question: Melvins art and Nazi symbolism

Started by Hank Hill, May 09, 2005, 03:03:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Moebius05

Quote from: Hank Hill
Quote from: Duds"Those punk rocker types, they have just no sense of humor"
read this interview with buzz and kevin in 2002

page1:http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate1.jpg
page2: http://www.themelvins.net/writings/thrasher/melskate2.jpg



my acrobat reader thing won't let me view this interview:  would someone kindly copy and paste the text to clear up any misconceptions, the guy that mentioned the Trilogy design has a good point.

I transcribed the relevant part of the interview:

[

Moebius05

Quote from: ShastaClock
Quote from: idiotboy
Quote from: cellphone
Quoteit's only stupid, inexeptable and counterproductive

at laest when used in the no-brain fashion like the above mentioned

i find the trilogy vinyl edition design embarrasing

this is a perfect example of someone basing their reaction on something as ultimately meaningless as a geometric design.  when birds fly in weird patterns, does it make you hurt inside?

lighten up man!  it doesn't matter!  instead of whining about symbols on album (especially since these symbols originally represented something far less sinister before being appropriated) maybe you should do something about people's attitudes, like actual racism, instead of getting pissy because someone decided to fuck with people like you and put a couple of offensive symbols in their liner notes.

Ever had tragedy in your life cellphone?

You tell me what it is so I can make fun of it and we'll see how you feel.

You are getting way too worked up over the symbols. The symbols did not kill anyone, did they? No. They had nothing to do with it. They were just dragged along.

Hey, did symbols ever kill anyone? No! Yippie-Yeah!
Hey, did ideology ever kill anyone? No! Yippie-Yeah!
Hey, did Adolf Hitler ever kill anyone? No! Yippie-Yeah!
Hey, did fanatics ever kill anyone? Yeah, but since there aren't many of them they never killed very many people.
Hey, did people who just don't want to get way too worked up over things ever kill anyone? Yes. Millions. And they do it up to the present day. More than 90% of all avoidable man made injustices are do to people who'll buy whatever they're sold, 'cause they "just don't care".

No offence other than what is absolutely necessary intended.

klump

hmmm, is "lighten up" inappropriate to say now? :P

Hank Hill

thanks moebius5 - case solved like sherlock, scotland yard and shit

idiotboy

Quote from: klumphmmm, is "lighten up" inappropriate to say now? :P

"lighten up" is always inappropriate to say in any situation. Just pisses people off more dont you think? Its like saying "what you have to say isnt important so be happy why dont you, you petty, ugly little weazle?"

idiotboy

Hey, did symbols ever kill anyone? Yes - and this point is sooooo simple - symbols represent more than just themselves.
Hey, did ideology ever kill anyone? Yip - like communism or faschism or democracy and so on...
Hey, did Adolf Hitler ever kill anyone? Yip - he did didn't he? I dunno maybe he didnt.
Hey, did fanatics ever kill anyone? No! Yippie-Yeah!
Hey, did people who just don't want to get way too worked up over things ever kill anyone? No! Yippie-Yeah!

Fantomastro

Oh man! to wich point has this thread gets?

When someone feels offended about the symbols, or the rabbit hitler and doesn't understand the meanings behind that, he should'nt buy it.
Because the melvins are nazis and jews, members of the plack panthers and the ku-klux-klan and of curse, christians and satanicis.

They're just schizophrenic :P

And to reemphasise, the trilogie symbols are just to show people the most powerful opposites which have and have had the most influence on human mind.

When I look at the trilogie, I'm glad, that I'm not a member of any of this groups, that I have my own ideologies and don't fear them. They're not a taboo!

Everyone has another method to deal with those symbols, or their beliefs.
As for the trilogie, it's in a more subtly way. For electroretard, it's more sarcastic. And Sargasm is, in my opinion, the highest form of contumeliousness.

Milky Transit

Fuck that shit....displaying Nazi symbolism is never cool. I lost some respect for The Melvins. Damn racist bastards!

klump


DirtyProtest

The Nazi's had one helluva art department that's for sure.

klump

a serious note: the nazis didnt know jack shit about real art.
and hitler was actuall a big hypocrit(sic) watching mickey mouse and charlie chaplin movies on his sparetime...he actually loved a commie rodent and a midget jew  :lol:

GrimReaper

If you really want to piss someone off tell them to "suck the dick that  made ya", works every time.

Vcavallo

i am fairly certain the melvins put the designs in place that we are speaking about right now, for that very reason.  to call to attention these issues.  they aren't promoting nazism, are they?  there is a swastika, but not a swastika with a big happy face and a check mark next to it, saying hey look at this thing, it is GOOD.  it is just there to make people think about it.  it is better than just avoiding it, wouldn't you say?  they are just tickling your brain, not advertising.  all these mentioned offensive images are on the INSIDE of the CD packages, assholes.  the only people that see them are the ones that choose to.  buying the trilogy and looking at the swastika on the inside is the same as opening up a notebook, drawing a swastika, and looking at it.  they aren't buying billboard space and displaying these crooked little lines all over the world, so while i see you point (a weak one, at that), you need to realize the impact the melvins' design decisions have on the population, which is in effect, nil.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

idiotboy

I think The Melvins are totally aware of what they are doing with this imagery -

pissing people off

They've been known to do such things in the past with their music - you could even say that they enjoy doing it.

The Melvins are not as some on this bbs would like to think - 'nice guys'. They're cunts.

klump