Do you hate Melvins for doing stupid shit?

Started by Grindfag, December 13, 2003, 07:28:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Grindfag

Quote from: GrimReaperI don't hate the Melvins for doing stupid shit but I hate myself for buying it all the time.

I feel the same about Meshuggah. When I bought Nothing, I wanted to punch myself in the face.

Being a fan sucks.

mr. bunghole

you're fucking stupid if you think a band actually wastes their time to confuse or joke around.

alnis

Quote from: mr. bungholeyou're fucking stupid if you think a band actually wastes their time to confuse or joke around.


I like this new "Mr. Bunghole."

Grindfag

Quote from: mr. bungholeyou're fucking stupid if you think a band actually wastes their time to confuse or joke around.


Are you from the Ipecac bored? Cause I remember people there were that stupid and couldn't see shit straight even if their lives depended on it...thus, stuff like Pranzo oltranzista got praised there.

Anyway, you're not brighter than a thousand suns if you figured out the Melvins make music to enlighten people and are serious about it. I mean, they're not fucking around at all. It's an all-serious band, really.


.....SARCASM

You're a gimmick.

kl0pper

you dont have to buy it because it says melvins (or snivlem) on the cover
they cover a large variety of musical styles, and it wont and cant appeal to EVERYONE
you dont have to buy it if you dont like it, you are still allowed to be a "melvins fan" even if you dont own all their albums

i happen to like those two albums...

Kurva

ha! they got you! they got you where they wanted... they must be laughing on all of you :) being hassled, arguing.... heh heh

the most important thing is that they do things THEY want to do
nobody dictates them what to do

wait a sec, isnt it what eddie had written? :)

fuck im so horny for the COD, ive got 'only' Prick
btw the only melvalbum i dont like, is HAT

Grindfag

Quote from: kurvaha! they got you! they got you where they wanted... they must be laughing on all of you  :)  being hassled, arguing.... heh heh

the most important thing is that they do things THEY want to do
nobody dictates them what to do

That doesn't make them superspecial, witty or anything, it just means that some of their stuff plainly sucks.

I don't really care for them doing the "unmusical" stuff now and then, but some might say you can only milk a joke for so long, y'know?
Particularly, I only dislike two of their albums, but there are a few songs now and then I could do without...

Kurva

speaking of prick.... who the fuck is in roll another one, speaking german :?:  :roll:  :D

eddie

Moe from the Three Stooges playing his Hitler role.

brian

after all of the interviews you've read where the band has stated that colossus of destiny was not a joke and that they actually listen to music which is similar in style to it themselves do you still think that they are playing a trick on you or do you finally realize that they have different tastes than you do and maybe that's the reason they put out the album.  another thing i'd like to know is that if you've finally realized this fact do you think the melvins are idiots for liking this type of music or are you willing to accept the old saying to each his own and are ready to cope with the idea that you listen to a band that puts out diverse styles of releases and deal with that by sampling it before you buy it?

eddie

I want to know what Melvins fans (before Prick) thought of "Prick." I mean they sign with Atlantic then jump to Amprep and make this...with the name snivlem on the spine and  "Melvins" backwards on the cover?!?

CausesUnknown

excellent, brian. You hit it right on the money.

Its just like their album design when they started on IPECAC. Who thought of making the back the front, and the front on the back? That was awesome. Its a better space for appreciating artwork. Or what about the trilogy vinyl that was SOOOOO controversal with their displays of hate signs? I really really like CoD, like Buzz said himself, you gotta really sit down and listen to it.
Go to their biography on the IPECAC website and its states
"The Melvins are NOT a play on music. Got It?"
Easy as this, You either like what they've done for the past....20 years, or you like some of it. Both are ok, to each their own. But why would anybody hate anything they do? They do as they please, if they wanted your opinion, they'd ask for it. Last time I checked, the shots are called by only 3 people. Deal with it, build a bridge, and move on.

Grindfag

Quote from: brianafter all of the interviews you've read where the band has stated that colossus of destiny was not a joke and that they actually listen to music which is similar in style to it themselves do you still think that they are playing a trick on you or do you finally realize that they have different tastes than you do and maybe that's the reason they put out the album.

I didn't read any of those, actually. My bad, but you do know they talk a lot of nonsense on their interviews just to be the complete opposite of your average joe-who-plays-in-a-band, right?

Quote from: briananother thing i'd like to know is that if you've finally realized this fact do you think the melvins are idiots for liking this type of music

Idiot is a strong word. The fact that I think it's stupid and sucky doesn't necessarily mean they're idiots to me.

Quote from: brianare you willing to accept the old saying to each his own

You mean it's alright for them to do whatever but I can't complain in case I don't like it? How far does this ''each their own'' theory go?

Quote from: brianare you ready to cope with the idea that you listen to a band that puts out diverse styles of releases and deal with that by sampling it before you buy it?

It's been like that for some time, but I still am let down now and then by them, even though I think when they get it right (IMHO), they rule.

brian

damn grandfag, you're right, the melvins did put out prick and cod just to take my money and fuck me over, now that i think about it, every piece of music i've ever heard that i didn't enjoy was an attempt by the artists who have released said pieces to screw me out of my hard earned money, excuse me while i kick myself for being duped for so long a period of time.

Reverend Ebeneezer

But Brian, they've admitted in the past (in some interviews at least) that Prick was done as something of a fundraiser to make some cash out of them demoing for Stoner Witch. In that sense, it was designed to extract cash. Mind you, since then Buzzo's said that it was a full-on artistic statement and everything inbetween. IMO, we'll never know. If you feel ripped off, that's one approach, if you feel satisfied, that's another...

And CausesUnknown, are the decisions really made by 3 people? Mr. Deutrom was out for dissenting...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...