Case study on jello and the melvins [part 1]. PLEASE VOTE

Started by Vcavallo, October 18, 2005, 07:54:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

To find out whether or not being a DK fan past or present has any effect on how an individual receives the jelvins album, i'd appreciate it if everyone participated in this.  you too, lurkers.  

i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am/was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener/enjoyer of DK and i like -- strongly like SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a lister/enjoyer of DK and i dislike -- strongly dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am not/never was a listener of DK and i neither like, nor dislike SEIG HOWDY
i am a melvins fan and past/present listener of DK and i have not listened to the album
i am a melvins fan and not/never have been a listener of DK and haven't listened to the album

Vcavallo

glad to hear it.  you are among my favorites, as you know

awwwww  :love:  :oops:    i love emoti CONS
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

i am genuinely interested for my own curiosity.  actually, you touched on one of the most important reasons.  halo of flies with jello singing is god-awful.  i think this, you think this, i believe many others do.  i want to see if people like this album mostly because they like jello already, or if they don't really have much experience with him, yet still think it is quality music.  both results should be enlightening. 
i didn't want to say too much about this in beginning because i don't want anyone to purposefully vote differently in order to make jello look different or something.  that's why i hid the results pre voting, and disallowed re-voting. 

i'll write a short discourse analyzing the data.  <--?

i love you too dud, you know that.  :wink:  :shock:

you can see already that only one DK listener disliked it...however, only one NON-DK listener disliked it as well, so i don't know....to confess i voted "neither like nor dislike" (i think).  if i really consider it, i don't NOT like it..it has its moments, but i hardly enjoy it, so that was the best choice for me.  it seems like most of the population doesn't care about it either way, likes it, or hasn't heard it.  not too many haters. 

i hope more votes come in.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Pastor Of Muppets

Sorry for being the odd one out here but I love Halo Of Flies. I've never heard the Alice Cooper version but I doubt everyone here is a huge Alice Cooper fan and that's the reason they can't handle Jellos voice.
By the way Vcavallo you are a true gent. Thanks so much for the House of Blues concert. It's brilliant. Know where I can get some other Melvins videos or even just their music videos. I've only ever seen Queen and Hooch.

Vcavallo

thanks!
i had them all up on my site a few weeks ago. 
i'm going to be putting up another live show soon with much better video quality.  after that i guess i'll put the music videos back.  or we can arrange something and i can send them to you directly.  email me.

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

meanclown

Hey there -

Some interesting discussion here - as a crusty old fart myself, and one  who is a huge fan of the original Alice Cooper Group (ACG, hereafter), and a big Melvins fan, and a Jello supporter  to boot....I gotta tip my hat to the boys  for covering what's quite possibly the most epic & phenominal of all Cooper Group  tunes - I suspect that it was done out of sheer respect & yes, maybe even  love of the  tune/the ACG /the genre...it takes guts to cover a song  like that in this day & age of homoginized muck. In fact, wasn't "Halo"  the  inspiration behind  the collaboration between Melvins & Jello to begin with?  It's not an easy tune to play...it's a real endurance test at times (just try playing that bass riff over & over & over during the drum solo - it's a work-out...for those who have not heard the original, I strongly recommend seeking out a copy)....also, a three-piece band "scaling down" an  arrangement originally done by a five-piece is no small feat either..Buzz is blending two guitar parts  into one here.....I dig it....yeah it's weird in an exciting & funny way hearing Jello sing it.....but that being said, I think he adds an almost "buzzing" kind of edgyness to the whole proceedings which just fuels the fire.  If someone told me 10 or 15 years ago that someday Jello & Melvins would cover "Halo of Flies", I'd have told 'em to get outta town, no way, and that would be a total trip! It just goes to show you,  it pays to live long enough to bear witness to  these kinda rock & roll miracles. I offer thanx & praise.....peace.............

rhett E rock

on Halo of Flies it sounds like Jello is reading the lyrics.  that's my only problem with the song. 

i think it does make a difference if you're a DK fan.  Jello is one of those people you either like or hate.  this was an interesting polll Vinney.  i've been wondering this myself.

