Do you hate Melvins for doing stupid shit?

Started by Grindfag, December 13, 2003, 07:28:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

alnis

Quote from: Reverend EbeneezerBut Brian, they've admitted in the past (in some interviews at least) that Prick was done as something of a fundraiser to make some cash out of them demoing for Stoner Witch.

Really? I don't doubt that you read that, but it seems wierd. A money grab? Prick? For Stoner Witch? I doubt they were cash-strapped with Atlantic, and I don't think Prick made much money. But I guess it's possible.

-----------

To "melvins do stupid shit" people:

I'm much less willing to stand behind Prick than COD. Prick is a complicated situation. Obviously parts of it (if not all of it) are jokes, but jokes on who? Or what? Certainly not the person who bought the CD. Listen to it with a smile. It's fun. If you don't like it, you don't like it. But it's not like the Melvins were out to get you. Or their fans in general.

But Prick excluded, the melvins aren't really joking around. Especially with COD. (There were some intervies posted recently, and the first one had some great comments on COD...comments I've heard many times before - COD is no joke). The Melvins are a good way to bridge yourself into different types of music, and if you just can't accept anything but good ol' rock and roll, then I don't know what to say. I guess you're just like 99% of humanity. Which is good and bad, for me and you.

Reverend Ebeneezer

Quote from: alnis
Really? I don't doubt that you read that, but it seems wierd. A money grab? Prick? For Stoner Witch? I doubt they were cash-strapped with Atlantic, and I don't think Prick made much money. But I guess it's possible.


I should explain: that conclusion is something of an amalgamation of various interviews etc, I've read with the Melvins. The Mark D interview on the first page discusses Prick in relation to the demoing of Stoner Witch. If I had the time or inclination I'd have a search for the cash-in interview, but I haven't so you'll have to take my word for it.

In any case, Prick's a neat record. Chief Ten Beers is one of my favourite Melvins songs...
Don't cut me!DON'T CUT ME!
-Thrones, Simon Legree live...

Grindfag

Quote from: briandamn grandfag, you're right, the melvins did put out prick and cod just to take my money and fuck me over, now that i think about it, every piece of music i've ever heard that i didn't enjoy was an attempt by the artists who have released said pieces to screw me out of my hard earned money, excuse me while i kick myself for being duped for so long a period of time.

You mean you're not even gonna try and come up with a serious reply?




I feel like adding that it doesn't really bother me when the Melvins do come up with stuff like Colossus of destiny or the last song on Houdini, I just don't listen to it.

All props to them for trying, but hey - to me, it sucks.

brian

Quote from: GrindfagYou mean you're not even gonna try and come up with a serious reply?

I feel like adding that it doesn't really bother me when the Melvins do come up with stuff like Colossus of destiny or the last song on Houdini, I just don't listen to it.

All props to them for trying, but hey - to me, it sucks.

i thought i was answering seriously, half the posts you've made in this topic have acknowledged the melvins ability to be sarcastic, so in turn i figured if i used sarcasm you'd be able to pick up on the underlying point i was making.

regardless, the latter two paragraphs in your post that i've quoted are statements of opinion, which i and i'm sure everyone else on this board can accept, however when you label a topic by stating that the melvins do stupid shit matter of factly, you're going to disappoint me and i'm going to feel the need to respond.

Grindfag

Quote from: briani thought i was answering seriously, half the posts you've made in this topic have acknowledged the melvins ability to be sarcastic, so in turn i figured if i used sarcasm you'd be able to pick up on the underlying point i was making.

regardless, the latter two paragraphs in your post that i've quoted are statements of opinion, which i and i'm sure everyone else on this board can accept, however when you label a topic by stating that the melvins do stupid shit matter of factly, you're going to disappoint me and i'm going to feel the need to respond.

Ah, but sarcasm doesn't translate too well on the internet, I'm afraid. In your case, it was pretty clear, though, but it's just that it seemed to me that you were dodging my question.

