"We Reach" review at indieworkshop.com

Started by the bloat, October 11, 2005, 10:14:32 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

the bloat


norecess

So is it just SYL performing Zodiac or SYL + Fear Factory?

rimb

Quote from: norecess on October 11, 2005, 02:26:43 PM
So is it just SYL performing Zodiac or SYL + Fear Factory?

Just SYL.  It's also a bonus track on the Korean version of their Alien ablum.


GrimReaper


What's that guy talking about, the cover of Claude is outstanding.

anaconda

he's probably never even heard the original to compare them.

youllneverbe

Pig Destroyer's old 'Oven' cover is pretty good as well.

the bloat

I have decided to give this release another chance. I am really starting to like it!

This weekend, I threw the disk into a CD player with a really good speaker set up and cranked it letting the buttrock rain over me and you know what......It kinda kicked my ass. The cover of 'Claude' and 'Zodiac' were astounding and stayed true to the Melvins' original intentions except now, the songs had the full sound quality that they always deserved. I still HATE the cover art, but I think I am going to start playing this disk a lot more.

anaconda

see! this proves my point that people still buy the cd even when theyve got the mp3s for free.

klump

Quote from: anaconda on October 17, 2005, 04:40:30 PM
see! this proves my point that people still buy the cd even when theyve got the mp3s for free.

yeah most records , but not this one cause it sucked.  :lol:

Leroy

the album is so-so.  Nothing special, but nothing horrible.   but if someone is a big fan of a lot of those bands on there, then they would probably like it more.

cellphone

this tribute album fucking sucks.

you pretty much know a band sucks when they like to talk/sing along with samples, and whatever the hell band that is does that with hog leg...lame.

anaconda

thats Billy Anderson's band Blessing The Hogs doing Hog Leg.