The Trilogy

Started by The Piss-Machine, March 11, 2004, 07:06:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

The Piss-Machine

So here's the deal; I'm in the opening stages of writing a paper for this pop culture analysis class. I'm trying to develop a thesis based around the Trilogy, my argument being that the whole thing is just a huge rejection of everything. Meaning, convention, you name it and they give it the finger, so to speak.
Think about it; The Maggot, it's close to something that you might expect from the Melvins, except that the tracks are divided arbitrarily, each song blends into the next in some sense (noise segue, etc.) and 'what you might expect' from the Melvins isn't necessarily conventional anyways.
  The Bootlicker: Total head fuck. 'Let it all be' has a bridge consisting of a bunch of rumblings in between to almost completely different tunes and we we is something that you don't here very often...Furthermore, the whole album acts as a kind of acid mutation of pop formula.
  The Crybaby: it's fucked. What is the psychology behind presenting the fans with a final chapter in a trilogy wherein all the songs are written and/or sung by people outside the band...
   Either way, there's something going on with the trilogy; I want to argue that it's some kind of cancerous wart on the history of rock music, a rejection of coherency. This is all in response to my lame-ass teacher lecturing on the significance and 'world-view' expressed in Don Maclean's 'American Pie'.
   Thus the proposal is this; what is the general take on the Melvins' Trilogy? What were other people's impressions of this pretentious beast? And what exactly is a 'Jew Boy Flower Head'?

alnis

First off, you'll definately want to check out the artwork for the triple LP picture disc vinyl release of the trilogy. It's not exactly fit for "pop culture".

Is the trilogy a rejection of pop culture? Hmmm.....I don't think it could be identified with that, and I think it would be harmful to claim that. The melvins (and the triligy) don't define themselves (itself) through rejection. That would be silly and empty (it is my impression that Marlyn Manson, for example, DOES seem to define himself as a rejection of pop culture, but I don't know much about MM...).

The melvins are always a double edged sword. The trilogy doesn't jive with pop culture, but it isn't encapsled as a rejection of pop culture either.

However, you can't pretend that the melvins just do what they want to do in a vacuum. Pop culture is an (negative) influence, one among many. I'm sure that part of why they do things is an intentional rejection of some standards, but an explanation (or description) that stops at the rejection misses something.

My point is that the if you're looking for some definate intent or messege behind the music of the melvins, be it in the trilogy or anything else, you'd be selling yourself (and the melvins) short by being picky-choosy with the facts that support your particular reification. It's more complicated (and interesting) than that.

[just my two cents]

Dr. Gonzo

First off you could make up whatever bullshit you want, because the professor is never gonna listen to the trilogy...

Secondly I once read this and am quite curious as to what the author meant:

BIDMOR@aol.com
Look guy, Mike or whatever, get on the bootlicker tip. I mean it's been out for a while now and it wouldn't be that hard to throw up a review. These two albums are fucking scary man. No one has mentioned the underlying concept yet but, my friend, there is indeed a concept. It's too horrifying to speak of in an open forum such as this, but there are some big clues as to what it's about,namely the hidden blurb at the end of the bootlicker. That's all I'm saying 'cause I value my existance, but try to see where I'm coming from. Listen to these albums repeatedly and maybe you shall see...maybe. manky? We'll just have to see what the crybaby's all about. All in good time


it's a user review from: http://markprindle.com/melvinsa.htm#boot

I think he's an idiot, but if there is some secret meaning I must find out!

blacksanta

What about the redundency theory of Art?

Just kidding. But seriously, are either of you two (Alnis, P machine) philosophy students/majors? I'm in my Junior year.

Blacksanta
Also melvins is gay cuz some of their songs are just noise, i tell you this so you all don't buy albums and find out only one two songs is good on them.

anaconda

talk is one thing but action is more direct
i live my philosophy thru my actions not
my thoughts. though i have arrived here only after
abandoning my mindset and living in actualities,
travelling the physical and mental of the globe
and rocking thineself to the fullest.

in sincerity  8)

anaconda

p.s.

the markprindle.com site is the most amazing thing.
thats the first site i ever went to on the internet

brian

postmodernist thinkers tend to belive that it is impossible to reject pop culture, i would definitely agree with this.  i'm too busy with schoolwork to delve deeper into this although i'd like to.  the trilogy could in fact be a futile attempt by the melvins to brush off consumer society, unfortunately they haven't ever been able to do this, even with colossus of destiny, the supposed fourth piece of the trilogy.  i think the main problem with this is the confusion on the true definition of pop culture, sorry to break the news but everyone here is a part of it, they live it and breath it every day, you're no less of a consumer by wearing a melvins shirt than mary sue is who wears her marilyn manson shirt or whatever the case may be.

