Melvins mentioned in new york times.

Started by groundmeat, September 17, 2005, 02:36:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

norecess

Quote from: dusteri think isis is pretty overrated. the vocals are embarrassing, as well. i still like them, they just get too much credit

I have never quite understood the meaning of 'overrating'. To me it depends on what or who is overrating. If it's the good ones who are overrating, I don't care. Long live worshipping.

norecess

Quote from: GalvanoOh I don't take it personally, I just think it's a cheap shot at trying to gain cred.

Well, it depends on the band. Eventually people will judge the band itself, not their influences.

Alvin

Quote from: norecess
Quote from: GalvanoOh I don't take it personally, I just think it's a cheap shot at trying to gain cred.

Well, it depends on the band. Eventually people will judge the band itself, not their influences.

that would be nice if that were the case. it doesn't seem that way though, since things like the beatles and hendrix and particularly nirvana are constantly sited for their influence on other bands, as opposed to just being good. i think people do stuff like that because it's just an easy observation to make whereas actually describing what you think is great about their music is subjective to some extent and is a lot harder to do unless you're eloquent. people like to make observations that make them look intelligent probably. i just realized i might've interpreted your post wrong. oh well.

Vcavallo

Quote from: Alvinthat would be nice if that were the case. it doesn't seem that way though, since things like the beatles and hendrix and particularly nirvana are constantly sited for their influence on other bands, as opposed to just being good. i think people do stuff like that because it's just an easy observation to make whereas actually describing what you think is great about their music is subjective to some extent and is a lot harder to do unless you're eloquent. people like to make observations that make them look intelligent probably. i just realized i might've interpreted your post wrong. oh well.

Perfect.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Kessel

Quotepeople like to make observations that make them look intelligent probably

Yes they do.
For life is not happy.

norecess

Quote from: Alvinthat would be nice if that were the case. it doesn't seem that way though, since things like the beatles and hendrix and particularly nirvana are constantly sited for their influence on other bands, as opposed to just being good. i think people do stuff like that because it's just an easy observation to make whereas actually describing what you think is great about their music is subjective to some extent and is a lot harder to do unless you're eloquent. people like to make observations that make them look intelligent probably. i just realized i might've interpreted your post wrong. oh well.

Amen. I definitely agree with you although I was more referring to MTV or NME or other pop magazines who already praise artists before they've even been on tour or have released a decent album instead of referring to bands. In fact, I don't think a lot of bands have been influenced by Nirvana at all. Or am I being naive now? Well yeah, Puddle of Mud or those kind of crappy bands maybe a bit musically. But as you say, they'll never understand what they really stood for.

Fuck I'm stoned. Was this thread about overrating or namedropping. Argh, I'll read this tomorrow when I'm sober.

'Submit'

norecess

Quote from: boll
Quotepeople like to make observations that make them look intelligent probably

Yes they do.

Maybe that's why we all like the Melvins.

Kessel

For life is not happy.

norecess

I'm not sure if it is. Besides, the music's first, but the position the Melvins have chosen in the music business is an interesting one. Lately I've been wondering what it is that I like the Melvins so much that I think about the Melvins on daily basis. When I first saw them live, I actually went for Tomahawk in the first place, but during the Melvins' set, I was completely overwhelmed. At that time I only knew the Bootlicker, which is - as I see it now - one of the worst albums to start with, not that's a bad album, not at all. I guess it also helped that Kurt Cobain liked them. This may sound like a 14 year old complaing how Kurt is God and everything, but it definitely helped me liking them. When I got more interested in the Melvins with albums as Houdini and Stoner Witch, I started doing more review on 'em, and I found out how important and original and unique and experimental they have always been. Or, and that's what I'm trying to point out, maybe that's just what I wanted to believe. And still do. Maybe I, or all of us on this forum, just want them to be the best band ever, except for Gonzo of course who rather whorships King Crimson ;] Also, the Melvins definitely help us to consider them that way in many ways: the lyrics, goofy interviews, the artwork on Stoner Witch, Mackie's artwork, Nikes, a Melvins foetus for fucks sake, a coffee table book, just anything. So have I chosen the Melvins for the music, or because of how they're positioned in the history and present of music? Maybe my empathy is too big. Or the hash is working really good. I'm curious if anyone else here has ever thought about the reason that they like the Melvins so much. I doubt if their music is the only reason.

Joe Deutrom

The Melvins are unlike any band I know of. I value their music. I appreciate the hard work and struggles Buzz and Dale have done and been through to keep their music fresh and original after twenty years. I am not one who has to have every little novelty they have put out. I leave that to the "collectors" and avid to the point of insanity fan boys (if there are any). But I understand it has to do with their bent sense of humor. I hope success on them, just as long as it does not interfere with their music, which they have already proven with great albums: Houdini, Stoner Witch and Stag. But at the same time, I dig their iconoclastic ways. And it is not a fake monkey wrench thrown into the machine; it is utterly honest. The Melvins are an education on music.  To me, I liken the Melvins to the cleansing rain Travis Bickle describes in Taxi Driver, a rain that should fall and wash all the filth away. As a musician, I highly esteem Buzz and Dale's skill with their instruments. So yeah, it's more than the music itself.

