Are the Melvins closer to punk or metal?

Started by Huey P. Newton, May 24, 2006, 10:21:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Huey P. Newton

I'd been wondering this myself, being that they started out punk but quickly evolved into a black sabbathy-metal offspring. I just don't know, what do you guys think?

FartLips

does it have to be punk or metal, or are they just being the melvins?
Judy is mad.🤣

M i C H e L L e

Metal definitely, because most punk songs are only a few minutes long.
*Grow Thy Beard )))((( it shall be the wild forrests of thine Kingdom and unto all shall bring great peace and prosperity throughout the land as was told the prophecy*

DubEMC


(PAUL)

Have you heard a Melvins song with a 4 minute guitar solo? No, I think they take things from both camps while ignoring the cliches set forth by both metal and punk. But labeling IMO is kind of silly. Have you heard a punk or metal band do half the things they have done?
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

mopafeena

www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband

blacksanta

Melvins: The Iconoclasts of Punk-Inspired Heavy Metal.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

Haggardsue

I think the melvins are good. Very good infact.

CaptainPungent

metal.

punk revolves around a lot of bass lines (not to say melvins don't, because melvins are switchy and can't be labeled)
a lot of melvins songs revolve around buzz's harsh guitar.

some of the cut off punks i know can't handle that.

but there is most definately punk in them.


anyway, who cares, if you like the melvins you're great
and if you don't, fuck you.

Pelican

"Are you a mod or a rocker?"

"I'm a mocker."

Huey P. Newton

I am not trying to really classify them, I just wanted to see what tree you guys think the gravitate more towards.

klump


TGH

Musically, the Melvins aren't very punk at all. But if you're going on the "punk idea" that you do whatever the hell you feel like, then yes.
This isn't a time for lectures!

klump


mopafeena

www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband