Did Kurt rip off buzz?

Started by nightgoat1, November 23, 2006, 03:30:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

nightgoat1

Has anyone ever noticed that the riff in nirvana's "Milk It"" off of in utero is the same exact bassline to "It's shoved" off of Bullhead? Just an interesting observation...

CaptainPungent

yeah, i think that's been said before.

good observation, probably true - unintentionally or not (perhaps he thought he made it up but it actually came from how many times he's listened to shoved).

The Fool

isn't there something about that in neither here nor there?
take care,
The Fool

AaronNi

It's in there somewhere near the back of the book The Fool.  It "Could" be a coincidence though, I know I've started playing a new riff only to hear it somewhere soon afterwards and remember it.  Hard to be original on the guitar anymore....
Earth first, make Mars our bitch!

feelmytool

It can be original if you put yourself into it.
if life is a dream in the imagination of ourselves, and there is no such thing as death, then what does waking up mean?

anaconda


Chomas

what about "spank thru" being a huge ripoff of "matt-alec"?  there does seem to be a pattern here... :-k

anaconda

and the killing joke riff and lotsa shit,
its called influence, its not a conscious theft

MailOrderBride

If you want to hear a rip off, and one acknowledged actually to a degree go listen to A Hole In The Wallet by Gang Of Four...Tipping The Lion lifts the opening bass line and drum part as well.

The Fool

Quote from: MailOrderBride on November 23, 2006, 11:54:33 PM
If you want to hear a rip off, and one acknowledged actually to a degree go listen to A Hole In The Wallet by Gang Of Four...Tipping The Lion lifts the opening bass line and drum part as well.

yeah i have an old show where dale said they ripped the intro off from a gang of four record before they play tipping the lion.
he even says which track and on which side of the record it is.

take care,
The Fool

norecess

Quote from: The Fool on November 23, 2006, 06:54:56 PM
isn't there something about that in neither here nor there?

It's in the story of Nick something, the guy from Soda magazine. Same goes for Come As You Are being a rip-off of Eighties by Killing Joke.

Rembrandt Pussyhorse

Smells like Teen Spirit = Boston's More Than A Feeling  :lol:
I could catch a monkey

klump

Quote from: The Fool on November 24, 2006, 01:48:39 AM
Quote from: MailOrderBride on November 23, 2006, 11:54:33 PM
If you want to hear a rip off, and one acknowledged actually to a degree go listen to A Hole In The Wallet by Gang Of Four...Tipping The Lion lifts the opening bass line and drum part as well.

yeah i have an old show where dale said they ripped the intro off from a gang of four record before they play tipping the lion.
he even says which track and on which side of the record it is.



could you post that one?

Its all about context.
Everyone does it, but sometimes the similarities are too obvious.
its a fine line...

I hear The Melvins stuff in ZZ Top too, but its a total different context.

Mad Arab

Especially ZZ Top. I can totally understand why they covered Nasty Dogs and Funky Kings.

meanclown

yeah..i suppose you could make the argument that you can imagine Steve Howe's guitar riff from "Starship Trooper" (the "Wurm" section at the end) being played over the chords to "Heart Shaped Box" too...that has to be the most beaten-to-death three-chord progression in the history of R & R !  :lol: