Grunge?

Started by Buzzocut, November 04, 2006, 07:33:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Buzzocut

I can't understand why alot of people consider them grunge. I mean, yeah, I know Cobain was their protoge, and he helped get them a major label deal, but they don't sound grungy, and I can't understand why lots of people think they are. They sound more like Metallica or some kind of metal band or M.I.R.V. or some Neo-Prog band.

TGH

I think they sound like the Melvins.
This isn't a time for lectures!

(PAUL)

If you consider Pearl Jam grunge, then yeah.
Hail, not fail.
PS:  fuck him.

duster

Quote from: Buzzocut on November 04, 2006, 07:33:19 PM
I can't understand why alot of people consider them grunge. I mean, yeah, I know Cobain was their protoge, and he helped get them a major label deal, but they don't sound grungy, and I can't understand why lots of people think they are. They sound more like Metallica or some kind of metal band or M.I.R.V. or some Neo-Prog band.

how did you hear about M.I.R.V.?

i posted a link to their site on here a ways back. they are some really fucked up people. they do produce some interesting music, however.

most people, myself included, are aware of them through the primus association.

Buzzocut

Quote from: duster on November 04, 2006, 09:59:12 PM
Quote from: Buzzocut on November 04, 2006, 07:33:19 PM
I can't understand why alot of people consider them grunge. I mean, yeah, I know Cobain was their protoge, and he helped get them a major label deal, but they don't sound grungy, and I can't understand why lots of people think they are. They sound more like Metallica or some kind of metal band or M.I.R.V. or some Neo-Prog band.

how did you hear about M.I.R.V.?

i posted a link to their site on here a ways back. they are some really fucked up people. they do produce some interesting music, however.

most people, myself included, are aware of them through the primus association.

I saw one of their videos on Beavis & Butt-head, which was "Shave My Face Off", and it's still the only song of theirs I've heard so far, but I do have the whole "Cosmodrome" CD.

anaconda


seas of luck

I don't think a lot of people consider them grunge.  I've always been more confused by the slow label.

PS I heard about MIRV through Primus.  I have "Cosmodrome" and "Dancing Naked in a Minefield".  Both are pretty good but I don't listen to them too often.  Their latest album "Million Pound Bomb" has been delayed for about 2 or 3 years now but they did put a new song on their myspace about a year ago.  That's progress...sorta.

duster


Chomas

"grunge" is a fucking media term, forget it existed already - don't you know why Buzz released Lysol?????????

Dog Tired

really if one considers the melvins grunge they really don't know the melvins.  so ignore them.

Buzzocut

Quote from: Dog Tired on November 05, 2006, 11:29:22 AM
really if one considers the melvins grunge they really don't know the melvins.  so ignore them.

Ha ha! Good point! There's alot of stupid people who consider certain bands grunge when they aren't.

Vampire Tapes

I always thought they were associated with grunge due to the Deep Six compilation. Which had lots of other so called 'grunge' bands on.

Dog Tired

they can be associated yes.. but not grunge itself.