POLL: which one is adam?

Started by ninigiku, April 13, 2008, 10:47:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

ninigiku

(this thread is specifically for one song, not an entire album)

track 4 from POTRE (the title track) has only 2 distinct guitar riffs.

the first one begins at 5:57 and ends at 10:33 --- (length:  4:36)
the second one begins at 13:32 and ends at 18:30 --- (length: 4:58)

obviously one is played by adam jones & the other is played by buzz, which one?

i vote:
1st one = adam
2nd one = buzz


PS--++-- if i post this on the POTRE album discussion, nobody will ever reply to it specifically
sarcalogos solus redemptor

(the) Razor

Don't click this

Branch Breaker

Quote from: ninigiku on April 13, 2008, 10:47:06 PM


obviously one is played by adam jones & the other is played by buzz, which one?



How is that obvious? You may be correct but couldn't they both be Buzz? Any live versions I've heard without Adam sound about the same.
Rectum? Damn near killed 'im!

norecess

I agree with Branch Breaker, I also don't see how it is obvious that Buzz plays one riff and Adam Jones plays the other.

ManWithNoName

I can never tell what adam does on any of the releases he's appeared on. It's better that way. I don't want to know.

rictus

I always assumed Adam just did sort of lead/fill-in stuff here and there. I always thought Buzz did the guitar and the bass on that track. Buzz is credited with playing bass on that album too, isn't he?

Uncle Fester

track 3 "Toadi Acceleratio" to me sounds like adam jones allthroughout the song.

ninigiku

Quote from: rictus on April 14, 2008, 11:54:27 AM
I always assumed Adam just did sort of lead/fill-in stuff here and there. I always thought Buzz did the guitar and the bass on that track. Buzz is credited with playing bass on that album too, isn't he?

so does buzz, that bassline in the 2nd guitar part definitely sounds like buzz on the bass yeah.

i assumed that since adam is listed as a band-member, it is possible that track 4 is the result of a jam session between buzz & adam.
kind of like on divorced where dale crover & danny carey were switching off on the drums, this could be kind of like that, except with an endlessly repeating guitar riff each.

i can usually recognize adam's guitar tone, (you can hear it on Toadi Acceleratio) and the 1st endlessly repeating riff sounds like something adam would have come up with, plus it sounds more like rutmanis on the bass.
so the 2nd riff is buzz on the bass for sure, and the guitar doesn't even sound like adam's style at all.


sarcalogos solus redemptor

Metalhead Cow

I always just assumed it was Buzz playing both those riffs on the title track

glen

and I loosely quote the great Buzz Osborne when I say:

"we purposely did not claim who played what and where on the album so the listener would not know what was ours, what was lustmord's, what was adam's, etc.     I lot of the parts you think are MELVINS are actually lustmord.   we also prefer to keep a mystery around who is playing guitar where."

thats a loose quote but you get the point Buzz was trying to make.   
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

FartLips



adam is the one on far right and second from left. :wink:

edit: the rest are buzzo.
Judy is mad.🤣

OfficerButtcrack

Lustmord is probably playing those riffs  :shock: