Melvins mentioned in new york times.

Started by groundmeat, September 17, 2005, 02:36:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

groundmeat

Since vcavallo and norecess were talking about what makes Melvins' music unique, let me just put in my $0.02 since I have thought about this a lot. I am not a professional musician, or anything  but I noticed the following musical 'tricks' that the Melvins use.

- Their songs usually have no melody whatsoever - but are hook laden and rocking. This is really bizzare as even the most extreme bands seem to have some form of melody along with hooks (or they just don't have any hooks at all). They play 'catchy', hooky yet non-melodic songs. I have no idea how they do this.


- They will play spectacularly ugly (but interesting) bits before they go into something that rocks more traditionally - but then they will stop that very quickly and so it leaves you wanting more. I think that's why I can listen to their songs over and over again, while other bands get boring very quickly.

- Buzz has an uncanny ability to come up with lyrics that don't make sense on paper but when combined with the music seems to reveal my innermost thoughts and feelings - case in point - "we riiiiiiiseee" when the chugging starts in the fool, the meddling idiot.

norecess

Interesting post, groundmeat. I'm not sure if your findings go up for all Melvins songs, but it gives a pretty good impression of Melvins songs I think. The most important reason however are our very own imaginations I think. I often idolize my favorite bands by reading interviews with them, read some background information on them, go to forums like this one and then create my own perfect world around 'em where they of course fit in perfectly. Of course this sounds a bit banal, but that's pretty much what I do with any bands I start to like.

GOOO-ING, MEEENTAL

Green Honey

Quote from: groundmeat...."we riiiiiiiseee"...
nah i think it's more likely "we riiiide (at zero)" but i think i get your point.

klump

Quote from: Green Honey
Quote from: groundmeat...."we riiiiiiiseee"...
nah i think it's more likely "we riiiide (at zero)" but i think i get your point.


here we go again :)

hehe

Green Honey


Vcavallo

Quote from: Green Honey
Quote from: groundmeat...."we riiiiiiiseee"...
nah i think it's more likely "we riiiide (at zero)" but i think i get your point.
not to start a lyric argument, but i do agree
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

groundmeat

norecess - yeah, I think interviews etc. also helps create a personality for the band that affects appreciation of the band.

And as for the "we riiiise" bit, I think you guys are talking about "we ride (at zero)"  that comes at 4:10 while the we rise bit comes on about 3:50. :)

The way I hear it : We rise from never/nowhere, nothing can or will rise, with fire at zero - makes sense to me personally. But then again I am not good at decyphyring lyrics.

Green Honey

Quote from: groundmeatAnd as for the "we riiiise" bit, I think you guys are talking about "we ride (at zero)"  that comes at 4:10 while the we rise bit comes on about 3:50. :)

The way I hear it : We rise from never/nowhere, nothing can or will rise, with fire at zero - makes sense to me personally. But then again I am not good at decyphyring lyrics.
oh yeah i got it mixed up. but after listening really closely -
while at the same time appreciating the fact that buzz lyrics
are often nonsense - this is my best effort:

We ride
For never
Nothing can or will arrive
We fight
At zero

if you want to see the rest of the lyrics mine are at the bottom of this page:
http://www.themelvins.net/bbs/viewtopic.php?t=3670

Vcavallo

Quote from: Green HoneyWe ride
For never
Nothing can or will arrive
We fight
At zero

i must say i think you are dead-on.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Green Honey


cellphone

Despite most of those metal bands being really different from eachother, I think the article is a reaction to the general migration away from dungeons and dragon themed metal to metal for metal's sake.  I really wish metal bands could get away from the fake screaming and fart singing, not to mention CLICKY DOUBLECLICKS, but despite that they're at least doing something different.  Even if Isis and Pelican are really just boring.

ManWithNoName

I've seen Isis and they're very boring live. I couldn't tell which songs were which. They all sounded the same.

glen

two things,            I'm going with "fight at zero", but isn't that the fun of Buzz's lyrics? I think they are interpreted by the fans (us) exactly as the writer would want. it's kinda like "fill in the blanks as you see fit."  would buzz be heartbroken if he thought people were misinterpreting his lyrics? I'm thinking "no" here.  70% of what your hearing your TRYING to decipher into words when there are no words there per say. I could say the lyrics are:  "wee bite at see row, nud thing kan ore we will rize" and probably get away with it.  (not that I think thats what they are, just making a point)
second thing:  ISIS sucks,   there I said it, I hope your all happy.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

Joe Deutrom

All I can say is the music world would be a lot crappier if the Melvins did not exist. Can I get an amen, brothers and sisters!

Vcavallo

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo