We Reach (Melvins tribute) reviewed at mxdwn.com

Started by doomsayer, September 25, 2005, 08:26:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

doomsayer

mxdwn has reviewed the new Melvins tribute "We Reach - The Music of the Melvins"

http://www.mxdwn.com/article.php?sid=522

:D

mattyboyfloyd

i just picked this up while i was in nyc. fuckin' awesome! a nice teaser while i wait for the new album, and for the melvins to rock the east coast yet again!

Vcavallo

Vinney "only takes 15 years to make good on his promises" Cavallo

bUTTHOLEmAN

if you CALL ME ON MY CELLY
i'll LET YOU RUB ME BELLY!


"I can push over twelve year old girls easy." - Fart
kill yr idols
emperors wear no clothes
"We don't have alot of information right now, but for all we know monkeys might fly out of my butt"- rictus

klump

I have a review for you : I listened to it, and it stunk.
Actually it blowed.
And sucked.

:lol:

GrimReaper

Klump, what happened to the friendly old Klump from back in the day? There are some shameful attempts at the Melvins on this release but I think it's all good.

There is a lot of positive stuff on the We Reach release. I just had it in today as a matter of fact. Epony's cover of Oven made me think of that and the Chanting of the Priests covers which i've never heard anything positive about, but I like it. Does anyone have a copy besides me?

Shevil by Meatjack is what I wanted to revisit thanks to Epony's Oven. And it is good. The Claude cover has some great guitar work. Mastadon covers the Bit on the We Reach.

I think the Melvins.net Tribute will be awesome when it comes out. What song are you going to cover Klump?

norecess

Mastodon played The Bit on that video that was posted a while back as well. It's the only Melvins cover they have done. I also have an exellent mp3 of them covering Esmeralda by Thin Lizzy btw.

GrimReaper


Yeah how could I forget him holding up four fingers and then making a "t"?

glen

speaking from a non-mastodon's fan point of view, I thought it was surprisingly good.  strange to hear a first-track off an album being covered though.  that doesn't happen too often.
"Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care." - Richie Goodtimes

Glen. You can totally go fuck yourself. I have no idea who you are and I really don't care.
(signed) MAYNARD  JAMES  KEENAN

klump

I think it was good that Mastodon covered The Bit instead of just stealing the riff like norwegian band the Cumshots did on their first record.

I like the Cumshots, but I thought that was a bit sleazy...
check out their song  "No nothing please die" to hear it yourself.
They covered "Hooch", but I didnt like it.
It sounds a bit like Mastodons cover of The Bit...Too metal.

If they would have gone crazy with it, it would have been fun.

but what the hell, I think what Turbonegro (and all the Turbonegro wannabe bands) are worse...
ALL of their stuff is ripped directly from Alice Cooper, Ramones , Dead Boys and Poison Idea....(in that order).
Riffs,lyrics, melodies EVERYTHING.

norecess

http://www.yousendit.com/download/zSI%2BpHObYZc%3D

This track, Scoop by Circle, off their 1994 debut Meronia, has a riff that slightly reminds me of The Bit.

mopafeena

Quote from: norecess on September 29, 2006, 11:27:56 AM
Mastodon played The Bit on that video that was posted a while back as well. It's the only Melvins cover they have done. I also have an exellent mp3 of them covering Esmeralda by Thin Lizzy btw.

Wasn't it Emerald?
www.myspace.com/mopafeena
www.myspace.com/afeenaband

norecess

Quote from: mopafeena on September 30, 2006, 02:57:23 AM
Quote from: norecess on September 29, 2006, 11:27:56 AM
Mastodon played The Bit on that video that was posted a while back as well. It's the only Melvins cover they have done. I also have an exellent mp3 of them covering Esmeralda by Thin Lizzy btw.

Wasn't it Emerald?

D'oh!

Buick GN

So...I brought this thread back up. 

I was thinking of purchasing this tribute cd.

I'd really like to hear the DEP, EHG and Mast. covers.

Does it really blow as Klump says?

FartLips

Quote from: Buick GN on December 13, 2006, 07:49:04 PM
So...I brought this thread back up. 

I was thinking of purchasing this tribute cd.

I'd really like to hear the DEP, EHG and Mast. covers.

Does it really blow as Klump says?
download it first.
Judy is mad.🤣