melvins rip off bands

Started by THE DON, June 12, 2005, 11:06:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

trust me i'm a stomach


norecess

Really? I always thought they ripped off the Pixies. Or was that during Nevermind?

Reverend Ebeneezer

There are tracks on 'Bleach' which are total take offs of the Melvins. IIRC, the ones Crover drums on are those tracks which most sound like early Melvins...the names escape me at this present moment though, but there are about 3 tracks which are total Melvins worship.

Anyhow, I'm intrigued by this Jucifer band...tell me more. Are they monolithic and heavy like Lysol or fun like Stoner Witch? Any songs I should try and download?
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

bullheaded

Yes, the Melvins and Nirvana were compadres. But even bands like Harvey Milk, had never listened to the Melvins; Yet there are striking similarities. And eventhough Harvey Milk ROCKS, their only influence was themselves and whatever other subliminal influences they had while listening and growing up in their music genre.

turnacus

Unless of course they realize they sound like a band they like, and deny knowing them.

High On Fire has a Melvins influence to them, but I wouldn't say that they rip them off.

Paper Cuts was my favorite Nirvana song. Little did I know it was a ton like the Melvins, and the guy from the Melvins drummed for them on it.
Van Hagar

the melvins

nirvanas Milk it sounds very much like  It's shoved.

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: the melvinsnirvanas Milk it sounds very much like  It's shoved.

which in turn sounds like the Pixies "Gigantic"....i dont know where you people get these comparisons.  The similarities are so small its not even worth mentioning and its ridiculous to say its a rip-off.  Although the bass part to Its Shoved does sound a hell of a lot like the bass part to "Gigantic."

thegrumpylil'hermit

Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerThere are tracks on 'Bleach' which are total take offs of the Melvins. IIRC, the ones Crover drums on are those tracks which most sound like early Melvins...the names escape me at this present moment though, but there are about 3 tracks which are total Melvins worship.

Anyhow, I'm intrigued by this Jucifer band...tell me more. Are they monolithic and heavy like Lysol or fun like Stoner Witch? Any songs I should try and download?

I think you'd definitely like Jucifer.  Overall, they're more like Stoner Witch, but its ridiculous to approach them that way.  Although they've been heavily influenced by the Melvins, they're definitely doing their own thing.  But yes, they are heavy for the most part....sometimes slow and monolithic, sometimes fast and punky and everything in between with some pop sensibility thrown in.  Id start with "Calling All Cars..." or "I Name You Destroyer" first as they're the most comprehensive to date.

the bloat

So what! The Melvins used to sound like Flipper, Black Flag and the Wipers rolled in joint and smoked by Black Sabbath.

It's hard to hide your influences when you are first starting out. Can I get a WHAT UP Idaho!!!!???

norecess

The intro of PJ's alive shows some similarities with Love Thing.

anaconda

Boris
Totimoshi
Camel Clutch
Frog Pond
The Blippos

... many are influenced and don't even know it.

Leroy

Quote from: thegrumpylil'hermit
Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerThere are tracks on 'Bleach' which are total take offs of the Melvins. IIRC, the ones Crover drums on are those tracks which most sound like early Melvins...the names escape me at this present moment though, but there are about 3 tracks which are total Melvins worship.

Anyhow, I'm intrigued by this Jucifer band...tell me more. Are they monolithic and heavy like Lysol or fun like Stoner Witch? Any songs I should try and download?

I think you'd definitely like Jucifer.  Overall, they're more like Stoner Witch, but its ridiculous to approach them that way.  Although they've been heavily influenced by the Melvins, they're definitely doing their own thing.  But yes, they are heavy for the most part....sometimes slow and monolithic, sometimes fast and punky and everything in between with some pop sensibility thrown in.  Id start with "Calling All Cars..." or "I Name You Destroyer" first as they're the most comprehensive to date.



Jucifer also sounds kinda like Houdini, in a way.  Bits of it are like Bullhead and Lysol, If I remember correctly.  .  But the singer's (Amber)  voice is really light and soft (most of the time), which adds a nice contrast.  At times they are as raw as the Melvins, but at other times they're almost jazzy.  Yeah, I'd probably start off with "I Name You Destroyer".  They have 12 or 13 amps on stage.  It's kinda weird seeing that little woman stand and rock out in front of all those amps, but their shows are awesome.  The drumming is tight too.  Not really as much uniqueness as Crover, but still pretty damn good.

cellphone

QuoteThe intro of PJ's alive shows some similarities with Love Thing.

guess that would make it a KISS ripoff then

The Wise Shotgun

Quote from: norecessI disagree. There is a difference between ripping off a band or be influenced by a band.
Yeah, There's Stealing & Borrowing Without Permission. Just Kidding, I Actually Agree With Norecess, Even Though Most Of Them SUCK.

RichieGoodtimes

The answer is Black Sabbath.

It all comes from Black Sabbath.