Houdini or Stoner witch?

Started by Pringles, May 25, 2006, 03:42:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Wich is the best?

Houdini
10 (41.7%)
Stoner Witch
14 (58.3%)

Total Members Voted: 19

Voting closed: May 28, 2006, 03:42:20 PM

Pringles

Luck is a residue of design

CaptainPungent

stoner witch.

skweetis buries a lot of things.

Branch Breaker

The Melvins album vs. Melvins album polls have all been easy calls so far. Bullhead>Ozma. HAT>Stag. Stoner Witch is very much superior to Houdini.

As soon as someone posts a HAT vs. Stoner Witch, however .... that's the kind of question that could keep a fella up all night.
Rectum? Damn near killed 'im!

glen

I admit it. I voted for houdini.  its got HAG ME on it.  thats all it takes.

plus night goat? come on.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

CaptainPungent

Quote from: glen on May 25, 2006, 06:16:49 PM
I admit it. I voted for houdini.  its got HAG ME on it.  thats all it takes.

plus night goat? come on.
personally, the first time i heard houdini, i was bored.
not with some of the songs like hooch and pearl bomb, but yeah. (of course i learned to love it)

stoner witch, being my first hear and buy of the melvins, instantly clicked with me.
the artwork, seeing all the members looking lost in some green spaced out photographs.
skweetis pulled me into some wacky swirl of a world and then threw me out into a
heavy and straight forward song called queen.
all of the more ambient and experimental fill songs clicked automatically into my ears
into some kind of dream of euphoria.
goose freight train connected me with blues, and showed me how dark it can be.
roadbull connected with my childhood and made me think of cub scouts (even though I wasn't)
besides skweetis and queen, at the stake got the hook.
one of my first posts on this board was me talking about how whenever I told how the melvins
were, I referred to that song.
my first learned melvins song was also junebug.
I remember going over to my best friends house, totally not listening to him and I brought
my cd player along, the day I got stoner witch, while we went against eachother on shooter
video games, I was listening to music and in bliss.
seriously, no album EVER has brought me such joy.
then lividity completed my awe by having that harsh sawing kind of sound that takes away
from the bassline, then at the end you hear "yep" "ehh...whatya mean? my lungs are fine...ehh...ehh"
to end a completely (what I thought) serious album.
phenominal.

Tyuge

(the melvins have never made a serious album.) anyway, i think houdini is better. i know it isn't "cool" to like it, since it is their most popular among the non-enlightened and it has Kurt Cobain on it (who it is also uncool to like), but i just think the songs are a lot better than on stoner witch. i think it's ironic that people disdain houdini for being "mainstream" and praise stonerwitch, when in fact stoner witch is 1,000 times more "normal" than houdini. (example: revolve)

Andy

The new Houdini has made me see it in a totally different light. I even like Copache now. Houdini is better. The first half is some of the best Melvins ever.
For your health!

CaptainPungent

the people who put stoner witch aren't owning up.
wussies!

rimb

Alright then.  Stoner Witch for its diversity and Mark D's playing - his best album imo.

mopafeena

These polls are all very hard, for me anyway.

But i went with Houdini because of the new respect for it that i've gained because of Newdini. But i still absolutely love Stoner Witch.
www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband

norecess


Kessel

For life is not happy.

TosT

i chose stoner witch because i find houdini to be more disjointed, not always a bad thing but...

i didn't like "set me straight" at all, although they've saved that song on the new live version. it's not boring like the original. and it's SHORT!
also wasn't blown away by sky pup or going blind. although i, again, much prefer both of these on Live 2005.

CaptainPungent

yeah.

houdini certainly doesn't fall into eachother track to track as well as stoner witch.
another reason for me to love the album more.

blacksanta

Boner Bitch...see my review of the New Houdini for reasons why. But here are a few more reasons.....Goose freight Train, Roadbull, At the Stake, Shevil.
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.