melvins and SY

Started by Uncle Fester, June 28, 2008, 04:28:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Uncle Fester

all the interviews I have read on the melvins have never given me any clue to what the melvins have to say or think of SONIC YOUTH.
There must be something?! I mean They are similar in some ways. They both started out in approximatley the same year and both are still around making music. sonic youth and the melvins are both very talented bands that have re defined music. Such raw energy and versatility is expected when you listen to these two bands.
anybody have any info?


bathroom creep

Everything was beautiful, and nothing hurt.

Centripetal core of soul sojourn the field vibrates to absolution. I climb toward the sun to breathe the universal.

Have you seen the bridge?  I ain't seen the bridge!  Where's that confounded bridge?!

Mount Ambulance

I remember Buzz once when asked in an interview who he would "line up" a festival w/ & his answer consisted of: Melvins, Sonic Youth, & Napalm Death. He cited pretty much your logic on Sonic Youth ... 3 bands that are originators ... still in their own space ... doing their own thing in spite of the ears of the world. Probably read it here. Can't imagine where else?

I donno, Sonic Youth just kinda bores me these days ... good an' all & still got heaps of respect for 'em, but at this stage it just all sounds the same ... predictable SY. Not bad, but definatly not fresh ... including O'Rourke gave a boost for a minute or two but ... I listened to the newest? "Really Ripped" or something .... ehhh, never listened to it again ...

Hey Creep ... you beat me to the punch ... damn my long windedness!!

Uncle Fester

Quote from: Mount Ambulance on June 28, 2008, 05:35:39 PM
I remember Buzz once when asked in an interview who he would "line up" a festival w/ & his answer consisted of: Melvins, Sonic Youth, & Napalm Death. He cited pretty much your logic on Sonic Youth ... 3 bands that are originators ... still in their own space ... doing their own thing in spite of the ears of the world. Probably read it here. Can't imagine where else?

I donno, Sonic Youth just kinda bores me these days ... good an' all & still got heaps of respect for 'em, but at this stage it just all sounds the same ... predictable SY. Not bad, but definatly not fresh ... including O'Rourke gave a boost for a minute or two but ... I listened to the newest? "Really Ripped" or something .... ehhh, never listened to it again ...

Hey Creep ... you beat me to the punch ... damn my long windedness!!

that new album... yeah./.. i agree. I think they are well past their peaks now!

martyr

i remember thurston talking about how awesome the melvins were

Komar

I remember one interview where buzz said someting like "they sound too much like the velvet underground" or something like that.

yeah, their recent records sound very similar. Especially in terms of recording. I always liked the different vibes that you got from the early-mid 90`s stuff.  Maybe it has something to do with having their own studio.

still one of my all time favourites.  bad moon rising is just wonderful!

norecess

Quote from: martyr on June 29, 2008, 05:47:00 PM
i remember thurston talking about how awesome the melvins were

Doesn't surprise me.

"At one point, the Melvins were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, the Die Kreuzen were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, the Stooges were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, the Velvet Underground were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, Nirvana were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, Dinosaur Jr were the best band in the US!"
"At one point, Minor Threat were the best band in the US!"

The list goes on.

GrimReaper

Kim Gordon had a small part in a movie I just watched "Boarding Gate".

She is looking very old.

I wonder if she still thinks Cobain was murdered? :-k