Do you hate Melvins for doing stupid shit?

Started by Grindfag, December 13, 2003, 07:28:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Rembrandt Pussyhorse

I love COD. I cream my pants everytime eyes flies kicks in. Best version ever.Its not realy noise though, if you listen closely you'll notice there's actually a beat throughout the whole cd.
I could catch a monkey

cheeseburger

Quote from: anacondaif some people are so into random noise, why even bother buying
CDs at all then? why not just go hang around a construction site,
or just turn on a tape recorder out near a freeway or something?
Seriously. That's what Throbbing Gristle used to do, and they were
the premier 'noise' band out there besides Test Dept, and maybe
Ensterzende Neubotten.

its not about random noise for me. honestly once you hear one merzbow cd you've heard em all, it gets redundnt ya know? throbbing gristle were doing alot more than just standing by freeways, they were a band, they had "songs" they were one of the first d.i.y. lables ever (industrial records),and i believe they around before test dept. and Einsturzende Neubauten.
i love cod and prick because its the fucking melvins. i can dig where there're coming from.

Greenmushroom


Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: anacondaif some people are so into random noise, why even bother buying
CDs at all then? why not just go hang around a construction site,
or just turn on a tape recorder out near a freeway or something?

Not wishing to be cynical, but there's a great deal of posturing and image maintainance in the noise community. Even more so than in the avant-garde rock scene...

Inferring, and only inferring ( :P ) of course, that a lot of the people who claim to love noise records are seeking underground cred.
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Vcavallo

im with pussyhorse (heh heh...pussyhorse...)  i love COD!  i listen to it rather often.  it's beautifully arranged and quite interesting.  listen to it from begining to end, cod haters, it really is a very good album even though it isn't necesarilly "music".  also just think of all the time and effort put into making that album flow as smoothly as it does.  damn it's good! i might listen to it right now, bagbiters!!!
Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

Grindfag

Quote from: asteriskits no wonder brian decided to make that messageboard annoucement.
if you dont like what the melvins do then dont listen and dont come here bitching.
the band isnt going to change for you and this messageboard will not help/

You mean we can't discuss the bad part about the Melvins on their message board?

Wow, that makes sense. Thanks.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: Grindfag

You mean we can't discuss the bad part about the Melvins on their message board?

Wow, that makes sense. Thanks.

Nah, I think when it comes to serious criticism discussion is fine, that warning is for the occasions when you get little "grungers" whining along the lines of "THE MELVINS SUX0RS! THEY DON'T PLAY GRUNGE THERE WEIRD" on the site who, obviously, need discouraging.

Incidentally, I'm aware that it should be "they're", I was putting myself into a child. If that doesn't sound rude. :oops:
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

JJ

Quote from: Grindfag
Quote from: asteriskits no wonder brian decided to make that messageboard annoucement.
if you dont like what the melvins do then dont listen and dont come here bitching.
the band isnt going to change for you and this messageboard will not help/

You mean we can't discuss the bad part about the Melvins on their message board?

Wow, that makes sense. Thanks.

Not everyone that complains about the melvins HATE the melvins.  A lot of those people own other melvins albums and enjoy them.  They're just expressing some criticism about albums like COD or whatever, which is fine.  It's freedom of speech.  I mean, it's not like everyone on this board should be forced to praise every single release the melvins came out with.

yeknod ykoops

Quote from: cheeseburgeryou took the words right out of my mouth...although i was into the melvins long before i heard merzbow, masonna, etc...
ever heard cock esp?

nah, but i have heard OF them. i will have to check them out. as for throbbing gristle just standing next to freeways and recording noise or whatever, no way. their music had a very strong "rhythm" to it. alot of it had a great beat and strong groove, in my opinion. as for just saying i like noise to get some underground cred, naaaaaah. i'm just a weirdo that drinks too much fuckin' nyquil and listens to noise. simple as that. it puts me into a weird trance...........or something.

alnis

Quotehonestly once you hear one merzbow cd you've heard em all

Ok, now that's just not true. Merzbow albums are all over the place. Very different from each other.

I think some noise is great. And there's lots of different types to be discovered. But this whole noise sucks/noise is awesome debate is wierd. Noise is noise. Rock and roll is rock and roll. Maybe you like it, maybe you don't. The "stupid shit" talk really curdles my milk, because you mom called to melvins stupid shit too.

It's all about being receptive.

klump

people should try to have an open mind, noise music is actually very funny stuff :)

and people who claim they like noise just to get "cred" are pathetic (sic)

banananananananannanananananananananananananananananana---------------------------------------------babananabbbanana----------------------------------kuntz-----------------kunntnnt----------:D merry christmas

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: klump

banananananananannanananananananananananananananananana---------------------------------------------babananabbbanana----------------------------------kuntz-----------------kunntnnt----------:D merry christmas

Klump, you're a madman. A madman with a great avatar...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

gwiz

peolpe thought Eraserhead was "stupid shit" and alot of people love that movie. me beinged one of themem. its a "cult film" nowadayssss. what does this have to do with this discussion??...i dont really know. maybe if we all learn to live together, and love the stupid things we all do, we too can sing along to the deaf mans music oneday....and the children will be happy Goddamit. think of the children you selfish people. the CHILDREN!! p. s.listening to noise does not rot you brain!

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: gwizp. s.listening to noise does not rot you brain!

Nah, PCP'll do that for you...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

GrimReaper

I don't hate the Melvins for doing stupid shit but I hate myself for buying it all the time.