buzz's comments re: joe preston ep

Started by blipntime, August 03, 2005, 12:27:12 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: Andy
You could argue that 'Eye Flys' has Thrones written all over it and that came out long before Joe was anywhere near the picture.

I thought ManMtn used the Eye Flys intro as something of a joke...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

blipntime

I dont think the Melvins owe us anything. But that whole "envision, execute" rhetoric he keeps giving the fans (the last few releases have featured a lot of self indulgent liner notes so yes it is aimed at the fans and it seems more like defensive posturing because he knows the majority of the listeners will think "Why the hell did I just shell out money for this crap?)  when he is merely referring to releasing whatever he wants and he knows it will sell.
Colossus Of Destiny was terrible. The Fantomas/Melvins Big Band thing was dreadful. And how many shitty sounding versions of At A Crawl can one person need? The song was not THAT good. The whole Melvins legacy seems to have gone to Buzz's head. How about write several good songs, record them, and release THAT? The last several releases and tours have relied upon additional instrumentation and guest artists, and they still are playing primarily shit from 10 or 15 years ago. Buzz has made a big deal that he can churn out stuff like Stoner Witch easy but he chooses not to. Hey whatever. As long as its a song, fine. I have purchased about 50 Melvins CDs---Had to buy their catalogue twice because my house burned down. My point is, he prides himself on the fact that hes releasing self indulgent tripe. Prick was okay---it was sandwiched between Stoner Witch and Houdini. And that was the beauty of the Melvins for so long, and it can all be summed up in one song....Magic Pig Detective. That encompasses the whole Melvins aesthetic, or at least it did at the time. Mind blowing noise that makes you wonder what the fuck and then kick ass rock and roll that was weird AND heavy. HAT was alright. It would have been a better EP. But Electroretard, COD, Melvins/Fantomas, POTRE, and two Jello Biafra releases, and there are maybe two decent original songs on all the releases combined. One good cover. And a bunch of shit that was rehashed. Something like Honky which was half Melvins dicking around and half Melvins trying was acceptable to a degree. I mean if the Melvins insist on irritating people pointlessly not only in concert but on record at least give us half an album. But record after record of shit that I could do on my 4 track if I were that bored is pretty discouraging.
Its almost like "TAKING DRUGS TO MAKE MUSIC TO TAKE DRUGS TO," but they dont take drugs anymore so its really lame and boring.

Its like Buzz is progressively releasing a box set, but skipping the career retrospective aspect of it. That unreleased "here's this one time back in 93 that I loaded up on pineapple juice and squeezed a few off into a Shure SM 57 and caught it all on DAT
and you have the honor of listening to my genius" is pretty pointless unless there is some real music along with it as contrast.

The Melvins in 1983 were not THAT interesting that we need several versions of the same songs we've been hearing for 20 years. I would however be very interested in hearing alternate versions of songs from Ozma onward. GLUEY PORCH TREATMENTS IS NOT AS GREAT AS EVERYONE HAS TOLD BUZZ IT IS. Its the shit that came after Ozma that was truly worthwhile and really brilliant. Why? Because in addition to being heavy Melvins glory, there are a lot of dynamics at play. Ozma and Gluey were 35 or so songs that all blur together. Then they put out Bullhead and people thought they sold out because they decided to put some songcraft into it? Nonsense.

As a hardcore Melvins fan, I feel obligated to purchase their new stuff because I might be surprised. But I feel like I'm buying a Britney Spears album blindfolded. I might like one song on the album, ya know, if I'm fucking lucky.

I have been into the Melvins for a while, not as long as some, but around the time of Stoner Witch. And there used to be a lot of anticipation and excitement and there were a lot of good releases in a short period of time. Now that they have Mike Patton letting them do whatever they want they are just resting on their laurels. Maybe they could use some fucking editorial input. They are "raging against the machine," but there is no machine now, so its pointless noise. As opposed to purposeful noise, done much more effectively by a lot of the stoner type bands out there.

anaconda

i like that Spacemen 3 reference up there.

Vcavallo

i think pigs of the roman empire is a great example of collaboration and experimentation paying off.  i find the writing on that album to be really interesting, and lustmord's input makes it perfect, in my opinion.  
i'm looking forward to the next project with lustmord.  

blip, why didn't you like POTRE?
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

popeye

...I love Collossus of Destiny.

blipntime

i seem to remember liking pigs of the roman empire, but i have a really short attention span. it sounds good. it really does. it just isnt very interesting. ive not been able to sit and listen to the whole thing. just bits and pieces at various times. tell ya what lets do---i'll put it on my ipod and listen to it today in its entirety from start to finish. then ill give an updated opinion. im sure its one of their stronger collaborations. only one or two songs jumped out at me from it. and they werent very memorable. HAT and all prior releases I havent had a problem with...but maybe it is me.

Joe Deutrom

The Melvins "owe" us a "Melvins" album or before long their fans are going to get tired of all this meaningless novelty stuff like Nike Air Crovers, Buzz Force One's, art book this and joke book that. When are we going to see the Melvins on David Letterman?

Vcavallo

hahahh air crover...

blip, i agree with you there, it is tough to listen to the whole thing at once..  i'm looking forward to your updated opinion.  it's always interesting to listen to music with the intention of forming an opinion on it.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

cellphone

I almost started to read that book of a post blipntime wrote, until I saw how long it would take.

GrimReaper

Blips iconoclastic ranting is well worth the time to read.

I like how the Melvins are re-packaging their old stuff. I have been satisfied with all this stuff since the Bootlicker, the Melvins last "Melvins" release since HAT:

Crybaby is a collaboration

COD live album

ElectroRetard remixes and covers

26 Songs a reissue

Millinium MonterWorks - Live

GPT a reissue

Mangled Demos unreleased songs from 1983

Venomus Concept

Fantomas release DC

Fantomas the new one

Altamont Our Darling

Neither Here Nor There a book

Porn Wine Women and Song

Tomahawk two releases

Salad of A Thousand Delights DVD

Pigs of the Roman Empire w/Lustmord

Never Breath What you Can't See

Jellvins EP unreleased

Add in HAT to this.

This is a lot of fucken music. Surely you an pick out something in this list you will like. If nothing else the selection is good. For fucks sake just look at that body of work since the Trilogy. Throw in the countless tours they have done.

And the beauty is purchase is not manditory.

mumu

Quote from: cellphoneI almost started to read that book of a post blipntime wrote, until I saw how long it would take.

:lol:  :lol:  :lol:
It's all fucking good-dini as far as I'm concerned. Then again, I'd eat a MELVINS deep fried turd. GO MELVINS!!

-Smellis[/i]

cellphone

Quote from: blipntimei seem to remember liking pigs of the roman empire, but i have a really short attention span. it sounds good. it really does. it just isnt very interesting. ive not been able to sit and listen to the whole thing. just bits and pieces at various times. tell ya what lets do---i'll put it on my ipod and listen to it today in its entirety from start to finish. then ill give an updated opinion. im sure its one of their stronger collaborations. only one or two songs jumped out at me from it. and they werent very memorable. HAT and all prior releases I havent had a problem with...but maybe it is me.

I hope you're not one of those people who sit and stare at their stereo/ipod/8-track while listening to music.

TGH

Quote from: GrimReaperVenomus Concept
.

That albums fuckins rocks.
This isn't a time for lectures!

blipntime2

I hope you're not one of those people who sit and stare at their stereo/ipod/8-track while listening to music.[/quote]


Only if the drugs are quality.

Hey I think my recent diatribes got me kicked out of here. It wouldnt let me log in at all, and I had to register again. Everyone is out to get me.

cellphone