The Piss-Machine

If not rejection then commentary? I'm going to try to attack this from one of two angles; I understand the idea of the harm in rejection, but if I'm not entirely off-base then there are some kind of reactions going on here. Whether we're looking at some kind of implicit commentary or whether it's vanity (as what i see as I kind of rejection) there is a reason why these albums were presented in such a sequence and the content was presented as it is.
 When I listen to the Crybaby, I immeadietly think narcissisim insofar as this is not an appeal to any sort of audience. Rather, the album wasn't made for us, it was made for them. While I'm positive that most of the Melvins' catalog was written without any sort of hope for a breakout, the Crybaby is basically a collection of songs created with the help of people the band admires and respects, taste of the fans be damned. That's alienation; that's a willfull lack of concern for what the reception will be like.
This is why I say 'rejection'; there's value to these things, but it seems as though it's a deeply personal kind of value, like the Melvins have some secrets that they really don't want to let anyone in on. The songs aren't crafted in such a way as to promote an understanding between the band and their audience, rather, the meaning is held in a vacuum and the attitude towards the audience is "if you want, come along".
It's like self-determined isolation on the part of the artist. This is why I associate it with an abhorence for convention and popular culture. Obviously there are certain conventions inside of which these songs operate, but the use of such has a sarcastic quality. They're laughing at us.
This opposed to what seems a trend in popular culture; the appeal to public consciousness. Hence, rejection.

brian

i agree with what you're saying to an extent but you must ask yourself if the possibility of the melvins losing the majority of their fanbase due to the release of the crybaby would change their minds as to whether or not they would release it.  They are capitalists to an extent, they live within a means that they have deemed comfortable for themselves, just as i assume britney spears has done, if she were to have released an album similar to say the melvins prick she would most certainly become a laughing stock and lose the majority of her fanbase in the process therefore ending the lifestyle in which she has become accustomed to.  the sad thing about art is that it always holds the hand of economics even though it may seem as though it is behind it's own back.

deadstone75

you guys are smoking too much dope, man.

GrimReaper

Post a copy of your analysis when it's done, we'd like to read it.

alnis

Quote from: anacondathe markprindle.com site is the most amazing thing.

Mark Prindle is hilarious. Good place to go when you're bored.

Quote from: Dr. GonzoI think he's an idiot, but if there is some secret meaning I must find out!

I believe the thery circulating about the hidden messege of the trilogy was that it was all about nirvana...the maggot was Courtney Love, the Bootlicker was...um...I dunno, and the crybaby was Kurt Cobain. But that seems pretty silly.

Quote from: blacksantaare either of you two (Alnis, P machine) philosophy students/majors? I'm in my Junior year.

I'm currently finishing up my BA in philosophy/religious studies. And wondering whether I should go to grad school. I'm getting pretty sick of it at this point. I need a break...more action, less thought. Which leads to the next thing....

Quote from: anacondatalk is one thing but action is more direct
i live my philosophy thru my actions not my thoughts

Sounds like you thought about that;) Nothing wrong with action, nothing wrong with thinking. They're both healthy.

Quote from: anaconda...rocking thineself to the fullest

I like that philosophy!

Quote from: The Piss-MachineIf not rejection then commentary? I'm going to try to attack this from one of two angles; I understand the idea of the harm in rejection, but if I'm not entirely off-base then there are some kind of reactions going on here.

There definately seems to be reactions. Commentary seems to sit better than rejection.

Quote from: The Piss-MachineWhether we're looking at some kind of implicit commentary or whether it's vanity (as what i see as I kind of rejection) there is a reason why these albums were presented in such a sequence and the content was presented as it is.

Yah, I'm sure a lot of thinking went into the trilogy. But I think it may be less deep then you're implying. There seems to be two levels of talking about this. The first involves asking what the intentions of the melvins were. What did they want to accomplish? Why? How? The second level involves the things that made the melvins have these intentions. What external pressures formed their intentions. THe former level seems to be conscious, and the second level is unconscious. There seems to be a danger of conflating the two.

Maybe I'm off. These are just some ideas that occurred to me.