As for me not being able to phrase it correctly, well, sorry if I hurt your feelings, but I couldn't possibly know. Are you sure you didn't understand my concept of stupid shit? Maybe you're just being sarcastic again, or something.

...it's not like english is my first language, bear with my limitations there.

benton netty

this is an interesting discussion. the way i see it, the melvins sometimes do specific things to elicit different responses rather than just blind adoration for their rock godliness or whatever. i've always felt that they do some things to test people, maybe weed out the idiots who have no patience for noise or craziness. for instance, the noise at the beginning of "magic pig detective," i've played that for people and they just get sick looks on their faces. of course, when the song kicks in, they're like, "whew, what a relief that's over," but i guess i just find it amusing.

it's like the last tour, where they did the "pregnant pause" thing -- i loved looking around the crowd and seeing people's looks of confusion. i guess i admire them for their ability to write insane rock songs and i also admire them for being almost andy kaufman-like in the way they test audiences, the way they look for reactions that aren't your standard, safe "yay! you rock," or whatever. i think it's great that they may (at times) be trying to annoy you, or test your tolerance for eardrum abuse. and then, just as you've had enough, they come back and rock you like a hurricane.

but i do think, too, that they find enjoyment in that. i don't think they're putting out "prick" and not having fun with it. noise is fun to make.

and to the guy who said that thing about people in bands not wanting to confuse or joke around -- i'm in a band, and i've done just that on countless occasions. i've sat in a chair onstage smoking a cigarette while my guitar fed back for ten minutes. why? because i'm interested, much like the melvins probably are, in testing the boundaries, in experimenting. i'm curious to see what happens when people are messed with. and i find it funny.

the melvins, i think, are never just totally trying to fuck you over. shit, prick and COD both have worthy moments of so-called "real" music on them, even. but i do think that not everything they do is meant to please you. some of it is a total challenge. but, i guess, the question is this: do you LIKE to be challenged?

Grindfag

Quote from: tonyi've always felt that they do some things to test people, maybe weed out the idiots who have no patience for noise or craziness.

That'd be me, me, ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Quote from: tonythe question is this: do you LIKE to be challenged?

I guess so. Some of my favorite bands include The residents, Captain Beefheart, Fant

Kurva

raise your hand if you like the drums on the very end of roll another one

I DO!

GRRRRRRRREAT!

mr. bunghole

Quote from: Grindfag
Quote from: mr. bungholeyou're fucking stupid if you think a band actually wastes their time to confuse or joke around.


Are you from the Ipecac bored? Cause I remember people there were that stupid and couldn't see shit straight even if their lives depended on it...thus, stuff like Pranzo oltranzista got praised there.

Anyway, you're not brighter than a thousand suns if you figured out the Melvins make music to enlighten people and are serious about it. I mean, they're not fucking around at all. It's an all-serious band, really.


.....SARCASM

You're a gimmick.
what the piss fuck shit are you talking about i'm a gimmick??? I don't think i'm bright its just stupid to think a band would waste its time trying to confuse people.  I just think the majority of people are easily confused.

Galvano


brian

why the fuck do you care if i don't prune the topics, there's a lot of valuable information posted in the forum and i'd have to moderate by hand every topic i didn't like.  the general discussion deletes all topics that haven't been posted to in 90 days and i feel that is sufficient.  if you have a serious reason why you think i should do the same in this forum i'll consider it.   :hal:

Galvano

A suggestion could be, move important/valuable/informative threads into it's own forum (as they are posted and after given consideration of the input). And let all the "what's the best Melvins song" die out in 90 days aswell.

Or don't, after all it's your forum, if you don't have the time, or just don't give a shit, it's your decission.

Personally I just think it's boring when 6 months old topic regain new life.

brian

Quote from: GalvanoPersonally I just think it's boring when 6 months old topic regain new life.

yawn


deejuks2

The reason they did those kinds of albums is to do THIS, and by this i mean make people whine and argue about it.