"We Reach" The Music of The Melvins

Started by mothra665, August 27, 2005, 02:09:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

klump

that was actually funny.

the shevil cover is okay too.

Kurva

that pincer song just slays!!!!!!! I wish the whole album would be like this! and it would be melviny.
yeah Pike ta-tata-at-tat--atatat-ting Creepy Smell. That would have been great.
anyway, some parts, theyve done perfectly, but some I cant follow.

the bloat

QuoteThis is the only band website I could find for them:
http://www.pincermetal.co.uk/

There's no way that could be the same band! Pincer are way too lame to even know who the Melvins are let alone crap out a cover like this. Pincer needs to stick to what they know best: takin' it up the butt and listening to Papa Roach with headphones so as not to disturb anyone.

Green Honey

indeed, this pincer are from a town i used to live in, ashton-under-lyne!
the band on the tribute are called pincer 2 anyway...

GrimReaper

It just dawned on me where I heard the guitar solo by Absentee  in "Revolve" on the tribute "We Reach". It's from "American Woman" by the Guess Who.

Don't fucken believe me? Ask any Canadian.

Galvano

Quote from: Dudbean
I almost spit out my dog's cock

What was it doing in your mouth in the first place?

Hank Hill

I liked the Mastodon and High on Fire covers best . . .  :shock:

Hateyouhumans

Quote from: Dog TiredWhy does the Mare cover sound nothing like Night  Goat?

I remember EHG blows

you are so wrong, i'm so sorry
Before beauty dissapears entirely from the earth, it will go on existing for a while by accident.
-Milan Kundera

Hateyouhumans

there is not a bad band on this comp, probably one of the best tribute albums i've ever heard, not that that says much... bad brains CM tribute is good (i never thought i'd say i like a moby track) and the sonic youth tribute has racebannon, steel pole bath tub and tub ring, so it's not half bad......
Before beauty dissapears entirely from the earth, it will go on existing for a while by accident.
-Milan Kundera

the bloat

IMO, this comp is strickly average. With any tribute record, you're going to have some bad songs. The tribute to Zeppelin that came out in the 90's should have been really good right? With such a great band, there couldn't be a bad interpretation. But there was.  There were several. "Custard Pie" was cool.

I think that the best cover I have heard on a comp (and obviously I haven't heard them all) was Weezer's cover of the Pixies "Veloria". I'm not even a big Weezer fan, but they hit the nail on the fucking head.  I think that is hard to do, especially with a band as unique as the MELVINS.

Chuck Ufarley

I thought this sucked.
Glad I got it free.
I make better music with my armpit.

Mesteren

Quote from: the bloatWith any tribute record, you're going to have some bad songs.

You're wrong. In the 90's there was a tribute record to Billy Joel - with absolutely NO music on it. Not one bad track. 666 copies.
To be afraid when you are alone, in the dark, faced with the unknown, the unspeakable; that is understandable fear. To be afraid, mortally afraid, in broad daylight, in a crowded city street, that is to know Melvins.

Hateyouhumans

Quote from: Mesteren
Quote from: the bloatWith any tribute record, you're going to have some bad songs.

You're wrong. In the 90's there was a tribute record to Billy Joel - with absolutely NO music on it. Not one bad track. 666 copies.

i choose to believe
Before beauty dissapears entirely from the earth, it will go on existing for a while by accident.
-Milan Kundera

Snufkin

Wow, I must be the only one that actually enjoys it, Mastodon's contribution is awesome. Really liking Dillinger Escape Plan's Honey Bucket.

Also liking Shevil, Joan Of Arc and Boris. Also Revolve is pretty cool.

mopafeena

I'm having a lot of trouble finding a copy. Wish i could, i'm dying to hear it. Might have to resort to internet shopping once again.
www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband