Follow up to "We Reach" Melvins tribute

Started by the bloat, August 30, 2005, 05:16:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

the bloat

Now that many of you are aware of the track listing on this recent compilation, have any of you asked yourselves why there is nothing really current being covered. I mean the newest song on there is "Laughing.." which was released 8 years ago. Why aren't any of the songs on the Trilogy, HAT or POTRE represented?

My question is, are the Melvins newest albums influencial to anyone or are they just riding the coatails of the genre that they invented 20 years ago?

anaconda

Should I post the mp3s I have from We Reach Volume 2??

the bloat

Don't play with my emotions like that....I don't know if I can take it. I need to hear "Black Santa" covered by Ween

anaconda

hahahha you do make a good point though, is it just that theyve gone back underground and no one knows the new stuff, or is it that these bands like the older stuff better so they decided to cover those songs instead of new stuff.. :?:

Vcavallo

it's the latter.

these bands can't cope with creativity.  they only want volume and rock
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

AlmightyRetard

Quote from: Vcavalloit's the latter.

these bands can't cope with creativity.  they only want volume and rock

:lol:
I like fucking corpses

Galvano

They all want to look like old school Melvins fans so they picked something old.  :lol:

Vcavallo

i should say, as much as i enjoyed the tracks, i am pretty disappointed with the featured bands.  i thought there'd be some much finer musical groups with love for the melvins, as opposed to a bunch of meatrock crap...anyone know what i mean?  half these bands are pretty...shallow?.  i was expecting some more musically inspired artists, not drunken metal heads.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Kessel

Quote from: Vcavallohalf these bands are pretty...shallow?.  i was expecting some more musically inspired artists, not drunken metal heads.


I have to totally agree.
Though i "could" listen to some of the bands that play on this tribute if i had to, i do not plan to.

None of them appeal to me... and i would love to know Buzz's true thoughts on it.

Dillinger Escape Plan....jesus...
For life is not happy.

Vcavallo

yea.  that's why i said half, because some are listenable at times.
i'd like to know what buzz thinks as well.  i have a feeling he'd kinda roll his eyes and say something sort of cryptic that he expects everyone to understand about how he doesn't like them.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

groundmeat

I think they are covering older songs because the newer ones haven't had time to become classic yet.

anaconda

maybe, but how cool would it have been to hear one of these newer bands tackle something off HAT?  like HOF doing the anti-vermin seed or something... opportunities lost

groundmeat

To me at least, most Melvins songs are perfect as they are. From the we reach volume I think I prefer only the first two tracks to the originals - and that's only because I hate Houdini. But that said, I enjoyed the covers but not as much as I was expecting to.

Another reason these guys might be covering older songs is because a lot of these bands are heavy, metal bands and the Melvins took a fairly hard left turn towards experimentation since stag. They may just not appreicate the weirdness of the newer releases at a gut level. But who the hell knows.

Vcavallo

Quote from: groundmeat...But who the hell knows.
you don't have to say that.  you are totally correct.  stand by it
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

klump

it would be really cool to hear ween, beck,Vaz,smoke and smoke,meshuggah, melt banana,