Quote from: The Piss-MachineWhen I listen to the Crybaby, I immeadietly think narcissisim insofar as this is not an appeal to any sort of audience. Rather, the album wasn't made for us, it was made for them. While I'm positive that most of the Melvins' catalog was written without any sort of hope for a breakout, the Crybaby is basically a collection of songs created with the help of people the band admires and respects, taste of the fans be damned. That's alienation; that's a willfull lack of concern for what the reception will be like.
This is why I say 'rejection'; there's value to these things, but it seems as though it's a deeply personal kind of value, like the Melvins have some secrets that they really don't want to let anyone in on. The songs aren't crafted in such a way as to promote an understanding between the band and their audience, rather, the meaning is held in a vacuum and the attitude towards the audience is "if you want, come along".

The crybaby does seem a little narcissistic. (It's my least favourite (so-called) "Melvins" album by far). But as to the melvins' concern for whether thier fans would like it, this is my hypothesis (and I think it applies to pretty much any melvins album). The melvins want to make what they think is good music. "Good music" is a complicated concept, and probably means different things for the melvins (and their individual members) and for everyone else. Insofar as "good music" shouldn't alienate thier fanbase, they don't want to alienate thier fanbase. From interviews with them I get the impression that they think they make good music, and if other people don't agree, then they can go listen to something else.

Quote from: The Piss-MachineThey're laughing at us.

The melvins laugh at/with everything!:)

(except for people who don't like COD...heh heh heh)

Dave

Whoa! Yiggity Yiggity Yah Yah!

Perhaps this will seem like an under-analysis to some of you trip-ticks, but I always saw the trilogy as an expression of The Melvins "up to" that point.

Briefly, the Maggot expresses their heavier side (with whatever deep connotations you can construct with that vague description) , the Bootlicker expresses their lighter side (" "), and I see The Crybaby as an expression of the fact that music, ideas, developments in general, etc., etc. are always a collaboration of some sort in some way.

I think the trilogy was a good way for them to sum up themselves thus far, while taking themselves further... a good way to end the millenium.


Bootlicka Kicks serious dong!!
"There is no exquisite beauty without some strangeness in the proportion."

- Lord Verulam

wonk-eye

all of these ponderances are meerly semantic shenanigans and buffoonery, we (as in the 'illuminati') all know that 'the melvins' is really just an entity created for tax shelter purposes so that second-rate colombian crack whores can launder their money in a safe, drug conducive culture. So every couple a years they 'crank' another one out just to keep up appearances.
also while we're on the subject.... this whole trilogy business stinks of messianic subtext and otherwise subversively encrypted religious themes. In fact, if you play the bootlicker backwards, you will uncover a secret text which when cross-referenced with both the necronicon and the egyptian book of the dead (the one sanctioned by Aleister Crowley) will reveal the exact time and date that the alien (though they may be just lesser demons) will invade (if you don't believe me, just reading any 'news' posting on the toolband website). The trilogy then is eschatological (perhaps millenial, but definetely post-modern(!)) attempt to convert 'rock' into a viable means of subverting the prevailing reality all the while simultaneously upholding what is traditionally accepted as a credible, indie-rock facade.



(et in arcadia ego....and so on) -w.e. <---the royal 'w.e.' you know the editorial....

idiotboy

Quote from: The Piss-MachineSo here's the deal; I'm in the opening stages of writing a paper for this pop culture analysis class. I'm trying to develop a thesis based around the Trilogy, my argument being that the whole thing is just a huge rejection of everything. Meaning, convention, you name it and they give it the finger, so to speak.

the melvins are very conventional in a lot of ways:

the instruments they play
the long 10 minute song at the end of albums
big, dumb, loud guitar riffs
quiet moody ballads occasionally interspersed (showing thier sensitive side)
...

The rejection you talk of is more of a 'twisting' of rock/metal conventions.

However - I do see a rejection with Prick - a rejection of what the band see as being wrong with the music/rock industry - the mombius hibachi video shows 'planet metalhead' (a sarcastic take on the excesses of the rock/metal industry) - the honeybucket video shows the crowd as sheep - in interviews the band often talks about the lack of talent other successful bands have - the crapness of thier music - and the stupidity of thier fans. This is the rebellion of the melvins - a rebellion against a music industry that is slave to a mass audience for which it produces the same old crap - time after time -  a rebellion against the lack of creativity that this entails.

I also see a rejection of the 'spirit of rock and roll' in buzzo's use of the nazi swastika - perhaps this is yet another way of alienating a mass audience all to keen to 'give peace a chance' and to reject any and all forms of prejudice. Dont most rock/punk bands today buy into that kind of 'freedom from all forms of prejudice' type carry on - even shit like lynkin park.