Do you hate Melvins for doing stupid shit?

Started by Grindfag, December 13, 2003, 07:28:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Grindfag

I.E. releasing stuff like Prick and Colossus of destiny?

I don't, but I could understand why someone would. It's kinda of an overused idea sometimes (the proliferation of piss-taking stuff) on their albums. I know Buzz is having a laugh, and all, but I still can see why would someone consider that weak/gimmicky.

When they're good, they're awesome, but when they're bad, they really do hit the shits on a new low.

JAWBONE BREAKINGMOUTH

the simple truth is, they had a good time making those records and thats all that matters. people get bent out of shape over shit like that and im sick of hearing about it just as much as the next person.
its the Melvins, not blink182.

Reverend Ebeneezer

I think hate's too strong a word. On the one hand, I'm glad they experiment but on the other I haven't listened to COD for a while and Prick's one of the few albums I don't own. I think the piss-taking is part of the Melvins appeal and to some extent I can laugh along with them. Mind you, the one release that actually pissed me off was King Buzzo's EP. I thought Isabella, Porg and Skeeter were all so inferior and just tossed off in minutes. I think the fact that I had to pay
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

eddie

Quote from: Reverend Ebeneezer

The Melvins are the only band besides KISS that could release the sound of farting and their fans would still lap it up. They subconsciously make you a fanboy and a collector-fetishist!


Dave would probably buy an album of Rush farting.

Beto Brasil

Quote from: GrindfagI.E. releasing stuff like Prick and Colossus of destiny?
both albums horrible.
i dont like this 2 albums...
:shock:  :shock:  :shock:
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

eddie

like what Kim Thayil said about Soundgarden, i think the Melvins just make music to please themselves and if they feel like dicking around then so be it.

alnis

A direct quote from ipecac.com:

------------
Here we are in 2003 and it's become obvious that we need to clear up a few things about the Melvins.

2. The Melvins are NOT a "trick on music".

Got It?
-----------

It's good to remember that.

alnis

Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerAnyhow, COD has the best cover art of any album ever...

I just had to add that I agree 100%, and I've been point that out to people ever since it came out.

Really...no joke...best cover ever.

yeknod ykoops

i personally enjoy COD, Prick, and all of their experimental stuff. i've been into "noise" stuff since before i even got into the melvins, so that stuff is kinda right up my alley. in closing, no, i don't hate them because i LIKE their "stupid shit."

Leroy

I listened to COD and I hate it.  Prick is funny though.  Prick has comedic value.

klump

why does everyone get annoyed by that stuff? i think its really funny :D

JAWBONE BREAKINGMOUTH

its no wonder brian decided to make that messageboard annoucement.
if you dont like what the melvins do then dont listen and dont come here bitching.
the band isnt going to change for you and this messageboard will not help/

cheeseburger

Quote from: yeknod ykoopsi personally enjoy COD, Prick, and all of their experimental stuff. i've been into "noise" stuff since before i even got into the melvins, so that stuff is kinda right up my alley. in closing, no, i don't hate them because i LIKE their "stupid shit."

you took the words right out of my mouth...although i was into the melvins long before i heard merzbow, masonna, etc...
ever heard cock esp?

turnacus

On the contrary my friend, these are the reasons I love the melvins.
Van Hagar

anaconda

if some people are so into random noise, why even bother buying
CDs at all then? why not just go hang around a construction site,
or just turn on a tape recorder out near a freeway or something?
Seriously. That's what Throbbing Gristle used to do, and they were
the premier 'noise' band out there besides Test Dept, and maybe
Ensterzende Neubotten.