Vcavallo

norecess,  
while the hash may be working real hard, i think you are speaking deep truths.
i know exactly what you mean.  i feel very strongly that the melvins' music is wildly experimental and their aura is so avant-garde.  then....i start to really think about it, and i wonder if i just want to believe that.  the realization comes when you are trying to expose someone else to the band and you find that you don't quite know what it is you like about them, and when you try to exemplify it to your subject, it is next to impossible.  one will always find oneself saying, oh wait, not this song, this one is slightly more mainstream, there is is one though that has this thing in it that's really cool....hmm....
then again, i often feel that it is this unnameable vibration about the melvins that one can't describe to others, that other-worldly sound between their notes which makes me love them, and simultaneously prohibits me from justifying my obsession to others.
i am not going to go back and proof this, because i have other things to do right now, though i suspect there are alot of circular ideas and run-ons.
i just wanted to tell you, norecess that i understand exactly how you feel, and many a times i have wondered about my intense feelings for the melvins.  wondered if i am creating a band of my dreams in my mind because i want one so bad, or if they really are that band.

ah...but then you see them live, and remember that it is the real deal....

then again, you put the residents on, and realize what true experimentation and avant-garde is, and you wish the melvins would stop being so monotonously straight-forward sometimes..

last thing, i promise:  sometimes the fact that they come off as straight-forward, yet when you listen 100 times and really consider the music, you realize that you have no idea what the fuck is going on in the song writing, or the tone just astounds you, or buzz's voice comes through so powerfully, or you just are able to, for a second, sense that THING in their music, and you think, "holy fuck"!  i thought this was just a regular song, but it is NOT!! this is something else all together! this isn't even music...this is pure, raw, sonic art.  the CONCEPT of non-objective art, embodied in a sound wave, and you realize that the melvins are doing something wholly amazing, and it is embedded in this mystical secret that few people on the planet in the middle of space are keen to.  

fuck, it's amazing. i love the melvins.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

Quote from: Joe DeutromTo me, I liken the Melvins to the cleansing rain Travis Bickle describes in Taxi Driver, a rain that should fall and wash all the filth away. As a musician, I highly esteem Buzz and Dale's skill with their instruments. So yeah, it's more than the music itself.

good one, man.  i like that.

about their bent sense of humor....i've noticed that they aren't really very funny in person.  in interviews and on video they are kinda like dumbasses, and they think they are funny themselves, but i don't really find it amusing. like in the rock squad video i posted, they are talking about being on tour, something about wearing a wedding ring, and if you don't wear one that means you are gay, or something similarly stupid.  i mean, gay jokes?  come on.  and that voice dale does is just sort of dumb...
but here's the thing!  their sense of humor in music and packaging and career direction and all that stuff is fantastic!  it's like proof that the essences of some personalities don't exist in all dimensions and forms of matter.  buzz's comes out better in that indeterminate way, rather than in words.
there was this one show where he started lecturing the audience about something involving submarines and polar ice caps or something and i found it very very funny.
as long as they keep entertaining themSELVES, it's fine with me.  that's what seems to fuel them and that's what's important.  
damn i'll be sad and quite depressed when one of them dies.........ouch, i can feel it.


^loser
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

DubEMC

I've got a few Isis and Pelican discs I don't listen to much.
I did enjoy the article though.

norecess

Quote from: Vcavallonorecess,  
while the hash may be working real hard, i think you are speaking deep truths.

See, drugs are good.

Quotethe realization comes when you are trying to expose someone else to the band and you find that you don't quite know what it is you like about them, and when you try to exemplify it to your subject, it is next to impossible.  one will always find oneself saying, oh wait, not this song, this one is slightly more mainstream, there is is one though that has this thing in it that's really cool....hmm....

Exactly, I have not succeed once yet to confirm a friend of mine of the genius of the Melvins. They just don't hear it. That's one of the things that started to think me of all this, am I the only one who hears it because I just want to hear it?.

It's good to read you understand what I was trying to say.

norecess

Quote from: DudbeanI bought Oceanic by Isis a while back. Then I returned it.
Really? I should do that too actually with a few CD's, never really thought about that option.

By the way, to me The Beginning and the End has one of the best intros ever.

QuoteMaybe their other stuff is better. For their sake, I hope so.

Their early stuff sounds like a crossover of Godflesh and hardcore. Later on, they have obviously chosen the direction of post-rock, and I like it. Just like I enjoy Mogwai, Explosions In The Sky, GY!BE, Mono etc. You shouldn't even try Panopticon I think, it will dissapoint you. Try Saw Blade or The Red See instead.