Melvins vs Tomahawk

Started by turnacus, July 16, 2003, 11:43:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 25 Guests are viewing this topic.

turnacus

Van Hagar


Anonymous

:)  just shut up and moderate, don't participate you nerd

Goldi

Damn, what a stupid question, you can't compare Melvins and Tomahawk, that's like you would compare a hamburger with spaghetti.  :D

i would say, both are great, but Tomahawk is more like "take the cd, listen to it and then put it away for some month because it gets boring"
For me it's like that, I could listen to the Melvins 24/7.

mantra

Tomahawk kicks ass.  But Melvins are just way better.

Swagger

There was a period of about 12 months where I listened to a Melvins album everyday. I liked the first Tomahawk record quite a bit. I've listened to Mit Gas about three times and it is now collecting dust.

I have seen the Melvins live about 8 or 9 times and they have always put on an incredible show. I always leave feeling as if I have gotten my moneys worth. I have seen Tomahawk play three times. 1 time they were pretty blah, 1 time they were amazing, and 1 time they were just decent.

So I guess in my battle of the bands I would have to declare Melvins victorious.

Ed

It just comes down to the fact that the Melvins dominate live.

mantra

Quote from: EdIt just comes down to the fact that the Melvins dominate live.

That is very true.

Beto Brasil

T H E    M E L V I N S !

F o r e v e r.
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

GrimReaper

I'm still wondering why the Melvins didn't headline the Geek Show Tour.

CausesUnknown

I like em both. I like the Melvins better however. I had the opprotunity to see them 5 times this year.
NYE
California tour with Adam Jones, Altamont opening
Both Geek show dates in SF
and now I'll get to see them 8/9 in SF again.

I hope they get around to a NYE show in SF again, so it'll be 6 times. :D

BuzzBorn

Hard question! both realse some of the best music getting realsed today!

mobmob

Quote from: BuzzBornHard question! both release some of the best music getting realsed today!
there are hundreds of great bands around, check out the "what are YOU
listening to..." threads to get a wider picture. i could name dozens of bands
which i like more than tomahawk, but yeah only a few that are comparable
with the mighty melvins (residents for example!) :twisted:

Rembrandt Pussyhorse

tomahawk bores me. they just remind me of how much i miss the Jesus Lizard.
btw is it just me or does anybody think John Stanier is way overrated?
I could catch a monkey

mobmob

yeah that's exactly what i think when i'm listening to tomahawk...
jesus lizard was great, i own every release from them but i have to admit
that it get's very boring after you heard a half year nothing else than jesus
lizard... it's a little bit to repetitive but well, a thousand times better than
tomahawk anyway. i like stanier... he's alright