are / were melvins punk?

Started by zium, September 23, 2003, 04:05:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

zium

i had a little discussion about this with some dude from soulseek. I know the melvins are talking about their punk rock days, but still i don't think of them as a punk band. they don't sound punk and their attitude isn't very punk either, the only thing punk about the melvins are some of the bands that they were influenced by. i'm a really big fan of their old stuff and it sounds more like some form of metal instead of punk if you ask me

melvins have a unique sound tho, they can't really be placed in one of those big genres i guess. i think this is a positive thing btw, most 'punks' piss me off with their huge amounts of poserness, it's like they're all trying so very hard to fit the profile by wearing the right clothes, listening to the right music (read: the garbage the average candy punker listens to rancid, nofx, offspring etc.) and doing things that they consider to be punk

spud boy

It's just music, what genre it happens to fall into (or not) doesn't matter.

turnacuss

is punk a genre or an attitude.

huber

isn't punk derived from a 16th century word for prostitute?

klump

:D  , try listening to Flipper, the Cows, The Stooges, Zeke(even them!:)), The Wipers, etc etc...

rancid and nofx and all that other ska/california "punk" has ruined the meaning of the word punk...

but i dont think you should pigeonhole the melvins they are a bit in between:) a bit punk, metal,prog,psychedelia,avantgard,noise,jazz,blues,polka etc etc

genres are dead :D enjoy        :arrow:  :D

klump

they havent ruined the meaning, thewy are just real punks, hehe

Ed

The Melvins aren't punk. They're, like, major posers, man.

Heroin

The Melvins' attitude is totally punk!
Punk = Fuck the world
Jacksonville = most punk song ever

dirty joe

when i think of punk music, i think of stripped down and pretty simple songs, which i think really is a part of the melvins sound.  just raw shit. it don't matter how hard it is to play, it's the feeling and energy in the music.

Beto Brasil

Poser? POSER is you, loser !!

Quote from: EdThe Melvins aren't punk. They're, like, major posers, man.
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm

zium

Quote from: dirty joewhen i think of punk music, i think of stripped down and pretty simple songs, which i think really is a part of the melvins sound.  just raw shit. it don't matter how hard it is to play, it's the feeling and energy in the music.


imo melvins has pretty complex melody. It's easy to play on the guitar though, but most songs have a pretty weird structure

Ed


Anonymous

The melvins music is unique and is not one genre. However as far as their attitude and their approach towards music, they are punk as fuck. You don't have to wear spiky armbands and play three chords fast to be punk.the melvins dont give a shit, they play what they want.i respect  that

zee melvins

Quote from: EdStop posing, Beto.

Poser.

shut up, Beto is the shit, he has an accent and he types like he has an accent, thats so cool.

Beto Brasil

Quote from: zee melvins
Quote from: EdStop posing, Beto.

Poser.

shut up, Beto is the shit, he has an accent and he types like he has an accent, thats so cool.

thank you man i never forgot you for this, my Prof!
Trading music since 1999 :

Update : http://www.themelvins.net/beto/DVD.htm