermitor how about their cover of Brutal Truth's "Zodiac"?   :wink:

uh? i hope that was a joke?  :wink:

Not a Brutal Truth fan??  :?

well, to each his own......but if Brutal Truth's "Zodiac" is not an awesome song, then i guess ex-Melvins bassist Lori doesnt play guitar and sing for the awesome Acid King.  :wink:

mumu

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit... i guess ex-Melvins bassist Lori doesnt play guitar and sing for the awesome Acid King.  :wink:

Lori Black stopped playing for Acid King?~!?!? :P
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

dontyoutellme

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit
Quote from: dontyoutellme
Quote from: DubEMC
Quote from: dontyoutellmeyouth of america. the length of their cover is even a strongpoint. the wipers sound like total wankers when their version is re-inspected.


Go back to school man. I'm sure even Buzz himself would admit how important and influential Greg Sage and the Wipers were to the Northwest scene and punk/alternative/whatever you want to call it in general.  The original YOA came out in 1980, recorded and produced by the band independently and is at least 10 minutes long. Pretty radical for " wankers " eh?

im not knocking the wipers as hard as you may fear with the obvious passion found in your reply. i'll go the less harsh route and say youth of america is my favorite cover, i think the wipers are splendid, but when the melvins cover something- odds are they're covering it in a way thats going to frost the cake. AND yes i do think buzz would "admit" in a hot minute how influential and important the wipers were. cornerstones shant be refused; eh?

what exactly did you mean by "the length of their version is a strongpoint" in your original post?  thats a bit suspect to me......i actually wasnt very fond of the Melvins cover the first time i heard it.  I dont think it does the original justice at all.  Not even close.  It rocks, for sure, but the original goes above and beyond that.  Its funny that you would call the Wipers "wankers" when all the Melvins really did was take the basic verse and chorus of the song, beef it up, and then replace most of that experimental noise in the middle(thats the best part!) with the same ole guitar solo wankery that Buzz has done a million times.   Listen to the middle of "Your Blessened" from Bullhead, perfect example....Buzz basically plays the same thing, note for note on Youth of America.   But Melvins fans dont take this the wrong way.  Its just a cover and im sure they didnt intend on trying to one-up the Wipers in the first place.   They're just fans paying tribute.

come on baby soft easy reader. as for suspecting the unusual; you win the rubber stamp collection of half the alphabet.
i am not suprised but rather amused by the inadvertent usage of misusage.
pzzzout.
-DONTYOUTELLME.
gamble gamble gamble DIE.