Vcavallo

meanclown, thanks for that verbose post. i loved it!

i think you are describing a real unique situation that you happen to be in.  that must be really amazing for you.  if i try to imagine a similar situation from my perspective at this age/point in music/taste, i can really appreciate where you're coming from.  i'm sure i would enjoy this song a whole lot more on so many more levels if i could hear it as you do.  i'll try it out.
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Vcavallo

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Chief Ten Beers

# 4 for me. Love the album and the previous one. Never was a DK listener back when they were relevant(was in grade school). I first heard of Jello on a Warner Bros. spoken word compilation LP I found early in the internet days called "Sound Bites From The Counter Culture". It also features Rollins, Timothy Leary, Hunter S. Thompson, etc. The track is "Tales From The Trial", about the Frankenchrist fiasco. Don't know if it's on an AT release. Jello is an interesting guy and I like what he has to say, bottom line. He has a unique voice and is a great frontman from what I saw with The Melvins last fall.

I don't know why, but I never got around to picking up any DK albums in the last ten years. Flag, Minutemen, Husker Du, Misfits, Minor Threat, I have everything by. I know I will never buy a DK release new, because his ex-band owns the rights and gets the royalties. DK today w/out Jello along with Jerry Only carrying on the Misfits is fucking pathetic.


Dale's right. The Melvins know what they're doing. If you don't like Jelvins, move on, or just shut up and wait for the next album. They don't care what you think.

jeremy

I was never really a DK fan, I never really explored thier music that much, But I like both the Jello & Melvins albums and they have encouraged me to check out Dks again.

I think Jello's voice can be a little overbearing sometimes, But I get used to it pretty fast.

Hog log


Pelican

My opinion doesn't really fall into any of the catergories, so here it is. I'm a huge Melvins fan, and also a big DK fan. I'm not really liking Sieg Howdy too much though. Just kind of seems like re-tread. I thought Never Breath was an awesome record, it was kind of like a new, updated DK album, but with my favorite band playing, and it rocked.

I like Halo of Flies, and the new version of Kalifornia Uber Alles. The remixes, and redos are weaker than the oringals on Never Breathe, in my opinion. Those Dumb Punk Kids is pretty good, but almost seems kinda hypocritical, but what do I know?

Vcavallo

it sounds, to the author, as if you fall into the "neither like nor dislike" category.  if you are absolutely certain that isn't the case, then you must decide which side you are on.  this reality is made up of 0s and 1s.  i only put the 50/50 choice there for perfectly down-the-middle people (a condition i think is impossible, though very convincing).
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Chief Ten Beers

Quote from: Dudbean on October 18, 2005, 09:36:42 PM
For the life of me, I can't understand how anyone can enjoy Halo Of Flies with that fucking voice. I'm as confused by that as I am by the number of people who buy/bought Alanis Morissette's "Jagged Little Pill" album. Millions and fucking millions of albums sold, without a single redeeming feature. I can see why people buy crap like Gwen Stefani (solid beats care of that Neptunes guy. Pharell? I don't know this kind of stuff.) or some other catchy shit of the day, but Alanis (and Jello) sound absolutely fucking awful. AWFUL. I don't know if I can ever get past that weasely voice and those inane, high-school lyrics. Maybe the Dead Kennedys were great - I wouldn't know - but Jello, in this day and age, makes my skin crawl, regardless of his political this-or-that. Hell, if he was elected president I'd turn my TV to Mute, just to avoid that fucking voice. Some of the songs I can handle, because los Melvins are in there, doing their thing with the music - I can even handle Jello at times - but most of the time it's just absolutely painful to listen to. If they have to collaborate bring back Lustmord. That was quality shit. Big Business should rock. Jello, though....doesn't agree with me.

I can't read this without speaking up. Putting Jello in the same category as some manufactured pop singer like Alanis Morrisette is way off the mark. Seems like you're used to your rock/metal/punk(whatever you're into) singers sounding a certain way. Jello's voice is different, and you can't handle it. It's powerfull and raw, same way Jeffrey Lee Pierce's(Gun Club) or Keith Morris'(Circle Jerks/Black Flag) is. The cover of Halo of Flies owns. I'm curious, who are some of your favorite singers?

Pelican

I agree with the Chief 100%. I don't see anything in common with Alanis and Jello. And, even if Gwen could get DJ Premier to make her music, her songs will always suck.

I'm curious as to what singers Dudbean likes too. My favorite voice of all time is Layne Staley. Mark Lanegan, Cobain, Plant, Jack White, Buzz, Cash, Dylan and Fiona Apple are all high on list too, among others, that's off the top of my head. But Layne had a range and rawness that still gets to me like no other.