'Melvins Expand Lineup, Ready Live Album' -Billboard

Started by klump, January 02, 2006, 01:37:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 4 Guests are viewing this topic.

CaptainPungent

keith moon's style is really messy.
he drums air.
he's a very good drummer though, his drumming was just like his life.
it's like ginger baker just did some lines of coke and 2 hits of lsd.
you can consider one of his disciples to be Brian Chippendale.

but...
I gotta go with Bonham, as I usually refer to him while talking about Dale.
2 drummers taught me how to play the "basics", John and Mitch Mitchell of Jimi Hendrix Experience.
Bonham is like a monster behind the drums, he hovers over them with his think pumping sound.
He could play ANY kind of music, and have a rich and new beat to go along with it.
Moon may have more personality outside of the drums, but Bonham has just as much or more on the kit.
Maybe it's only drummers who know this, but Bonham learned something before double bass kits
(-that's what was used at the time instead of a double pedal)
anyway, Bonham created a double bass sound, 2 to 3 (maybe more) rolling beats on the kick drum with one foot.
this is imitated so much, to this day.
Bonham also taught Ringo Starr much of what he knows today, and you can hear this perfectly in their later albums.

Yes, Moon had his own style, but it wasn't precise.
Just because you don't hear a thousand things going on at once in Bonham's drumming doesn't make him
less than of a drummer.
that's pure stupidity to think, watch live footage of Bonham, and you'll see why he's great.
It is usually in live performances you can see why I think this, get 'The Song Remains The Same' video.
After that, you can go to 'How The West Was Won', etc...
He was a simple farm boy who was a God on the drums, and didn't always want to show it.
I mean, he had his times to be great, but he also had 3 other members who were also phenomenal at what they did.
Come on, you're really going to put Zeppelin behind The Who?
what?!
If you're going to say this, atleast back it up.  Match each individuals playing to one another.
doesn't match up for me.
Maarten, you just need to listen to more Zeppelin, didn't you say you hardly have listened to them?
Take my advice and start with Led Zeppelin II, this was the first album to really show people John Bonham.
Yes, it does have Moby Dick on it, but you'll appreciate his playing before you even get to that song.

norecess


ManWithNoName

I don't give a flying fuck who's better and who's not. It has everything to do with what moves me and what doesn't. Zeppelin just bores me.

I could sit here and list all the reasons why I prefer entwistle to jones, townshend to page and moon to bonham but we'd still be at the same point. I don't care for their techincal ability. It's simple really, I'd pick tommy before any zeppelin album. In fact, I wouldn't even have to bother with tommy. If I had to chose one song to listen to for the rest of my life it would probably be a quick one while he's away.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82usxXFTwZE&search=the%20who%20quick%20one

CaptainPungent

DON'T LISTEN TO HIM, MAARTEN!


HE'S TRYING TO CONVERT YOU TO THE DARK SIDE!
sorry manwith, you're cool anyway.

you have to agree that led zep boys had a lot more admiration and love for eachother that the who boys.
i watched an interview with townshend* and he was an asshole to the rest of the members,
as he is to a lot of people outside in life.

here's moby dick from tsrts:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=56_J8aPF06k&search=john%20bonham

it's not the whole thing, you can check out more on youtube if you want.
i forgot he plays with his fuckin' hands!'
this is a great video for you, you get to see how john was.
there's even a shot of him playing drums with his son when he was little, the now famous jason bonham

an interview with him and plant:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ery04XxqJO4&search=john%20bonham


let's just be friends, manwith:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=14WOrv62ob4&search=john%20bonham

norecess

:D

Not gonna watch 'em now since Houdini is playing, but I'll check 'em out ronight or so.

Hey, Joan of Arc sounds like the intro of Malpractice by FNM after 4 minutes.