"We Reach" The Music of The Melvins

Started by mothra665, August 27, 2005, 02:09:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Chris Jonasson

Quote from: AlmightyRetard
I just heard someone is also missing out on a copy of Hairspray Queens' "Toilet Dive Extended Dance Re-mix"

Aw crap! All right, you win I lose! Let's end this pointless spamming before we get banned! See you in bed darling...

Galvano

Quote from: AlmightyRetard
Quote from: GalvanoShould've saved your money, it blows.

Shit man, you got some serious complaining going on these days

I try.



Dog Tired

Why does the Mare cover sound nothing like Night  Goat?

The mastodon cover has no bite.
The DEP cover sounds like a DEP song which is cool.
I remember EHG blows and Dog Fashion Disco is great.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Hey thanks for posting Conda!

But what the fuck is up with that 'version' of Night Goat. It's a piss take, I assume? Why can't that bloke from Dillinger bring himself to try, oh say, singing for once?!?

The Mastodon cover's awesome! Really respectful. I'm loving the Eyehategod 'Easy as it was' too...probably my fave track on it thus far. Anyway, going to go listen to the rest of it now...mind you, wasn't there a version of Laughing at Lucifer... from someone on this at some point?

EDIT: Hmm...not sure I like what SYL have done with Zodiac, but at least they've put their own spin on it. The Pig Destroyer and HOF covers aren't great...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

turnacus

Van Hagar

Rusty Shackleford

thanks big black.

nightgoat?   :?

i do like the shevil cover a bit.   :twisted:

moose

There's plenty of good renditions on there. Meatjack Strapping Young Lad Mastadon area ll good. I like that the Mare cover is totally unlike the song. If all the bands were just doing straightforward covers, I'd be disappointed. Not that it always works. :roll: who's Dave?
Well, we'll always have "In the Air Tonight." Will that be your most enduring song?
You know, that song won't lie down. It just won't go away. I mean, there's a Mike Tyson moment associated with it now. It's just bizarre. I guess it has a bit of mystery, a lot of atmosphere, and the drums coming in, pinning people to the wall.

Vcavallo

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

i just listened to it now.  i must say that i am quite happy with the whole thamn ding!  i was expecting garbage by all of your reviews, but i am really enjoying it!!  you guys make me feel like there is something wrong with me for liking it, since most of you venomously dislike it...
i don't know what else to say except this is a very entertaining album, when taken for what it is.  
sure some of the note for note covers were a bit disappointing creatively, but it is always interesting to hear another band's sound underneath a familiar song, and especially to hear different vocals.

liked dog fashion disco's alot.

is what was posted the whole CD?
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

this just reinforces for me that nobody drums like crover.  (or records drums like the melvins do).  he's WILD
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

TGH

Quote from: Vcavallo
is what was posted the whole CD?

No, it's missing the last six songs (too lazy to name them.) I really liked the Bar X cover, though.
This isn't a time for lectures!

jeremy

I don't mind The Bit & Anaconda, Night goat had me laughing.

TGH

Quote from: monkey drummerI don't mind The Bit & Anaconda, Night goat had me laughing.

If they didn't use the drum line; I would have never known it was even supposed to resemble a song.

Oh, I must say CKY should win for doing the most clever cover on the whole album (even though CKY sucks.)
This isn't a time for lectures!