question: Melvins art and Nazi symbolism

Started by Hank Hill, May 09, 2005, 03:03:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

cellphone

The Melvins have always been adept at confusing the shit out of anyone reading their liner notes.  Serious? Not serious?  It really doesn't matter, because the distinction can be very grey.  What it ends up coming down to is that we all take things much too seriously but at the same time are much too preoccupied with the very concept of being serious.

Beyond that, we allow our opinions, reactions, and emotions to be swayed by simple things like symbols that by themselves have never hurt anyone, even if the ideas many people hold them to represent do.

klump

if people start to cry if they see a swastika, they should get a life!

a house in my city has BIG swastikas around the roof as an old ornament (been their since  before the germans came and messed around)

i actually like the nazis, without the we wouldnt have a place to play our musikkk. :lol: (my band is practicing in an old nazi barrack, mmmmm, asbestos!)

Moebius05

=> not funny

people in the US/UK sometimes think that it would be risqu

Rembrandt Pussyhorse

Oh yeah, well my mom took me to see The Passion, and Mel Gibson said  Jews were snakes and liars. And if the Road Warrior says it, it must be true..

ahhh nevrmind


DRINK J
I could catch a monkey

Duds

"Those punk rocker types, they have just no sense of humor"
read this interview with buzz and kevin in 2002

page1:http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate1.jpg
page2: http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate2.jpg

cellphone

Quoteit's only stupid, inexeptable and counterproductive

at laest when used in the no-brain fashion like the above mentioned

i find the trilogy vinyl edition design embarrasing

this is a perfect example of someone basing their reaction on something as ultimately meaningless as a geometric design.  when birds fly in weird patterns, does it make you hurt inside?

lighten up man!  it doesn't matter!  instead of whining about symbols on album (especially since these symbols originally represented something far less sinister before being appropriated) maybe you should do something about people's attitudes, like actual racism, instead of getting pissy because someone decided to fuck with people like you and put a couple of offensive symbols in their liner notes.

DanGerous

YOU'RE ALL NIGGERS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

idiotboy

Quote from: cellphone
Quoteit's only stupid, inexeptable and counterproductive

at laest when used in the no-brain fashion like the above mentioned

i find the trilogy vinyl edition design embarrasing

this is a perfect example of someone basing their reaction on something as ultimately meaningless as a geometric design.  when birds fly in weird patterns, does it make you hurt inside?

lighten up man!  it doesn't matter!  instead of whining about symbols on album (especially since these symbols originally represented something far less sinister before being appropriated) maybe you should do something about people's attitudes, like actual racism, instead of getting pissy because someone decided to fuck with people like you and put a couple of offensive symbols in their liner notes.

Ever had tragedy in your life cellphone?

You tell me what it is so I can make fun of it and we'll see how you feel.

Hank Hill

Quote from: Duds"Those punk rocker types, they have just no sense of humor"
read this interview with buzz and kevin in 2002

page1:http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate1.jpg
page2: http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate2.jpg



my acrobat reader thing won't let me view this interview:  would someone kindly copy and paste the text to clear up any misconceptions, the guy that mentioned the Trilogy design has a good point.

klump

:)

i think the more we try to say that certain symbols are "dangerous" , the more power these symbols will get...and thats a FACT. :idea:

norecess

Quote from: Duds"Those punk rocker types, they have just no sense of humor"
read this interview with buzz and kevin in 2002

page1:http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate1.jpg
page2: http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate2.jpg

I love that last line: 'We love skateboarding'.

TGH

Quote from: idiotboy
Quote from: cellphone
Quoteit's only stupid, inexeptable and counterproductive

at laest when used in the no-brain fashion like the above mentioned

i find the trilogy vinyl edition design embarrasing

this is a perfect example of someone basing their reaction on something as ultimately meaningless as a geometric design.  when birds fly in weird patterns, does it make you hurt inside?

lighten up man!  it doesn't matter!  instead of whining about symbols on album (especially since these symbols originally represented something far less sinister before being appropriated) maybe you should do something about people's attitudes, like actual racism, instead of getting pissy because someone decided to fuck with people like you and put a couple of offensive symbols in their liner notes.

Ever had tragedy in your life cellphone?

You tell me what it is so I can make fun of it and we'll see how you feel.

You are getting way too worked up over the symbols. The symbols did not kill anyone, did they? No. They had nothing to do with it. They were just dragged along.
This isn't a time for lectures!

mumu

I think it's rediculous to discount idiotboy's reaction so quickly.  You have symbols that are associated with gross human injustices, and then when someone objects, it's rather lame to pull the 'ha, they're just symbols!' statement.  It doesnt diminish the automatic emotional reaction to the symbols some people will automatically have.

It seems rather lame for artists to use catholic imagery, devils, etc. for a strong reaction.  Ho hum.  Certain artists need to try and be creative for once, create some artwork that actually inspires different feelings rather than rely on hackneyed images guaranteed to offend.
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

Moebius05

Quote from: cellphone
Quoteit's only stupid, inexeptable and counterproductive

at laest when used in the no-brain fashion like the above mentioned

i find the trilogy vinyl edition design embarrasing

this is a perfect example of someone basing their reaction on something as ultimately meaningless as a geometric design.  when birds fly in weird patterns, does it make you hurt inside?

lighten up man!  it doesn't matter!  instead of whining about symbols on album (especially since these symbols originally represented something far less sinister before being appropriated) maybe you should do something about people's attitudes, like actual racism, instead of getting pissy because someone decided to fuck with people like you and put a couple of offensive symbols in their liner notes.

To claim that for package designers geometrical patterns are unimportant (if I'm not misinterpreting you) is the stupidest thing I came across today.

Closely followed by the remark about the birds. When somebody is struck by lightening, do you hold a murder trial? No you don`t, because there is no deliberate human act behind it. Birds generally are not trying to make a point when they fly in patterns. Artists on the other hand are expected to try to express something. It is a bit disappointing when they just randomely waste other peoples time, space and money. And when they misuse symbols associated with things of great importance for artistic padding that is, like I said before, embarrassing

Moebius05

Quote from: Duds"Those punk rocker types, they have just no sense of humor"
read this interview with buzz and kevin in 2002

page1:http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate1.jpg
page2: http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate2.jpg

Also this interview here, kindly linked by Duds, is a nother hint that the Melvins ued the six symbols without giving the whole thing too much thought: I am not a native english speaker, but as far as I know a "hate group" is not a group that is being hated, but a group that hates. Again, judaism as a religion (do not confuse with the policies of the current government of israel) to my knowledge does not have a history of excessively hating anybody. So when I call Kevin Rutmanis an idiot for saying that people of jewish faith are a hate group like the NAZIs, the KuKluxKlan, etc., I am really suggesting the friendliest of possible interpretations for his remarks.