question: Melvins art and Nazi symbolism

Started by Hank Hill, May 09, 2005, 03:03:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

norecess

Quote from: Vcavalloit is just there to make people think about it.  it is better than just avoiding it, wouldn't you say?

I wish I could agree with you on this one, but I can't. Theoritically it's better to unavoid this subject but it's hard in practice. Especially for my grandma for example who has consciously experienced the war. The difference is most people of my age in Holland have grandparents who actually were there in 40-45. We just stand closer to it I think.

But of course me personally gets the idea of Buzz using swastika's in his art or thanking A. Hilter.

idiotboy

Quote from: klumpcunts are nice...

:lol:  :lol:

Vcavallo

Quote from: norecess
Quote from: Vcavalloit is just there to make people think about it.  it is better than just avoiding it, wouldn't you say?

I wish I could agree with you on this one, but I can't. Theoritically it's better to unavoid this subject but it's hard in practice. Especially for my grandma for example who has consciously experienced the war. The difference is most people of my age in Holland have grandparents who actually were there in 40-45. We just stand closer to it I think.

But of course me personally gets the idea of Buzz using swastika's in his art or thanking A. Hilter.

no man, we are agreeing.  i am saying it is BETTER THAN avoiding it.  as in, it is better to think about big things in many ways, instead of not thinking about them.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

norecess

Quote from: Vcavallo
no man, we are agreeing.  i am saying it is BETTER THAN avoiding it.  as in, it is better to think about big things in many ways, instead of not thinking about them.

Ok, we agree ;]

Indeeeeeeeeed!

deejuks2

here is a bar graph as to why you people are a bunch of chiley weasels.

deejuks2

Quote from: norecess
Quote from: Vcavallo
no man, we are agreeing.  i am saying it is BETTER THAN avoiding it.  as in, it is better to think about big things in many ways, instead of not thinking about them.

Ok, we agree ;]

Indeeeeeeeeed!

indeeeed... Emerson Lake and Kunka?

Vcavallo

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

mumu

Quote from: deejuks2here is a bar graph as to why you people are a bunch of chiley weasels.

Are Chiley Weasels anything like Chilly Willys?

It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

klump

Quote from: norecess
Quote from: Vcavalloit is just there to make people think about it.  it is better than just avoiding it, wouldn't you say?

I wish I could agree with you on this one, but I can't. Theoritically it's better to unavoid this subject but it's hard in practice. Especially for my grandma for example who has consciously experienced the war. The difference is most people of my age in Holland have grandparents who actually were there in 40-45. We just stand closer to it I think.

But of course me personally gets the idea of Buzz using swastika's in his art or thanking A. Hilter.


my grandparents were marines and in the resistance.

mobmob

Quote from: Vcavalloit is just there to make people think about it.  it is better than just avoiding it, wouldn't you say?

it's still the dumbest fashion of making someone "think" about something.
in germany they're still spraypainting svastika's on jewish tombstones,
would you go and tell everyone that's just there to make people "think"?
no you wouldn't. you make people think by providing informations not by
bullshitting them with shallow agenda's and/or nonsensical symbolism.
it's immature and silly, no matter if they're going for pissing people off or
"making them think".

klump

I think Id get mighty pissed off if anyone sprayed a peace sign on my tombstone.

EGO the Living Planet

I think you guys have missed something important about the symbols on the Trilogy vinyl. It's not just that there's a satanic and a christian symbol, a white racist and a black racist symbol and a Nazi and a Jewish symbol.  It's where they are placed. The pentagram is OPPOSITE the cross, the KKK symbol is OPPOSITE the Black Panther, etc. As in "these are different sides of the same coin". The sticker on the front tells you "don't be an idiot". They mean to tell you that getting worked up and fanatical about these things is foolish and dangerous. They're saying don't trust either side. Shock value was intended, but not the reason and they weren't doin' this on a lark. Thgey meant to make you think when they had your attention.

The only hesitation I have involves the Star of David. That is a symbol of Judism as whole, which I don't think is a hate group. You could defiately make an argument that the Zionist movement and certain parts of the State of Isreal (which also use the same symbol) desrve that treatment, but sayin' it about all of Judism wouldn't be fair or acurate (Buzz is jewish, isn't he?)

I encountered some Nazis on the UBL MELVINS board a few years ago. I don't neccesarily have a problem with the way they use the symbols, but I'm afraid the wrong folks are gettin' the wrong message. I would have hoped they'd have learned somethin' from their friend Jello's simaler experiences with that.

Milky Transit

Quote from: EGO the Living PlanetI think you guys have missed something important about the symbols on the Trilogy vinyl. It's not just that there's a satanic and a christian symbol, a white racist and a black racist symbol and a Nazi and a Jewish symbol.  It's where they are placed. The pentagram is OPPOSITE the cross, the KKK symbol is OPPOSITE the Black Panther, etc. As in "these are different sides of the same coin". The sticker on the front tells you "don't be an idiot". They mean to tell you that getting worked up and fanatical about these things is foolish and dangerous. They're saying don't trust either side. Shock value was intended, but not the reason and they weren't doin' this on a lark. Thgey meant to make you think when they had your attention.

The only hesitation I have involves the Star of David. That is a symbol of Judism as whole, which I don't think is a hate group. You could defiately make an argument that the Zionist movement and certain parts of the State of Isreal (which also use the same symbol) desrve that treatment, but sayin' it about all of Judism wouldn't be fair or acurate (Buzz is jewish, isn't he?)

I encountered some Nazis on the UBL MELVINS board a few years ago. I don't neccesarily have a problem with the way they use the symbols, but I'm afraid the wrong folks are gettin' the wrong message. I would have hoped they'd have learned somethin' from their friend Jello's simaler experiences with that.

The symbols would have made more sense had there also been a symbol of an old wart covered lady dropping a hot pile of fecal matter on a wounded dog.

Moebius05


ElGrampo

Quote from: Moebius05My grandfather was a was in the SS.

congratulations!
www.myspace.com/rokkosadventures
www.rokkosadventures.at